What method of data collection and analysis was used

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13928601 , Length: 10 Pages

FORMAT, CONTENT AND ORGANIZATION

The review should be a maximum of ten (10) A4 pages, typed using the Seminar Paper Review Form and should generally have the following format and organization and cover the following points. Be flexible in your approach. The questions are prompts to let you know what to look for. Please DO NOT answer just YES or NO.

1. Summary

Prepare a concise summary of the paper (no more than one page) that will tell someone who has not read the paper what it is about. Specifically, what was the research question/s? 

Why was the question/s important? What method of data collection and analysis was used? What were the results?

2. Introduction and Motivation

What motivation did the author(s) give for the research? The motivation is the reason or justification for expending the time, effort and money in conducting the research.

How did the authors demonstrate why the research is important, and to whom it isimportant?

Did they convince you of the importance of the study? Why or why not?

3. Literature Review and Theory Development (sometimes this is combined with 4below)

How did the author/s demonstrate their scholarly ability to identify and outline relevant existing knowledge?

How did the author/s identify the gap in the existing literature which they reviewed?

How did the author/s locate their study in the relevant literature?2

4. Theory development and hypotheses formulation (if applicable - not all papers willdevelop hypotheses)

What were the independent and dependent variables examined in the research? How the author(s) motivate or justify the choice of variables adequately?

Were there other important variables that were not included in the research that should have been?

How were the variables related in the hypotheses or model(s)?

How d i d the hypotheses or model(s) follow logically from the theory provided (and/or the literature reviewed)?

5. Method

What was the research method? (The applicability of the following questions depends on the research method used)

Was this the most appropriate method to collect data to test the hypotheses and/or address the research question? Why or why not?

What are the strengths and weaknesses of the method in terms of testing the hypotheses and/or addressing the research question?

How were the variables measured or operationalized? (It is possible that this question is not applicable to the paper under review)

Discuss how the measures are valid (measuring the concept they purported to measure) and reliable (measuring consistently across time and samples)?

Identify any threats to internal validity (the extent to which one can believe the results of the study). Were there any omitted variables potentially correlated with both the independent and dependent variables that could serve as rival hypotheses or confounds to the results? How significant were the threats to internal validity?

Identify any threats to external validity (the extent to which one can generalize the results beyond the sample). How significant were the threats to external validity?

6. Results

Did the author(s) explain their results satisfactorily? (This requires more than a yes/no answer)

In particular, where results were inconsistent with hypotheses, did the author(s) seek toprovide possible explanations? Were these explanations plausible?

OR

How were these results consistent or inconsistent with the literature and the explanatoryframework developed by the authors framework suggested by the authors?

7. Discussion and conclusions

What conclusions did the author(s) draw from the study? How did they relate them to the original research problem?

Did the author(s) discuss the limitations of their research? Were there other limitations that should have been discussed or acknowledged?

Did the author(s) discuss the implications of their findings for practice (economic and/or social decision-making) and/or theory (the advancement of knowledge in the area of the research)?

Were there any other implications the author(s) should have stated?

Discuss how the author(s) identified areas for future research arising from their study.

8. References

If you have referred to other papers or materials in your review, provide full bibliographical details in a list of references. 

Reference no: EM13928601

Questions Cloud

Functions of marketing management : Assume you are the Marketing Manager for Target or another brand. How would you apply the four functions of the marketing management process in your role? In your answer, identify how a marketing manager might realize when it is time to focus on o..
What discount rate should the firm use for the project : Gnomes R Us is considering a new project. The company has a debt-equity ratio of .78. The company’s cost of equity is 14.6 percent, and the aftertax cost of debt is 7.9 percent. What discount rate should the firm use for the project?
Preferred customers during product ramp-up : 1. Why would a company want to supply a product to preferred customers during product ramp-up? 2. What is a company trying to optimize in the most common approach to developing a workcenter layout?
Preparing to pay its first dividends : Boo pack is preparing to pay its first dividends. It is going to pay $1.00, $2.50, and $5.00 a share over the next three years, respectively. After that, the company has stated that the annual dividend will be $1.25 per share indefinitely. What is th..
What method of data collection and analysis was used : Prepare a concise summary of the paper (no more than one page) that will tell someone who has not read the paper what it is about. Specifically, what was the research question/s?  Why was the question/s important? What method of data collection and a..
How much external financing is required by berea : Berea Resources is planning a $75 million capital expenditure program for the coming year. How much external financing is required by Berea for the coming year?
How much was the interest expense : Breads ‘R Us had sales of $35,000 last year. Their total costs were $12,000, and the depreciation charge was $3,000. They have 1,480 shares outstanding and paid dividend of $2.20 per share after keeping 70 percent of the net income as retained earnin..
Detailed information on a company that outsources their crm : Detailed information on a company that manages their own CRM "in house." What are the advantages and disadvantages of this company managing their own CRM in house?
Brief introduction of the given article : Read the Article and write a 3 page minimum article critique following the below outline in APA, A brief introduction of the article-TRAINING AND PERFORMANCE OF A DIVERSE WORKFORCE

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Summarizing the main points presented

Write one paragraph about each source, summarizing the main points presented.

  Texas constitution

In what ways does the Texas Constitution reflect the influence of the U.S. Constitution? What effect have changes in the U.S. Constitution had on the Texas Constitution?

  Negative behaviors in the classroom

ow does Maslow's Hierarchy theory relate to student behavior ? Can it be used to a teacher's advantage when dealing with negative behaviors in the classroom ?

  How verbal-nonverbal communication can affect communication

Describing how verbal and nonverbal communication can affect communication in the following areas: Police situations (public announcement to the press)

  Issue related career goals

What are your reasons for attending college?

  Forbidden city-chinese culture

Do you think the Forbidden City and all it represented prevented European influence on Chinese culture? Explain your response.

  Discuss the top wine-producing areas of each region

Discuss the top wine-producing areas of each region.

  Explore the various benefits of brand equity

ick a brand. Assess the extent to which the brand is achieving the various benefits of brand equity. Identify all of its brand elements and assess their ability to contribute to brand equity.

  What it is supposed to be measuring or representing and

statistics are often used in misleading ways. using the internet find an example of a statistic that you feel is

  Statements taken in violation of the miranda rule

Statements taken in violation of the Miranda rule may be used to impeach a defendant that testifies inconsistently with his confession. However, an involuntary confession cannot be used for impeachment. What justifies the distinction between these tw..

  User to enter a number of seconds and works as follows

There are 60 seconds in a minute. If the number of seconds entered by the user is greater than or equal to 60 the program should display the number of minutes in that many seconds.

  Why it is important not to smoke or drink during pregnancy

Your friend, Shannon, is pregnant for the first time and asks you about smoking cigarettes and drinking a glass of wine to unwind during her pregnancy.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd