Operational research, Corporate Finance

Assignment Help:

Fisher and Raman (1996), Fisher et al. (2001) propose to let a number of experts within a company estimate the demand for a product. The demand is calculated as the average of the experts' estimates. The method is straightforward and very applicable for the speci?c company that we consider. Indeed, both Fisher and Raman (1996), Fisher et al. (2001) also proposed the method for a retailer in the apparel industry.

Mantrala and Rao (2001) also develop two forecasting methods based on experts' estimates for an apparel retailer (of the demand for mens walking shorts for the spring season). Their methods are more detailed than those of Fisher and Raman (1996), Fisher et al. (2001), since they divide the season into a number of periods and also consider different price levels. The ?rst method starts by asking each expert separately for the minimum, maximum, and most likely (modus) demand for each combination of period and price.

Subsequently, using the Delphi group method, the experts have to reach consensus on the minimum, maximum, and modus for each combination of period and price. Finally, for each combination of period and price, the forecast (for the mean) is calculated as the average of the minimum, the maximum, and the modus. The second method asks different input from the experts: an estimate of total (over all periods) demand at a single price, as well as a 95% con?dence interval; the expected percentage of total demand that will occur in each period; and an estimate of the price elasticity.

Based on these inputs, total demand is estimated using a rather complicated model including a log-normal disturbance term. The authors do not report any results on the quality of the resulting forecasts of the two methods.

Based on a survey among 240 ?rms, Sanders and Manrodt (2003) report judgmental forecasting methods to perform less well than quantitative methods. They offer two explanations for the poor performance of judgmental forecasting. First, there are a number of inherent biases, including optimism, wishful thinking, lack of consistency, politicalmanipulation, and overreacting to randomness. Second, people have a limited ability to consider and process large amounts of information.

On the other hand, judgmental methods are often preferred by practitioners, since they can incorporate special insights, trends, and macro-economic factors, which are hard, if not impossible, to quantify in practice and since practitioners are more acquainted with them. Moreover, a lack of data often rules out the use of complex forecasting methods. This is certainly true for the mail order retailer that we consider.


Related Discussions:- Operational research

Dividends , I need help in Logit using Stata I am very new in that and my s...

I need help in Logit using Stata I am very new in that and my supervisor wants me to use panel data ... which model is best for me and why? no idea could you help me...

Fundamentals of Corporate Finance 2nd edition, The higher the rate of inter...

The higher the rate of interest the more likely you will elect to invest your funds and forego current consumption. Is this statement true or false?

Project analysis, McGilla Golf has decided to sell a new line of golf clubs...

McGilla Golf has decided to sell a new line of golf clubs. The clubs will sell for $825 per set and have a variable cost of $395 per set. The company has spent $150,000 for a mar

Determine the net present value-discount cash flows, Suppose GeKay Inc. has...

Suppose GeKay Inc. has a two-year lease over a small copper deposit; the government acquires all rights to the property at the end of the lease.  It is known that the deposit conta

Calculate the cost of equity capital, Question: (a) As the cost of capi...

Question: (a) As the cost of capital is an essential element of investment appraisal, its calculation must be undertaken with care. Failure to do so could lead to adverse cons

The credit term "2/45 net 90" indicates, Ask questThe credit term "2/45 net...

Ask questThe credit term "2/45 net 90" indicatesion #Minimum 100 words accepted#

How could phoenix activity be addressed, Q. How could phoenix activity be a...

Q. How could phoenix activity be addressed? A range of actions have been suggested to mitigate phoenix activity. These suggested actions were selected on the basis of: - pr

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd