The limitations of nonexperimental research

Reference no: EM131351481

The limitations of nonexperimental research were dramatically brought to the attention of the public by the results of an experiment on the effects of postmenopausal hormone replacement therapy (part of a larger study known as the Women's Health Initiative). An experiment is called a clinical trial in medical research.

In the clinical trial, participants were randomly assigned to receive either the hormone replacement therapy or a placebo (no hormones). The hormone replacement therapy consisted of estrogen plus progestin.

In 2002, the investigators concluded that women taking the hormone replacement therapy had a higher incidence of heart disease than did women in the placebo (no hormone) condition. At that point, they stopped the experiment and informed both the participants and the public that they should talk with their physicians about the advisability of this therapy.

The finding dramatically contrasted with the results of nonexperimental research in which women taking hormones had a lower incidence of heart disease; in these studies, researchers compared women who were already taking the hormones with women not taking hormones. Why do you think the results were diff erent with the experimental research and the nonexperimental research?

Reference no: EM131351481

Questions Cloud

The required yield to maturity tripled at the time : The Starr-Monuca Company bond is an unusual bond. It does not pay any coupon, and only pays the Fave Value at the end of 20 years. Such a bond is called a zero bond. Compute its yield to maturity if it is currnetly selling at 70% dicount. What would ..

Write a response about the given post : In my personal experience, a person's memory strength is quite different. Some seem to have a great memory and very accurate and some forget what they had for breakfast. For example, my mother can never remember something small and insignificant..

Website showing the percentage mortality rate : Clearly, no filtering at all would maximize XYZ's profitability. However, a local environmental group monitors XYZ's contaminant level and maintains a website showing the percentage mortality rate of the dove tailed turtles due to XYZ's contaminan..

Determine the equation that models mars’ elliptical orbit : The elliptical orbit of Mars has its foci at (0.141732, 0) and (0.141732, 0), where 1 unit equals 1 AU. The length of the major axis is 3.048 AU. Determine the equation that models Mars' elliptical orbit.

The limitations of nonexperimental research : Why do you think the results were different with the experimental research and the nonexperimental research?

Alignment between the 4ps of marketing : Please elaborate on the alignment between the 4Ps of marketing and a product life cycle. Consider the product you are using in the course for your response. How might the 4Ps change through its life cycle and why?

What are the anticipated cash inflows for the first quarter : National Beverage Company anticipates the following first quarter sales for 2015: January: $1,800,000 February: $1,600,000 March: $2,100,000 It posted the following sales figures for the last quarter of 2014: What are the anticipated cash inflows for..

How could business abuse technology in advertising campaigns : How could businesses abuse this technology in advertising campaigns? Who are the advocates of this technology and what is their argument regarding potential privacy violations?

Write an in-depth analytical essay : Write your analysis focusing on one of the following elements from one of the assigned short stories - write an in-depth analytical essay using your own ideas plus supporting evidence from the text, such as quotations, paraphrases, and summaries, ..

User Account

All Pages