Why do you choose one option over the other

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131633487

Assignment

You are an explorer within a foreign land and you have been living with a local forest tribe that you know has had problems with the enroachment of the country's government into their tribal lands. Late one night, the village you are staying in is raided by a local military unit and everyone is taken prisoner. Early the next morning, the commander of the unit comes to you and apologizes for your imprisonment. He explains that foreigners are greatly valued in this society and he would like to bestow an honor upon you. He summons a group of ten captive tribesmen before you and tells you that he will give you this choice (as an honored guest in this land): a) you may choose to shoot one tribesman for his crimes against the government and the others will be released (presumably having learned their lesson) or b) you may choose not to shoot anyone and then the soldiers will execute the men of the village.

What would a Kantian agent do here (use the Categorical Imperative, both HEI and UL formulations, to justify your answer)? What do you do in this circumstance? Why do you choose one option over the other? Do you believe that we should be held morally responsible for things we don't do as much as things that we do?

Reference no: EM131633487

Questions Cloud

What changes have you notice in your community : What changes have you notice in your community in the past several years - has the structure of the population change, the economy improved.
Explain readers that the writer is a sensitive person : Sensory details show readers that the writer is a sensitive person
How can changes in the environment affect the products : How can changes in the environment affect the products you buy?
Copy of the practice or organization : Do you think patients should have to sign a copy of the practice's or organization's financial policies? Should they be provided with a copy of them? Why or why
Why do you choose one option over the other : Why do you choose one option over the other? Do you believe that we should be held morally responsible for things we don't do as much as things that we do?
What is the pv of only the interest payments : Sally borrows $300,000. The loan requires monthly payments for 30 year at 5% APR.
What are the core elements of the conflict : What are the core elements of the conflict? How did the conflict develop in regard to a factionalized, extremist separation from the mainstream leadership?
Calculate the after-tax cost : Calculate the after-tax cost of each of the company's current financing sources
What are the current employment opportunities : What are the current employment opportunities? What information is available to customers? What information is available to employees?

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  How does change reflect racial and ethnic diversity in us

How does this change reflect racial and ethnic diversity in the US, racial tolerance and the future of race relationships in the U.S.

  Explain how you would use swot and bsc together

Briefly compare SWOT and BSC and the unique value of each to strategic management. Explain how you would use SWOT and BSC together. Explain how one tool complements the other.

  Nature versus nurture debate-sociologists claim

In the nature versus nurture debate, sociologists claim that

  Analyze how discrimination has been manifested

Identify one historical example and one contemporary example of discrimination. Consider the underlying causes and the consequences of discrimination in these cases.

  social-mental health and financial support

A system that would meet not only the physical needs of the person, but would provide social,mental health, and financial support is envisioned as a continuum of care. Pick one managed care model. How does it address the problems and challenges of Lo..

  Discussion of existential psychology

In our discussion of existential psychology we talked about our burden of freedom and responsibility. What does this mean? Give an example of a situation in which you were faced with the dilemma of having to choose and bear the responsibility of that..

  Does film have power to transform political sensibilities

Developing a clear and concise thesis statement (an argument) in response to the following question: Does the film have the power to transform political sensibilities

  How can you interpret the y-intercept

What does the y-intercept mean in your real-life data? How can you interpret the y-intercept? Does the line fit the data? How can you tell?

  Develop a chart which compares and contrasts the two views

develop a chart that compares and contrasts the two views. include two to three reading activities for each philosophy

  What is the minimum sampling rate to ensure quality data

A computer will be used to control flow through 10 pumping stations. The pumps exhibit a surging effect with a period of 2.2 sec. What is the minimum sampling rate to ensure quality data? How much time can be spent processing each stationâ

  Explain findings of your t-test and cohen d in plain english

How does the difference in standard deviation influence the outcome of the hypothesis test? Researchers are investigating sleeping habits of young adults in order to determine if they currently get more, less, or the same amount of sleep compared t..

  Discuss societal interest in criminal investigations

How does the probable cause standard for arrests balance the privacy interests of the individual against the societal interest in criminal investigations

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd