Standardise the counter-argument, English

Assignment Help:

Standardise the following argument/counter-argument, and state whether any premises on the same level are linked or convergent. Include any counter considerations.

Some commentators are saying that the stalking tackle should be banned from rugby league because it is unfair if a player is incapacitated and still open to attack as this places players unfairly at risk of injury.  However, the traditionalist's say that although some players might get injured, the tackle shouldn't be banned since rugby league is a team sport, so incapacitating an opponent in tackles for your team mates is a fair part of the game.  Also, they claim that if you are worried about injuries you shouldn't be playing rugby league in the first place. 

Target Argument: (Some commentators)

1.1 Being incapacitated and still open to attack places players unfairly at risk of injury

1. It is unfair if a player is incapacitated and still open to attack

C. The stalking tackle should be banned from rugby league

Counterargument: (Traditionalists)

[cc] Although some players might get injured

1.1 Rugby league is a team sport

1.    Incapacitating an opponent in tackles for your team mates is a fair part of the game [x1]

2.    If you are worried about injuries you shouldn't be playing rugby league in the first place

C.   The tackle shouldn't be banned

Premises 1 and 2 of the counterargument are convergent.


Related Discussions:- Standardise the counter-argument

Essay, Samuel Johnson (2013) highlights the importance of the Archangel Mic...

Samuel Johnson (2013) highlights the importance of the Archangel Michael’s prophecy and its connection with what he calls “the great action” in Milton''s Paradise Lost (see page 13

Genres of creative writing, Genres of Creative Writing In some ways, it...

Genres of Creative Writing In some ways, it makes no sense to speak of creative writing in terms of categories. In the first place, all writing is creative. And you might creat

Mother, I wrote a narrative essay but I need to know how to improve it

I wrote a narrative essay but I need to know how to improve it

What is prewriting, Prewriting Introduction to the Writing Process T...

Prewriting Introduction to the Writing Process The writing process is a systematic approach to writing that can help you to achieve your writing goals. From prewriting throu

Revising, I need help revising a document that I am writing

I need help revising a document that I am writing

Explain the historical background to the catcher in the rye, Explain the Hi...

Explain the Historical Background to The Catcher in the Rye The Catcher in the Rye is more than just a story of one alienated teenager trying to make sense of his life.  It is

Direct to indirect speech, change this in indirect speech.... 1.the young s...

change this in indirect speech.... 1.the young scientist said,''''things weight slightly less at the poles than at the equator.''''

MARU, From the reading of maru,show how the masarwa faces discrimination

From the reading of maru,show how the masarwa faces discrimination

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd