Do the changes director lewis milestone, History

Assignment Help:

Do the changes director Lewis Milestone made in turning Erich Maria Remarque's novel All Quiet in the Western Front into the Best Picture of 1930 strengthen or weaken the story? See below for a list of a few changes.

While the novel All Quiet on the Western Front starts with the veteran soldiers (probably in 1917 after enlisting in 1915) "at rest five miles behind the front" (1; ch. 1) rather than in the front lines, the film introduces the main characters as high school students and then follows them through the war chronologically.

Lewis Milestone transforms the account of "Kantorek . . . our schoolmaster" (10; 10-13; ch. 1) into the first major scene in the 1930 film (2:00-9:18) and the account of Kantorek in bootcamp (174-78; ch. 7) into a visit to his classroom (1:50:40-1:54:23).

After his first romantic interlude (143-51; ch. 7), Bäumer is "not in the least happy" (151) and fears "it might be impossible ever to be free of them ["the soldiers' brothels"] again" (150). Bäumer's response in the scene in the film (1:26:24-1:34:32) differs from that in the novel. Which response (novel or film) is more appropriate to the story?

Does the scene of the body parts hanging in the trees (207-09: ch. 9), one of the most gruesome in the novel, appear in the film? If not, why not?

The brief scene with the sniper (228-29; ch. 9) inspired the ending of the film, which is different from the ending of the novel.


Related Discussions:- Do the changes director lewis milestone

Threat of national insolvency, Agree or disagree with the following stateme...

Agree or disagree with the following statement and justify your opinion: "It is not possible to maintain massive war and policing efforts around the globe while maintaining generou

What did the athenians discover, What did the Athenians discover that allow...

What did the Athenians discover that allowed Themistocles to build a large navy? What did Themistocles say that the Delphian Oracle meant by the "wooden wall" in its prophecy?

What was the logic and reasoning of two of these arguments, There were a nu...

There were a number of strong arguments floating around North America to remain attached to England. What was the logic and reasoning of two of these arguments to remain attached a

Cause of the economic crisis in 1857, Which of the following was NOT a caus...

Which of the following was NOT a cause of the economic crisis in 1857? A. the influx of gold from California B. the overproduction of grain in the Midwest C. the inflation

What was the process through which mckinley and taft, What was the process ...

What was the process through which McKinley and Taft endeavored to assimilate the Filipinos?

Second industrial revolution, The Second Industrial Revolution seemed to br...

The Second Industrial Revolution seemed to bring America to the forefront of the world, economically. But it had its downsides. What were they? Did any of these downsides lead to t

Why did the lynching in indiana happen, Why did the lynching in Indiana hap...

Why did the lynching in Indiana happen, what lead residents to engage in such behavior and commit such acts? How did the 1930 lynching reflect the post-civil war history of racial

What factors led to u.s. imperialism overseas, What factors led to U.S. imp...

What factors led to U.S. imperialism overseas? How did U.S. control its territories, and what kind of debates or opposition to imperialism emerged during this period?

Most powerful nation in the world after civil war, Once the Civil War was o...

Once the Civil War was over, the United States adopted the Union vision for the nation with a strong federal government steering the course. Some historians believe adopting this v

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd