Compute the optimal decision

Assignment Help HR Management
Reference no: EM13859814

Write a 1-page individual report on your virtual team activity. Answer the questions below in a Word document to submit it to the Drop Box.

Think back on the decision-making process that you and your team members went through in deciding the case of "State vs. Scroggs." Do you feel any of you used a rational decision-making model? As you explain, you might recall that rational decision-making goes through six steps:

Define the problem. (Did Scroggs do it or not?)
Identify decision criteria, etc.
Weight the criteria.
Generate alternatives.
Rate each alternative on each criterion.
Compute the optimal decision.

If no one followed this rational decision-making model exactly, did anyone follow even one of the steps - or some half way? As you explain, you might consider that you could have been using what we call bounded rationality? (That's where you satisfice - that is, you don't follow such a rigorous model, but rather you seek solutions that are merely satisfactory.) In bounded rationality, you use some rationality, but you are not completely disciplined about it.

Case Study: State vs. Scroggs

In the fall of 1875, Hiram Smith filed a claim on a very fertile piece of land in South Dakota with the land office. Before he could make any improve­ments on the land, he died. A young Swede, newly immigrated, filed a counterclaim to the land at once, and by late spring of the following year, he had built a home and had begun to cultivate the land.

In the meantime the widow of the original claimant was on her way West with her two daughters and her son, Hiram, Jr. She built a house on the land, across a ravine from the Swede's home, and cultivated that half of the claim. Both parties sent their claims to the Department of the Interior, but ten years went by without a decision. Both the Swede and Mrs. Smith built barns and cultivated the land intensively each on their own side of the ravine.

A distant relative of Mrs. Smith, a clergyman named Rev. Wilbur Scroggs, lived in a small town about two miles from the rival farms. He had been an advisor for the Swede on all matters of religion and politics since the fellow had first taken up farming in Dakota.
He had often complimented the Swede on his land and had expressed his opinion at the general store that it was the best land in the West.

Wilbur Scroggs had acted as arbiter for the disputants and had corresponded with the Secretary of the Interior in regard to the land. One day at the general store he told the Swede that he thought the Swede's claim would be supported. The Swede swore that no one was going to put him off the land.

The next day Scroggs went to the Smith farm and showed Mrs. Smith a paper from Washington , D.C. , ratifying her claim to the land. He said it would be all right for them to take possession of the entire claim. Young Hiram Smith, Jr. hitched a team to the plow and went over on to the Swede's side of the farm. Scroggs, Mrs. Smith, and the two daughters went along, with Scroggs on his horse. Young Hiram, Jr. had just started plowing when the Swede ran out of his house with a gun and shot him.

Two more shots killed the horses at the plow. Scroggs galloped off and shouted that he was going after the marshal. When the marshal and a posse arrived, they found the Swede had killed the three women and had then committed suicide. Rev. Scroggs, being the only relative of the dead woman, would stand to inherit both pieces of land.

The marshal, who was very familiar with the case, confronted Rev. Scroggs. "I place you under arrest, Sir, for inciting these murders. You are innocent until proven guilty under the law. But you must go to trial.

Reference no: EM13859814

Questions Cloud

View of responsibility for unemployment : Explain the relationship between one's beliefs about whether the minimum jobs program presented in the chapter actually solves the unemployment problem and one's normative view of responsibility for unemployment.
Urban community that exceeds the emissions standard : Assume that two power plants, Firm 1 and Firm 2, release arsenic in a small urban community that exceeds the emissions standard. To meet the standard, 40 units of SO2 must be abated in total. The two firms face the following abatement costs:
What are the pros and cons of a competitive market : 1) Assume a competitive market has firms earning large economic profits. What is expected to happen over time in this competitive market and to firm's profits?2) What are the pros and cons of a competitive market in the long run?
Determine ownership of the funds that had been in accounts : Determine the ownership of the funds that had been in the accounts. In what form of ownership were the accounts held? Who is entitled to which of the funds and why?
Compute the optimal decision : Think back on the decision-making process that you and your team members went through in deciding the case of "State vs. Scroggs." Do you feel any of you used a rational decision-making model? Compute the optimal decision
The principles of keeping things simple : An effort to stick with the principles of keeping things simple, I found that collaboration is a cooperative arrangement in which two or more parties, which may or may have not had a previous relationship, work jointly towards a common goal (Business..
The mitigation methods to overcome these potential problems : the mitigation methods to overcome these potential problems in the education industry
Briefly summarize the history of smartphones : Briefly summarize the history of smartphones. How has the increased presence of smartphones changed the way people access information
Which can be categorized as host ids and network ids : which can be categorized as Host IDS and Network IDS

Reviews

Write a Review

 

HR Management Questions & Answers

  Incorporation under treasury stock method

Using a fair value option pricing model, total compensation expense is determined to be $1,800. Wine exercised his option on October 1, 2010 and sold his 400 shares on December 1, 2010. Quoted market prices of Ellison Co. stock in 2010 were

  Engage in counterproductive behaviors

There will be times when employees disregard policies and procedures or otherwise engage in counterproductive behaviors.

  Three sociological perspectives

Compare the differences among the three major theoretical perspectives in sociology (structural-functionalism, conflict theory, and symbolic interactionism). With which theory and theorist do you find that you share similar views with and why?

  Description of unfair labor practicesfor a number of years

description of unfair labor practicesfor a number of years union membership has been steadily declining except in

  Technology in the pm process and best practicesdiscussion 1

technology in the pm process and best practicesdiscussion 1 technology in the pm process1. from the e-activity

  Integrate the learning of the organizational behavior

The reflection assignment should be 500-600 words reflecting on what you have learned in this course, determine the implications (the so what or why did this material matter) for you as a present or future manager. Also, I would value the feedback on..

  Self-managed teams compensation management prosconsa hot

self-managed teams compensation management prosconsa hot topic in organizations is the development and use of teams

  Human resourcesimagine you are working in a human resources

human resourcesimagine you are working in a human resources department. you are asked to put together a program to

  Describe the nature of the organization

Question 1: Describe the nature of the organization (provide industry, product/service, a brief history, and position in relation to competition)

  Major components of an executive compensation plan

Explain the major components of an executive compensation plan, and discuss the effect reverse discrimination has had on the design of these executive compensation plans.

  Define and discuss design for six sigma dfss and four

define and explain design for six sigma dfss and the four principal activities in a 2-3 page paper using apa format for

  Evaluate the planning function of management

Evaluate the planning function of management as it relates to the organization's goals and strategies. Use steps in the planning process outlined in the text.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd