Reference no: EM13954728
The Great Temperature Debate
The employer is a small, nonunion furniture manufacturer with 15 employees engaged in interstate commerce. Both of the employees involved in this case worked in the machine shop building as band-saw operators. Because the band saws were located near the shop ’ s large overhead door, to facilitate the disposal of sawdust, the band-saw operators were often subject to lower temperatures and drafts on cool or cold days ,whereas other employees farther from the overhead door often felt too warm. To resolve this long-standing problem, the plant manager established a rule that stated: “ The overhead door will remain open when the temperature in the shop exceeds 68 degrees and closed when the temperature is at or below 68 degrees. ”
On the day in question, employees Drake and Keeler, who were both band-saw operators, complained to the shop supervisor that they were too cold and requested that the overhead door be closed. When questioned by the shop supervisor, the majority of the other shop employees present responded that they thought the door should be left open. The thermometer on the wall of the shop supervisor ’ s office, located in approximately the center of the machine shop building, read 72 degrees .
On this day, employee Drake was wearing a sleeve-less shirt and shorts. Employee Keeler was dressed in blue jeans, a short-sleeved shirt, a flannel shirt, and a heavy sweater. Both Keeler and Drake claimed it was too cold and drafty at their workstation near the open overhead door. The shop supervisor refused to close the overhead door because the majority of employees wanted it left open. During a scheduled lunch break, Drake and Keeler discussed their problem and decided to walk off the job for the remainder of the day to protest the cold temperature at their workstation.
Upon returning to work the following morning, Drake and Keeler were informed by the plant manager that they had been fired for leaving work the previous day without management ’ s permission. Drake and Keeler subsequently filed an unfair labor practice charge with the NLRB alleging their discharge represented unlawful discrimination of their right to engage in concerted and protected activity under Section 7 of the LMRA. Drake and Keeler requested a remedy to include reinstatement with full back pay and restoration of any lost privileges.
1. Because Drake and Keeler ’ s employer meets the standard for coverage under the LMRA by engaging in interstate commerce, which specific employee right protected by Section 7 of the LMRA could Drake and Keeler argue they were engaged in which at least partially motivated the employer ’ s decision to discharge them?
2. On what grounds might the employer try to argue that the discharge of Drake and Keeler was an appropriate (legal) exercise of management’s rights?
3. Was the employer’s s discharge of Drake and Keeler ran unfair labor practice under the LMRA, as amended? If so, what should be the appropriate remedy?
Comprehensive understanding of key concepts
: The final assignment for this course is a research paper. This paper will reflect comprehensive understanding of key concepts that have been discussed during this course. This assignment will provide you with the opportunity to apply related urb..
|
Explain the difference between public, for-profit
: Discuss the major differences among these three legal structures, as well as the benefits and drawbacks from a legal and regulatory perspective.
|
Secretary arrange for the firm to break even
: A firm is considering adding a second secretary to answer phone calls and make appointments. The cost of the secretary will be $10/hour and she will work 200 hours each month. If each new client adds $400 of profit to the firm, how many clients must ..
|
Statement of financial position of comp plc
: The following is an extract from the statement of financial position of Comp plc as at 31.3.X6:
|
The great temperature debate
: The employer is a small, nonunion furniture manufacturer with 15 employees engaged in interstate commerce. Both of the employees involved in this case worked in the machine shop building as band-saw operators. On what grounds might the employer try t..
|
Proposing a change initiative related to motivation
: Using the same organization that you selected in Week 1, propose a change that your organization could implement that would aid it strategically. The proposed change might relate to some area of need, performance deficiency, or other opportunity t..
|
Directors of britton plc wish to raise additional capital
: The directors of Britton plc wish to raise additional capital. They currently have in issue one million £1 ordinary shares and no long-term loans. What options do they have available to raise extra capital and which would you advise them to choose..
|
Three entities in a bookstore database
: There are 3 entities in a bookstore database as follows, (1) Author, (2) Book, and (3) Publisher. Each book may have more than one author, and each author may write more than one book. Each book was only published by one publisher, and one publisher ..
|
Statutory regulation governing
: Answer the following questions for both sole traders and companies: (a) Is there any statutory regulation governing them?
|