Realization of auditors, Business Law and Ethics

Assignment Help:

Realization of Auditors:

it is a mere truism to say that the value of loans and securities depends on their realization.  We were told that a statement to that effect, is so unusual in an auditor's certificate that the mere presence of those words was enough to excite suspicion.  But, as already stated, the duty of an auditor might infer from an unusual statement that something was seriously wrong, it with no means follows that ordinary people would have their suspicion aroused by a similar statement, whether as in this case, there its language expresses no more than any ordinary person would infer without.....the balance sheet and profit and loss account being true and correct in the sense that they were in accordance with the books.  But they were, nevertheless, entirely misleading, and misrepresented the real position of the company.  Under these circumstances I am compelled to hold that Mr. Theobald failed to discharge his duty to the shareholders...  Possibly he did not realize the extent of his duty to the shareholders as distinguished from the directors, and he unfortunately consented to leave the Chairman to explain the true state of the company to the shareholders instead of doing so himself. 

The fact, however, remains, and cannot be got over, that the balance sheet and certificate of February 1892 did not show the true position of the company at the end of 1891, and that this was owing to the omission by the auditor to lay before the shareholders the material information which he had obtained in the course of his employment as auditor of the company, and to which he called the attention of the directors....  Where did the money come from with which the dividends were paid?  The money came from cash at the bankers or in hand; but this cash could not be properly treated as profit, and the directors and auditors knew this perfectly well...."


Related Discussions:- Realization of auditors

Discuss the role of policy maker, Discuss the role of policy maker A po...

Discuss the role of policy maker A policy maker, who focuses mainly on the possibility of remaining in the office, faces different set of incentives in choosing policy. He trie

Appeals - court-martial, Appeals - Court-Martial In fact in Section 11...

Appeals - Court-Martial In fact in Section 115 of the Armed Forces Act including a person who has been convicted through a court-martial to appeal to the High Court either aga

Explain the second theory of international antitrust, Explain the second th...

Explain the second theory of international antitrust cooperation A second theory of international antitrust cooperation is a more limited multilateral approach under which only

Domestic or family agreements - elements of contract, Domestic or Family Ag...

Domestic or Family Agreements - Elements of Contract However there is a rebuttable presumption such the parties did not intend for create legal relations as: 1. Agreements

Explain the fundamental causesof inertia, Explain the fundamental causesof ...

Explain the fundamental causesof inertia The fundamental causes of such 'inertia' which are reflected in, besides other factors, in inaction and delays. The theory must also be

How much damages should be awarded, X Co. is a retail dealer of garden trac...

X Co. is a retail dealer of garden tractors. Mr. Y signs a contract to buy a garden tractor for $400 but later backs out of the agreement. The tractor that Y agreed to buy is subse

Ostensible authority - authority of partners, Ostensible Authority - Author...

Ostensible Authority - Authority of Partners A difference is something drawn among the genuine and ostensible authority about a partner. Whether it is actual or express author

Discuss alternative dispute resolution, QUESTION 1 Nowadays, many peopl...

QUESTION 1 Nowadays, many people are opting for Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) as a means to settle commercial disputes due to its advantages. Discuss QUESTION 2

Business law , Explain whether Mike should be excused from not performing u...

Explain whether Mike should be excused from not performing under the contract with Jim: Facts Mike ran an excavation business whereby he was contracted by builders to use his exca

International financial crime , During the first lecture students asked for...

During the first lecture students asked for some assessments topics to guide them in the decisions that they need to take. Please note that: 1   Students may still formulate the

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd