Cost benefit analysis-vat, Macroeconomics

(1) Based on the article, describe as best you can:

(i) the reference group for the cost benefit analysis,

(ii) the purpose of the study (i.e., what is the "project" in this case?), and

(iii) the estimated project life over which the project is evaluated.

Explain whether the cost benefit analysis is:

(iv) formative or summative;

(v) ex ante or ex post; and

(vi) social cost-benefit analysis or private cost-benefit analysis.

Explain or define your use of these terms and provide reasoning and evidence (if any) in support of your answers.

2. (a) Briefly describe the major categories of expected benefits and expected costs from undertaking the project, as explained by the authors.

(b) Explain how and where the value of human lives saved or lost might enter this analysis, and explain whether all of these effects are addressed in the article. If human lives are expected to be saved or lost, should some or all of the value of these be itemized separately in estimating Net Present Value, or would they already be incorporated in the measures of benefits and costs given in your answer to

Question 2(a)

3. (a) An important aspect of any cost benefit analysis is the choice of the counterfactual situation against which project benefits and gains are to be measured. Describe as clearly and succinctly as you can what you believe to be this counterfactual situation [i.e., the "without-project" case]. What is the relative increase in traffic volumes with relative increase in traffic volumes with the project as compared to the counterfactual situation?

How much larger (expressed as a multiple) is the volume of traffic using the tunnels (as projected by the authors) after 50 years compared to the first year of use?

(b) Explain clearly whether you agree with the authors' decision to treat the collected road tolls as a cost-reducing item. Support your answer with a diagram if this helps.

(c) Explain clearly whether you agree with the authors' decision to exclude the (VAT) taxes paid on the construction costs. Support your answer with a diagram if this helps.

4. (a) What discount rate do the authors use? (Specify whether it is real or nominal, and social or private.) Does it appear that the authors have calculated the Net Present Value using the so-called Harberger (SOCC) approach or the Marglin approach (STP-SPC)? Explain your answer.

(b) From the description of the project given in the article, prepare a short list of which members of society, that is, of the project reference group, would be relative winners and which would be relative losers if this project went ahead as described. [Your groups need not be mutually exclusive.]

5. (a) Explain by the use of reasoning or evidence, whether the NPV in Table 6 has been estimated using (i) the "domestic price approach," (ii) the "border price approach," or (iii) something else. If you would recommend some changes to the approach used, what would they be?

(b) In your answer to Question 1, you described the estimated project life over which the project is evaluated. What steps appear to have been taken by the author to capture any residual benefits or residual costs after this project life? What changes would you recommend to the approach used?

6. The value of land is not prominent as a cost or benefit described in the article.

(a) Suppose the government has to expropriate or purchase some land to situate the new highway routes, ramps, overpasses and so on. What conceptual approach or criterion should be used to value these lands for the purpose of this study?

(b) If acquired, should these land values be costs to the project (they would involve cash payouts); benefits to the project (the project's real estate holdings have increased); neither, or both? Explain.

7. Assume for the moment that all of the author's data-and all of the numerical calculations that employ the data-were correct and the best available for the 2010 study.

In your view-calculations aside-what are other major potential sources of inaccuracy, omission, or error which might make the net benefits of the project evaluated in this article be much higher or lower than estimated there? List three or four which might work in each direction. (Your answer may repeat some of the issues raised in other questions).

Posted Date: 3/9/2013 2:00:47 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Cost benefit analysis-vat, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Cost benefit analysis-vat, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Cost benefit analysis-vat Discussions

Write discussion on Cost benefit analysis-vat
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
If the price of DVD players decreases, we can expect that the demand for DVDs will: a. increase. b. be unaffected. c. shift left. d. Decrease

Q. Describe Exports and imports in AS-AD model? Exports and imports. This is more difficult to justify owing to exchange rate. Suppose that we have a flexible exchange rate a

Give your own example of "pseudoreplication" (sensu Hurlbert 1984) in an experiment. How does pseudoreplication cause problems for correct inferences from experiments?

what is the cause of inflation in PNG

The annual income from an apartment complex is $20,664. The annual expense is estimated to be $3,414. The apartment complex could be sold for $146,499 at the end of 10 years. If yo

why does the price level not enter desire consumption, investment and net exports of the desired aggregate expenditure function in the keynesian cross model

#questionKeynes liquidity Preference theory stipulates that money demand is negatively related to current income and positively related to interest rate..

Classical Quantity Theories Quantity theories have had a long history and a widespread use in economics. As originally formulated these were not explicitly designed as theories

If a nation were to experience an influx of foreign labor into the market for corn production, the production possibilities frontier for the nation would: a. shift inward due to

ACCOUNTING SYSTEM-EXAMPLE I  Consider a very simple economy. It consists of a. A number of households. b. A single productive organization, a 'firm' - say the Jam Corpora