What do you think about teenage curfew

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131438540

Write 150 word response to Teenage Curfew on Colin Hodgkins. What do you think about Teenage Curfew? What are your thoughts how the whole situation was handled? Is the California Curfew law stricker or roughly the same? Do you think the mother did the right or wrong? Explain. APA Format, No title page. Need to cite and reference response.

In 2000, 15-year-old Colin Hodgkins had a late dinner at the Steak 'n Shake in Marion County, Indiana, where he and some friends had stopped after attending a school soccer game. As Colin was leaving the restaurant, he was arrested for violating the state's curfew law.36 He was taken by the police to the local high school, where he was questioned and required to undergo drug tests before being released to his mother. At the time, Indiana law prohibited minors from being out in public after 11:00 p.m. without parental accompaniment.

Hodgkins's mother filed suit against the state, arguing that the Indiana statute violated her son's First Amendment rights by preventing him and other teenagers from attending midnight mass or a late political rally. When the district court agreed with her, the state amended the statute to make such late-night activities exceptions to the curfew.

37 Colin then challenged the amended statute, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit agreed that the statute dissuaded minors from engaging in protected activities because they risked arrest, detention, and drug tests if they did so.38In the words of the court, "[W]e hold that the curfew law, even with the new affirmative defenses for First Amendment activity, is not narrowly tailored to serve a significant governmental interest and fails to allow for ample alternative channels for expression.

The statute restricts a minor's access to any public forum during curfew hours, and the affirmative defense for participating in First Amendment activities does not significantly reduce the chance that a minor might be arrested for exercising First Amendment rights."39

In 2003 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit overruled a similar city ordinance that had been enacted by the city of Vernon, Connecticut.40 Nonetheless, at last count about 500 cities in the United States had curfew regulations in effect,41 and courts are split on the constitutionality of such statutes.42

In 2000, a Texas court upheld a curfew ordinance that was enacted by the city of San Antonio.43 The San Antonio Youth Curfew ordinance prohibits youths under the age of 17 from being in public places within the city between the hours of 10:30 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. on Sunday through Thursday and between the hours of 12:00 midnight and 6:00 a.m. on Friday or Saturday. In the 2000 case, a teenager had been stopped by the police for violating the city's curfew law. He was subsequently searched, and the police found marijuana on his person.

About the same time, a curfew law passed by the District of Columbia was found unconstitutional because it was not narrowly tailored to serve the District's compelling interest in addressing the problems of crime and victimization by and against minors in the least intrusive manner.44

As these cases show, the constitutionality of curfew statutes is unclear. The laws that have been overturned were generally seen as being too vague and as restricting the First Amendment rights of the teenagers involved. Many officials believe, however, that such laws are needed to combat criminal activity by juveniles.45

Reference no: EM131438540

Questions Cloud

Can you think of another reckless crime : Driving while intoxicated crimes in California include a charge of drunk driving which can however be reduced to a conviction of reckless driving involving alcohol. This crime of conviction of reckless driving is normally achieved through a plea b..
Write a literature review for article related to chemicals : Write a literature review for each article of around 300 words - Removal of heavy metal from industrial wastewater using chitosan coated oil palm shell charcoal by Saifuddin M. Nomanbhay and Kumaran Palanisamy
Most effective re engineering efforts are successful : The most effective re engineering efforts are successful when they recognize that? having a focus on the customers needs to be put on hold until the dust settles and managers sort out their budgets. it is best to begin with a very generous severance ..
Represent major issues for personnel administrators : Equal employment opportunity and diversity of the workforce represent major issues for personnel administrators in most organizations. Explain the benefit of a diverse workforce in an organization and propose an innovative strategy that would inc..
What do you think about teenage curfew : Write 150 word response to Teenage Curfew on Colin Hodgkins. What do you think about Teenage Curfew? What are your thoughts how the whole situation was handled? Is the California Curfew law stricker or roughly the same? Do you think the mother di..
Undergoing significant transformations : As a field, human resource management is undergoing significant transformations, from one previously concerned with performing administrative functions to one concerned with becoming a strategic partner to senior management.
How is the hp hewlett packard and dell doing : How is the HP (Hewlett Packard), and Dell doing? How has the stock price done? how HP (Hewlett Packard), and Dell is doing financially?
Problem of illegal downloading : Do you think the lawsuits brought by the recording industry will solve the problem of illegal downloading? Are there alternatives? Would legislation help?
Problem of illegal downloading : Do you think the lawsuits brought by the recording industry will solve the problem of illegal downloading? Are there alternatives? Would legislation help?

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Discuss about the generalized anxiety disorder

Generalized anxiety disorder.Discuss the following with regard to the selected disorder:Biological and social ramifications.Prevalence, age of onset, and gender differences.

  Underground electric cable across

The Blue Utilities Company paid Sue $1,500 for the right to lay an underground electric cable across her property anytime in the future.

  Discuss the implications of agency that apply in situation

Discuss the implications of agency that apply in this situation, and describe at least one way the company may be able to cancel or return the order in question.

  How would an american company marketing abroad benefit

What does this mean? How would an American company marketing abroad benefit from its existing employee base? Would it be beneficial to add multinational members/employees to the organization

  Compliance techniques issue

Which tactic is the most powerful? In other words, which tactic produces the highest level of compliance?

  Why is this an ethical dilemma

Is Angela's current situation one that Dr. Hernandez should have anticipated in establishing group therapies designed to treat addiction and substance dependence? Does Dr. Hernandez have a professional responsibility for Angel's safety outside the..

  Massive social-economic and political movement focused

A massive social, economic, and political movement focused on eliminating discrimination began on December 1, 1955 when ________ refused to give up her seat to a white man on a bus as the law required her to do.

  Describe the organizational environment or corporate culture

Does the Code of Professional provide helpful guidance as to how the dilemma should be addressed? If so, cite the provision that gave guidance. Describe the organizational environment or corporate culture in which the dilemma exists. Cite Kohlb..

  How the united states ranks on this issue

How the United States ranks on this issue in relation to other countries. Efforts of the World Health Organization and other agencies on this issue

  Law related to religious discrimination v/s undue hardship

Lynette Hines is employed by Irvin Industries. She recently became a Seven Day Adventist and has informed her employer that she can no longer work on Saturday.

  Element of critical thinking and problem solving

One key element of critical thinking and problem solving is to plan ahead for contingencies--things that come up that you weren't expecting.

  Discuss the most popular form of television commercials

The most popular form of television commercials is the 30-second spot. Discuss why 30-second spot are so popular among advertiser.when might a marketer be able to effectively use 10-or15-second commercial?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd