Limitations of rational expectations school, Macroeconomics

Assignment Help:

Limitations of the theory of rational expectations:

  1. Critics of this theory note that if policy makers have more information about the economy or their own actions than does the general public, policies can be devised that will alter output and employment. To illustrate, suppose clandestinely, the monetary authority increases the growth rate of the money supply. Since the more rapid increase in the money supply is unanticipated, output and employment increases. Of course, if the rational expectations view is correct, output and employment will return to their original levels after the public learns of the new policy. Consequently, the policy is effective only during the learning process, which may be short-lived. In the case where policy makers possess more information about the economy, it might be easier for them to disseminate the information and let the public act on it rather than going for new policy options.

  2. A second limitation of the theory of rational expectations has to do with the assumption of wage and price flexibility. Under the theory, money wages and prices are assumed flexible. But due to various reasons, they may be "sticky." As a consequence, even if expectations are formed rationally, money wages and prices may adjust slowly, resulting in changes in output and employment. Suppose, for example, that aggregate demand decreases. Assuming that households and firms anticipate the change, money wages and prices should fall so as to leave output and employment unchanged. But if money wages and prices are sticky, output and employment decrease, contrary to the theory of rational expectations. Critics of the theory claim that money wages and prices adjust only slowly over time. Thus, they believe that discretionary policy can alter output and employment, at least in the short run. Proponents of the theory respond by arguing that the role of policy would be limited in this context, since repeated use of policy will lead to changes in the types of contracts that are negotiated. The effects of these changes will reduce or eliminate the ability of policy makers to alter the equilibrium levels of output and employment through the use of a systematic policy.

  3. Opponents of this theory charge that the rational expectations theory cannot explain the prolonged periods of unemployment that we sometimes experience, especially in advanced industrialized economies. If expectations are formed rationally and if wages and prices are flexible, they claim that deviations from the equilibrium levels of output and employment should be short-lived. Since this implication appears to be inconsistent with actual experience, many critics reject the theory on this basis. In response, proponents have constructed theories of the business cycle based on rational expectations. These theories are capable of explaining the observed movements in output and employment.   

As we have discussed above, the theory of rational expectations is controversial. In fact, there is currently no universally accepted theory about expectations. At present only a small minority of economists appear to support the theory of rational expectations. On the other hand, support seems to be growing. Because of the theory's implications for the conduct of policy, resolution of the controversy is very important. The theory of rational expectations together with efficient market clearing led to the emergence of supply-side economics.


Related Discussions:- Limitations of rational expectations school

Aggregate demand with inflation, Aggregate demand with inflation In pre...

Aggregate demand with inflation In previous versions of Keynesian model, Components of aggregate demand did not depend on P. In IS-LM and in AS-AD models, investments depended

Issctes related to balance of payments, ISSUES RELATED TO BALANCE OF PAYMEN...

ISSUES RELATED TO BALANCE OF PAYMENTS: It  is to be remembered that the Indian economy witnessed varying intensities of BOP problem during 1956-9  1.  However over the 1990s,

Money and banking, Suppose the price level in year 2009 is 100 and $100 buy...

Suppose the price level in year 2009 is 100 and $100 buys 100 notebooks that year. If the price level rises to 125 in year 2010, what is the new value or purchasing power of the do

AD-AS, THE AD CURVE SHIFT TO THE LEFT WHEN

THE AD CURVE SHIFT TO THE LEFT WHEN

Classical model, why and how is price level determined by the monetary sect...

why and how is price level determined by the monetary sector in the classical model?

What are the comparative benefits, What are the comparative benefit The...

What are the comparative benefit The idea of comparative benefit defines that a nation must specialise in the industries in which it has a comparative advantage. Comparative be

Question one hw, A small country can import a good at a world price of 10 p...

A small country can import a good at a world price of 10 per unit. The domestic supply curve of the good is S = 20 + 10P The demand curve is D = 400 – 5P In addition, each unit of

Determine optimum output and price levels, Given the demand and cost data y...

Given the demand and cost data you will have available (see information below), briefly describe the process you would use to determine optimum output and price levels in the devel

Determine the gross domestic product, Determine the Gross domestic product ...

Determine the Gross domestic product Gross domestic product is the total value of an economy's domestic output of goods and services. Gross national product is the similar as

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd