What review process does facebook data scientists

Assignment Help Biology
Reference no: EM13943838

1.What review process does Facebook data scientists have to go through in order to launch a psychological study?

Thousands of Facebook Inc. users received an unsettling message two years ago: They were being locked out of the social network because Facebook believed they were robots or using fake names. To get back in, the users had to prove they were real.

In fact, Facebook knew most of the users were legitimate. The message was a test designed to help improve Facebook's antifraud measures. In the end, no users lost access permanently.

The experiment was the work of Facebook's Data Science team, a group of about three dozen researchers with unique access to one of the world's richest data troves: the movements, musings and emotions of Facebook's 1.3 billion users.

The little-known group was thrust into the spotlight this week by reports about a 2012 experiment in which the news feeds of nearly 700,000 Facebook users were manipulated to show more positive or negative posts. The study found that users who saw more positive content were more likely to write positive posts, and vice versa.

Facebook Chief Operating Officer Sheryl Sandberg said Wednesday during a trip to India that the study was "part of ongoing research companies do to test different products" and was "poorly communicated."

The company said that after the feedback on the study, "We are taking a very hard look at this process to make more improvements."

Until recently, the Data Science group operated with few boundaries, according to a former member of the team and outside researchers. At a university, researchers likely would have been required to obtain consent from participants in such a study. But Facebook relied on users' agreement to its Terms of Service, which at the time said data could be used to improve Facebook's products. Those terms now say that user data may be used for research.

"There's no review process, per se," said Andrew Ledvina, a Facebook data scientist from February 2012 to July 2013. "Anyone on that team could run a test," Mr. Ledvina said. "They're always trying to alter peoples' behavior."

He recalled a minor experiment in which he and a product manager ran a test without telling anyone else at the company. Tests were run so often, he said, that some data scientists worried that the same users, who were anonymous, might be used in more than one experiment, tainting the results.

Facebook said that since the study on emotions, it has implemented stricter guidelines on Data Science team research. Since at least the beginning of this year, research beyond routine product testing is reviewed by a panel drawn from a group of 50 internal experts in fields such as privacy and data security. Facebook declined to name them.

Company research intended to be published in academic journals receives additional review from in-house experts on academic research. Some of those experts are also on the Data Science team, Facebook said, declining to name the members of that panel.

A spokesman said Facebook is considering additional changes.

Since its creation in 2007, Facebook's Data Science group has run hundreds of tests. One published study deconstructed how families communicate, another delved into the causes of loneliness. One test looked at how social behaviors spread through networks. In 2010, the group measured how "political mobilization messages" sent to 61 million people caused people in social networks to vote in the 2010 congressional elections.

Many of Facebook's data scientists hold doctoral degrees from major universities in fields including computer science, artificial intelligence and computational biology. Some worked in academic research before joining Facebook.

Adam Kramer, the lead author of the study about emotions, said in a 2012 interview on Facebook's website that he joined the company partly because it is "the largest field study in the history of the world." Mr. Kramer, who has a doctorate in social psychology from the University of Oregon, said that in academia he would have had to get papers published and then hope that someone noticed. At Facebook, "I just message someone on the right team and my research has an impact within weeks, if not days."

Much of Facebook's research is less controversial than the emotions study, testing features that will prompt users to spend more time on the network and click on more ads. Other Internet companies, including Yahoo Inc., Microsoft Corp., Twitter Inc. and Google Inc., conduct research on their users and their data.

The recent ruckus is "a glimpse into a wide-ranging practice," said Kate Crawford, a visiting professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology's Center for Civic Media and a principal researcher at Microsoft Research. Companies "really do see users as a willing experimental test bed" to be used at the companies' discretion.

Facebook's team has drawn particular interest because it occasionally publishes its work in academic journals that touch on users' personal lives, including the study about positive and negative posts.

"Facebook deserves a lot of credit for pushing as much research into the public domain as they do," said Clifford Lampe, an associate professor at the University of Michigan's School of Information who has worked on about 10 studies with Facebook researchers. If Facebook stopped publishing studies, he said, "It would be a real loss for science."

Dr. Lampe said he has been in touch with members of the Data Science team since the controversy erupted. "They've been listening to the arguments and they take them very seriously," he said.

Mr. Ledvina, the former Facebook data scientist, said some researchers debated the merits of a study similar to the one that accused users of being robots but there was no formal review, and none of the users in the study were notified that it was an experiment.

"I'm sure some people got very angry somewhere," he said. "Internally, you get a little desensitized to it."

Credit: By Reed Albergotti

What review process does Facebook data scientists have to go through in order to launch a psychological study?

Reference no: EM13943838

Questions Cloud

Insert a clipart image to the right of the table. : Insert the following table into Sheet1 of an Excel spreadsheet, keeping the cell references consistent
Critical analysis of a criminological theory : Critical analysis of a criminological theory - Locate a newspaper article on an Australian criminal event. In the essay, you will provide a synopsis of the criminal event and explain the causes of the incident using three criminological theories of..
Write a report on airline industry and companies in india : Write a report on Airline Industry & Companies in India describing General Trends in Growth, Profitability and Forecast. What are the key Constraints of the Airline Industry? Describe Porter's Five Forces Model. Also include Aviation Industry Cluster..
Do we know whether the ideas work or not : Do we know whether the ideas work or not? Are there any practical "strategic" recommendations for leaders based on that theory?
What review process does facebook data scientists : 1.What review process does Facebook data scientists have to go through in order to launch a psychological study?Thousands of Facebook Inc. users received an unsettling message two years ago: They were being locked out of the social network because Fa..
Convective heat transfer co efficient : A nickel steel rod 8 cm outer diameterorginally at a temperature of 300 Troc is suddenly immersed in a liquid at 100oc for which the convective heat transfer co efficient is 100 w/m2 0k . what is the..
Describes the probability that they will get to pearl rock : If the tourists start at Looloo with a full tank of fuel and intend to refuel every chance they get, which of the following fault trees (1-8) most accurately describes the probability that they will get to Pearl Rock without being delayed by havin..
Give an example of one government employee law : Give an example of one government employee law that you think people may take advantage of and how people take advantage of it?
Unemployment claims in anderson : The sheet EZDescription describes the variables for this question. The data are on unemployment claims in Anderson (IN) from 1980 through November 1988. In 1984, an enterprise zone ("EZ") was located in Anderson (as well as other cities in Indiana..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Biology Questions & Answers

  Which of these is considered to be an essential amino acid

Nitrogen fixation represents a process by which atmospheric nitrogen is oxidized to make 2 ammonium ions.

  Treasure trove of fossils from these unusual animals

Several main types of animals are now extinct. A treasure trove of fossils from these unusual animals was found in the Canadian Rockies.

  Immediate effect ofligand binding to G proteincoupled

Which of the following best describes the immediate effect ofligand binding to a G proteincoupled receptor?

  What is generally oriented to interior of protein molecule

In the stable form of protein, what is generally oriented to the interior of the protein molecule?

  Increase in the solutes concentration

The urine of a thirteen year old boy turned dark brown several weeks after a bout with strep throat. The diagnosis was glomerulonephritis.

  Which statement regarding the eukaryotic nucleus is false

Chris and Kassie are working in a research lab and are hoping to study the movement ofribosomal subunits through the nuclear pore complex. Which microorganism would they most likely choose as their model organism?

  Q1 listing the two macromolecules that have been partially

q1. listing the two macromolecules that have been partially digested by time acid chyme moves into the intestine where

  Define antigen and chemical characteristics of antigens

The definition of antigen and the chemical characteristics of antigens, The definition of antigen and the chemical characteristics of antigens, haptens and how they become antigenic.

  How does the rna differ from the dna

How do codons relate to primary structure of proteins? Be able to construct a strand of messenger RNA from the sense strand of DNA (TRANSCRIPTION) and understand where this happens in a cell. How does the RNA differ from the DNA? How do mutations in ..

  How could ph play a role

In the absence of the protein translating catalysts of the cell, what would be required to form a peptide bond between two adjacent amino acids such as that found in a proteins primary structure?

  What is the significance of the first and last codons of an

backgroundnbspdna represents the architectural blueprint for all living systems encoding specific instructions in the

  What tool in cell biology would be the best to study

What tool in cell biology would be the best to study the migration of cells on a biologically active surface.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd