Is short amount of time she has to live ethically relevant

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131195757

Euthanasia

The word "euthanasia" draws its roots from Greek meaning "good death." As it is used in this discussion, it means "the act of ending the life of a person suffering from either a terminal illness, or an incurable disease." The AMA is against physicians assisting in euthanasia. There is currently only one state in the US that allows for euthanasia, and that is Oregon, where in 1997, the "Death With Dignity Act" went into effect. Euthanasia advocates stress that it should be allowed as an extension of a person's autonomy. Those who are against euthanasia often say that it can lead to the devaluation of human life, and to a slippery slope in which the old and disabled will be killed on the whims of healthy people. We examined one case and the Oregon law to view the ethics of euthanasia.

Case One:

A woman was diagnosed with motor neurone disease (the same

disease that Stephen Hawking has) 5 years ago. This is a condition that destroys motor nerves, making control of movement impossible, while the mind is virtually unaffected. People with motor neurone disease normally die within 4 years of diagnosis from suffocation due to the inability of the inspiratory muscles to contract. The woman's condition has steadily declined. She is not expected to live through the month, and is worried about the pain that she will face in her final hours. She asks her doctor to give her diamorphine for pain if she begins to suffocate or choke. This will lessen her pain, but it will also hasten her death. About a week later, she falls very ill, and is having trouble breathing.

Questions for Case 1:

Does she have a right to make this choice, especially in view of the fact that she will be dead in a short while (say six hours)? Is this choice an extension of her autonomy?

Is the short amount of time she has to live ethically relevant? Is there an ethical difference between her dying in 6 hours and dying in a week? What about a year, and how do you draw this distinction?

Is the right for a patient's self-determination powerful enough to create obligations on the part of others to aid her so that she can exercise her rights? She clearly cannot kill herself. She can't move, but should someone be FORCED to help her, or to find someone to help her?

Should the money used to care for this woman be taken into account when she is being helped? Do you think that legalizing euthanasia could create conflicts of interest for the patient/ or the doctor? Will people feel that they need to end their lives earlier to save money?

Ask each student: If you were the physician, what would you do? Note: if you would pass her off to another doctor knowing he or she would do it, does this free you from you ethical obligations?

Oregon's Death With Dignity Act:

Students were given the two paragraphs that are found on the following web page: https://www.nightingalealliance.org/htmdocs/iss_a_p.htm. We then discussed the following questions pertaining to the Death With Diginity Act.

Death With Dignity Questions:

Look at the requirements for the request. Do you see any problems with them? (The woman from case 1 would not qualify.)

Why would they put in these guidelines? Should they be there, if they keep a competent person like the woman above from living her autonomy? (Is it to protect the doctors so they will not have to GIVE the medication?)

Is there a moral difference between prescribing the drug and actually giving it to the patient? If not, why put in the rules?

Why do you think they wouldn't let a person who is terminally ill and in pain with possibly more than 6 months receive assistance in dying? Say someone is diagnosed with HIV?

Does the justification of euthanasia necessarily justify the assisted suicide of a healthy person?

Do you think a weakness of this law is the probability of patients being influenced by family members? (For example, for financial or other reasons?) Note: Approximately 60% of Oregonians in 2000 said (before they died) that they used the prescription at least in some part due to fear of being a burden on their family.

The AMA says that euthanasia is fundamentally incompatible with the physician's role as healer. What do you think about this statement? Why should a physician have to be the one who does this?

Reference no: EM131195757

Questions Cloud

What are the length width and height of the prism : What are the length, width, and height of the prism if the volume is 3x3+ 9x2 + 6x? Your answer will not have exact numeric dimensions but rather three algebraic terms that represent them.
Assistance in locating and hiring an outstanding : You have been hired as a staffing consultant by the administration of Sincere College. They need your assistance in locating and hiring an outstanding young scholar to join the faculty of the Davis School of Business
How would you decide between the two vendors’ products : The two products are very evenly matched on other key factors, such as performance, features, reliability, and support costs. How would you decide between the two vendors' products?
What is the max and minimum value of the given vector : What is the max and minimum value of the above vector? In what elements are these values found? Find the square root, cube root and 7th root of this vector using a single operation.
Is short amount of time she has to live ethically relevant : Is the short amount of time she has to live ethically relevant? Is there an ethical difference between her dying in 6 hours and dying in a week? What about a year, and how do you draw this distinction?
What whistle-blower actions did dr. wigand take : What motivated Wigand to take an executive position at a tobacco company and then five years later to denounce the industry's efforts to minimize the health and safety issues of tobacco use?
Suitability of the zone transformer impedance : Confirm the suitability of the zone transformer impedance, and zone transformer neutral earthing impedance and The zone substation transformer overcurrent and earth fault relay settings on HV.
How would you decide between the two vendors'' products : The two products are very evenly matched on other key factors, such as performance, features, reliability, and support costs. How would you decide between the two vendors' products?
What about problem of biases in psychological testing : What is reliability? Consistency in scores or ratings that are expected to be consistent. Random variations in measurement are called "error of measurement" or "error variance. What about different ways of assessing reliability?

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  How do you think an entire prehistoric group of people

how are scholars able to find out how early people with no written records lived?bullwhat was prehistoric society like

  Measuring framework and types of digitizers

A brick-on-edge course of bricks may be required____. Bank measures amounts to tak into account___. Which of the following statements about measuring framework is false? What are the two main types of digitizers?

  Western nutrition herbs class assignment

Western nutrition herbs class's assignment- Write 200-300 word (about one page double spaced typed) reflections on course material five times throughout the course

  Similarities between the luddites

Are there similarities between the Luddites of the 19th century and the neo-Luddites of today? What objections do they have against technology? Is our technology "dumbing us down"?

  What are the stages in the historical development

What are the stages in the historical development of the juvenile justice system and of separate treatment for juveniles? What is the philosophy underlying today's juvenile courts

  Characteristics of neoliberalism,

Explain how modern political ideologies evolve and new ideologies emerge. Identify the key characteristics of neoliberalism, communism, socialism and fascism.

  Many legalist politics were adopted

Many Legalist politics were adopted by

  Preparing class time table

Suppose you are preparing class time table. You have three teachers (T1, T2 ad T3) and seven periods (P1, P2, P3, P4, P5, P6,P7).

  Define the problem persuasively and accurately

You will then include the following in the report: define the problem persuasively and accurately, propose a solution or solutions to the problem or issue and present that solution to a decision-maker or group of decision-makers who can implement the..

  World factory currently experienced under globalization

What (ideological) image did the Newly Industrializing Countries project upon other developing nations? Do you see any link between the novelty introduced by these NICs and the "world factory" currently experienced under globalization, with its outso..

  Formulate interview questions relating to memory

Formulate interview questions relating to memory, learning, and intelligence. Formulate interview questions relating to cognition and problem solving.

  What does osha mean by employee immediate access to sdss

List and briefly discuss four exceptions to the Safety Data Sheet requirements of the Hazard Communication Standard (HCS). What does OSHA mean by employee "immediate access" to SDSs?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd