Legal rights - winding up, Business Law and Ethics

Assignment Help:

Legal rights - Winding up:

In substance these two people are really partners" and by analogy with the law of partnership (which permits dissolution if the partners are really unable to work together) it was just and equitable to order liquidation.

(a) The members or directors are associated in the company on the basis of certain understandings but one (or more) exercises his legal rights against another in breach of those understandings with results which are unfair.  Such situations are sometimes referred to as a "fraud on the minority"

                                                  Case: EBRAHIM v. WESTBOURNE GALLERIES (1973)

E and N carried on business together for 25 years, originally as partners and for the last 10 years through a company in which each originally had 500 shares.  E and N were the first directors and shared the profits as directors' remuneration; no dividends were paid.  When N's son joined the business he became a third director and E and N each transferred 100 shares to N's son.  Eventually there were disputes: N and his son used their voting control in general meeting (600 votes against 400) to remove E from his directorship under the power of removal given by Companies Act 1948 s.184 (Kenya, s.185).  E sued to have the company wound up.

Held:

The company should be wound up.  N and his son were within their legal rights in removing E from his directorship but the past relationship made it "unjust or inequitable" to insist on legal rights and the court could intervene on equitable principles to order liquidation.  E's petition for relief on grounds of oppression of minority failed since he failed to make out a strong enough case for such relief.


Related Discussions:- Legal rights - winding up

Significance of registration, Significance of Registration:           ...

Significance of Registration:           S.389 provides that "no company or association or may partnership consisting of more than twenty persons shall be formed... except it i

Explain universal jurisdiction of criminal jurisdiction, Explain Universal ...

Explain Universal jurisdiction of criminal jurisdiction It is concerned with the application of a State's criminal jurisdiction in respect of offences committed against the int

All spark-producing devices, Mrs. Rusholme occupied the firm of Saunders an...

Mrs. Rusholme occupied the firm of Saunders and Watts to refinish floors in assured rooms of a home owned by her and her husband in Red Deer, Alberta. She told Mr. Saunders that sh

Enumerate about the short-run phillips curve, Enumerate about the short-run...

Enumerate about the short-run Phillips curve Diagrammatically the short-run Phillips curve becomes flatter under coordination as opposed to no coordination. If one country expa

Liability based definition of phoenix activity, Q. Liability based definiti...

Q. Liability based definition of phoenix activity? The definition used by Treasury, and used as a working definition for this project, focuses on the intent with which phoenix

Recovery of premium - s. 44, Recovery of Premium - S. 44 One partner h...

Recovery of Premium - S. 44 One partner has paid a premium for another on entering in a partnership to a fixed term such and the partnership is dissolved previous to the expir

Explain self determination, Explain Self determination Self determinat...

Explain Self determination Self determination is actually the foundation of United Nations (UN) Charter. It is defined as a right of people to determine and to choose their ow

Explain ihl prohibitions, Important to observe that IHL prohibitions It...

Important to observe that IHL prohibitions It is important to  observe that  IHL prohibitions should be identified and followed as  their violations/breach may be considered as

Describe in detail about the european monetary union, Describe in detail ab...

Describe in detail about the European Monetary Union The experimental lab for international policy coordination has been the European Union where monetary unification of member

Business and company law, ali send an offer to bakar on 13/9/2010 by fax.on...

ali send an offer to bakar on 13/9/2010 by fax.on 14/9/2010 ali change his mind and revoke the offer by fax unfortunately bakar''s fax machine not working and ali call for bakar. b

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd