What alerts you to the presence of an ethical dilemma

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131376761

Tonya and Lydia are two senior nursing students assigned to work in the intensive care unit with a critically ill patient. The patient, Mr. Dunn, is an 87-year-old retired ironworker. He lives alone in an old two-story frame house. Mr. Dunn is diabetic. He is nearly blind and has moderately advanced prostate cancer and Alzheimer's disease. Mr. Dunn was admitted to the intensive care unit after he was discovered unconscious in his home by a neighbor. At that time he was ketoacidotic and had a very severe necrotic wound on his left leg. The surgeon plans to amputate Mr. Dunn's left leg but has been unable to get consent from either Mr. Dunn or his next of kin, a niece who lives out of town.

Tonya is proud of her efficiency as a nursing student. She makes rapid decisions. Tonya insists that Mr. Dunn must have the amputation. She boldly suggests to the physician that he have a surrogate appointed for Mr. Dunn so that the surgery can proceed. The course is clear to her. Lydia, on the other hand, is not certain of the correct course of action. She talks to Mr. Dunn and his niece about his condition. She wonders if the amputation is the best solution to his problem. She thinks about what his quality of life will be after the surgery. She worries about his ability to care for himself and about his state of mind should he be forced to live in a nursing home. She thinks about what she would want for her own father if he were in the same situation. Lydia falls asleep at night pondering these thoughts. She does not know how to go about solving the problem. Tonya is impatient with Lydia. She sees no benefit to the time and energy spent worrying about this problem when the solution is apparent to her. She dislikes wasting her time talking to Lydia about these concerns.

Think about It: Facing Ethical Dilemmas

What alerts you to the presence of an ethical dilemma?

How do you feel when confronted with difficult ethical decisions?

To what degree do you think nurses should become involved in making decisions such as the one described in the situation presented previously?

With which qualities of each nurse do you identify?

Reference no: EM131376761

Questions Cloud

Information security policy and an information security plan : Develop a document discussing the importance of creating information security polices and an information security plan.
Which fields in the tcp protocol provide reliability : 1. Which fields in the TCP protocol provide reliability? 2. Why do you think that the version field is in the very first field on the header? Notice that is located in the same place in the IPV6 IP header as well.
How do you feel about having your fingerprints : How do you feel about having your fingerprints, facial features, and perhaps more of your biometric features encoded in documents such as your passport? Explain your answer.
Analyze the information presented on microexpressions : Discuss how body language and facial expressions can be critical in determining someone's actions and inner states. Analyze the information presented on microexpressions and lying, and explain how understanding these concepts can influence your pe..
What alerts you to the presence of an ethical dilemma : What alerts you to the presence of an ethical dilemma? How do you feel when confronted with difficult ethical decisions? To what degree do you think nurses should become involved in making decisions such as the one described in the situation present..
What is the purpose of a bank reconciliation : What is the purpose of a bank reconciliation? What are the reasons for differences between the cash reported in the accounting records, and the cash balance in the bank statements?
Fundamental characteristics and components : Select an organization you are familiar with. Write a 1-page paper that includes the following based on your chosen Local Organization: Explain the network's fundamental characteristics and components.
Who will be the targets of the next round of layoffs : You have been accidentally copied on an email from the CEO, which details who will be the targets of the next round of layoffs. What do you do?
Vulnerability assessment : 1. How can you use this methodology to combat risk? 2. Describe a situation where you would use it and why? 3. What challenges would you face in using it?

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  List modifiable risk factors of coronary artery disease

List four modifiable risk factors of coronary artery disease and explain how each of these factors contribute to the development of plaque

  Describe how the disorder could affect memory

Describe how altered states of consciousness related to sleep, psychoactive drugs, or meditation and hypnosis affect individuals with the disorder. Describe how the disorder could affect memory. Provide a brief description of any biological influen..

  Disorder differ from similar behaviors considered normal

Describe the symptoms commonly associated with this disorder according to the DSM-IV. How do the behaviors associated with this disorder differ from similar behaviors considered normal in American culture?

  Why did aesop use animals instead of people in his stories

Now the cat didn't want to put her paw so close to the flames, but she was flattered by what the monkey had said about her. So she crept carefully right up to the fire and, just as carefully, drew out a chestnut with her paw.

  Greatest influence on your value system

So, where do you get your values? Normative ethics is about studying how to USE your values to come to a good conclusion to a tough moral problem. You plug your values into the equation and get your answer. But each of us has different values. Where ..

  Describe the gender theory that you picked

Explain how gender identity may have changed in the past 2-3 generations (i.e., your parents and grandparents) with changing dynamics in family (divorce, single parents, women in the workforce, Title IX, etc.).

  Cultural appropriation and cultural appreciation

What is the difference between cultural appropriation and cultural appreciation

  Determine what ethical-legal and institutional policies

1300 EST :Provide information and support for a proposed Computer and Internet Use policy. Discuss the important factors to be considered when creating a Computer and Internet Use policy and why they are important. Remember, you are trying to conv..

  Definition of affirmative action

In "Affirmative Action: Past and Present", what is Tim Wise's definition of affirmative action? How does this understanding of affirmative action go against popular beliefs as to what constitutes affirmative action?

  Your community is residential for the most part with

you live in a community where during the past year the voters have chosen to have the town of eagles nest colorado

  Recognize at least three different tools of psychological

identify at least three different tools of psychological assessment and review the benefits and liabilities of

  Discuss why you have chosen this topic for the population

Discuss why you have chosen this topic for this population, including research on the relevance of this topic to this particular group. Summarize the important points of what you have found in the research.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd