Refuse psychiatric intervention

Assignment Help Biology

Reference no: EM133912204

Case 1:

The patient is a 27-year-old man who has severe schizophrenic illness and type-I diabetes. Before treatment in your secure treatment unit, he was treated successively in different settings with good success. He had been brought to your secure treatment unit after a near-fatal assault on a patient in another hospital. His stay has been characterized by periods of relative health alternating with periods of withdrawal and aggression, at which time he would become very depressed. During these periods, he talks about hearing "voices" which he claims were the reason he attacked others physically, including staff, in the past.

He also refuses to accept his insulin during periods of depression but agrees to his schizophrenia medication; this is appropriately managing the illness, despite the periods of withdrawal and aggression. The only treatment that helps him to recover to some degree from his depressive episodes is electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), even though he had once expressed his wish to not receive it when he was capable. Although he has been found incapable of consenting to treatment during depressive episodes, he refuses ECT each time it is presented, and he has to be forcibly restrained while his insulin is administered.

The staff find it distressing to have to forcibly restrain the patient so often, and to inject him with insulin against his will. They feel that restraining him compromises their caring relationship with him. Also, they feel uncomfortable in having to inject him with insulin, which he needs for his type-I diabetes, since he is adamantly refusing. Unfortunately, this is the only way to keep him from ketoacidosis until he recovers from his depression after a few weeks of ECT.

1. What are some of the ethical issues in this case?

2. Which of the treatments (if not all) should/should not be administered?

3. When capable, what did the patient refuse exactly? What did his refusal mean?

4. Do prior expressed capable wishes apply only to somatic disease or do they also apply to mental health conditions?

5. Does the patient have the right to refuse psychiatric intervention in prior expressed wishes from a mental health point of view? If so, what if he becomes violent?

6. Would this only apply to mental health patients with periods of stability? What if the patient became permanently incapable?

7. What alternatives are available to this patient (to the ECT) and were these provided to him as options when capable and deciding?

Reference no: EM133912204

Questions Cloud

Do you think that bipolar disorder is difficult to diagnose : Why do you think that most providers who see patients with bipolar disorder see them when they are depressed? Do you think that bipolar disorder is difficult

Describe to general audience the data analytics methodology : Reflect on the efficacy of the techniques/software used and what other data and techniques could enhance the analysis - Reflect briefly on the role & limitation

What primary sources does dr miljana radiojevic mention : What material was more important than silk for early trade along the Silk Road? What primary sources does Dr. Miljana Radiojevic mention?

Appropriate medical terminology and abbreviations : Identify three reasons it is important for the enrolled nurse to use appropriate medical terminology and abbreviations in clinical situations

Refuse psychiatric intervention : Does the patient have the right to refuse psychiatric intervention in prior expressed wishes from a mental health point of view?

Which condition would likely be the cause of heart murmur : While auscultating heart sounds, the nurses hear a murmur over the mitral valve location. Which condition would likely be the cause of the heart murmur?

What elements of this writing make it technical : What elements of this writing make it technical? Do you think that you create technical writing? If so, when? For what purposes? How often?

About patient physical health status : What methods might be used to obtain accurate information about patient's physical health status or actual/potential problems regarding their health status?

Postoperative acute respiratory depression : A patient is prescribed opioid antagonists for postoperative acute respiratory depression. What are the adverse reactions of opioid antagonists?

User Account

All Pages