Indicate whether you agree with the majority decision

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131071339

It is important to understand the impact an expert testimony may have in the ultimate decision made by a court. In addition, it is helpful for practitioners of forensic psychology to be able to read and understand legal cases.

Tasks:

Review the case Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen (2005).

The case describes an appellate legal opinion or court decision involving expert witness testimony. When a case is appealed, it goes to an appellate or to a higher court. The appellate court then reviews the findings of the lower court, which in this case was the trial court. The appellate court offered the following two opinions:

- The first opinion (Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen, 2005, pp. 1-24) is the majority opinion and is the one that counts.

- The second opinion (Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen, 2005, pp. 24-31) is an opinion filed by a minority of judges who concurred (agreed) in part and dissented (disagreed) in part with the majority of the judges who ruled.

After reading the appellate legal opinion, write a 2- to 3-page paper addressing the following:

1. Discuss whether either of the expert witnesses in this case acted unethically. Support your opinion with the relevant APA or specialty ethical guidelines.

2. Indicate whether you agree with the majority decision or the minority concurring or dissenting opinion. Explain why.

The paper should be in APA style.

Reference:
Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen, 609 S.E.2d 4 (Va. 2005).

Attachment:- commonwealth_case_study.rar

Reference no: EM131071339

Questions Cloud

What is the value of the p-value : Is this evidence that the mean nicotine content is actually higher than advertised? To answer this, test the hypotheses H0: μ = 1.5 versus Ha: μ > 1.5. What is the value of the P-value?
Relationship between mental illness and dangerousness : Discuss research studies on the relationship between mental illness and dangerousness. Describe symptoms that correlate with an increased risk of violence among those experiencing mental illness.
Determine an equation for finding : If you are paid a weekly base salary of $200 plus an hourly wage of $5.00, determine an equation for finding your weekly gross pay (P) for t hours. Specify an amount between 25 and 50 hours worked for 1 week and determine your gross pay for that w..
Which historical movements do you consider most important : Which historical movements, legal decisions, and legislative actions do you consider most important in forming the basis for special education services in the United States?
Indicate whether you agree with the majority decision : Discuss whether either of the expert witnesses in this case acted unethically. Support your opinion with the relevant APA or specialty ethical guidelines.
Computing the tension in the rope : One rope is horizontal and the other is inclined at an angle ? to the horizontal, as shown in the diagram below. The tension in the rope inclined at ? to the horizontal is 72N. Find the angle ?, giving your answer to the nearest degree.
Compute the inverse laplace transform : Read Chapter 3 in the textbook Signals and Systems Using MATLAB.>? Read the Lecture "W4 Lecture 2 - Laplace Transform".
Perspectives on the same concept : Gives you many perspectives on the same concept. If one type of explanation is not very clear to you, you can then depend on another kind of explanation in another website to understand the concept.
How do traditions influence self-care to improve well-being : Choose one ethnic/cultural group. How do their traditions/culture influence self-care to improve well-being. Choose one of the aspects of self (physical, mental, emotional/culture, spiritual). Cite sources from the readings or online library.

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Describing the role of the judges

Describing the role of the judges in Israel during the settlement period. Use the GCU eLibrary to identify and use two scholarly sources in addition to the text.

  Example of the androcentric bias in real life

Define “Androcentrism.” In your own words, what does this bias refer to? Give an example of the androcentric bias in real life.

  Passage of national security act

Critically discuss how U.S intelligence has developed since the passage of the National Security Act. What weaknesses were associated with U.S intelligence in light of the September 11, 2001 attacks?

  Demographic changes and cultural values

How have demographic changes and cultural values influenced the evolution of health care delivery systems in the United States?

  Different roles of law enforcement in american society

Define the different roles of law enforcement in American society - examine the field as it pertains to job opportunities and movement within the field.

  Ancient cultures

Can the extravagance and costs, both of currency and lives, be justified in the opulent architecture commissioned by "divinely empowered" individuals of ancient cultures

  Find a peer-reviewed journal article

Find a peer-reviewed journal article that examined one or more of the skin senses. This research can have either a basic or applied focus and it can be conducted in either humans or other animals

  Write paper on online shopping cart

Need a 3 page electronic commerce paper in apa format with three references. Topic is on "Online shopping cart"

  Explain and critically evaluate contemporary literature

Explain and critically evaluate contemporary literature in the field of criminal justice. Identify ethical problems faced by individuals or communities and identify effective solutions.

  History of cattle domestication

You are collaborating with a group of archeologists to reconstruct the history of cattle domestication. Your archeologist colleagues tell you that cattle were already domesticated by 9000 years ago, as evidenced by the appearance of pottery fragments..

  Symbolic importance of quilts

I am writing on the symbolic importance of quilts in Alice Walker's Everyday Use. Could someone help me formulate an outline? I want to show that the quilt shows both the strength and weakness of the bonds between the women in the story.

  Industrial revolution came about because of the development

The Industrial Revolution came about because of the development of:

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd