Impact evaluation using an instrumental variables approach

Assignment Help Business Economics

Reference no: EM13896671

Impact Evaluation Using an Instrumental Variables Approach:

In the 1960’s a group medical practice (Health Insurance Plan or HIP) undertook a large scale randomized trial to evaluate the effectiveness of mammography. There were 62000 subjects in the experiment (women members of HIP aged 40-64) of whom 31000 were randomly selected to be the control group and the other half were randomized into treatment (i.e. chosen for treatment). These individuals were sent an invitation to four rounds of annual screening (a clinical exam and mammography) and we will call them the treatment group. The control group received no such invitation and was provided with the usual level of health care.

(a) The researchers followed the subjects for five years and recorded the number of deaths due to breast cancer that occurred in each group. They found that in the treatment group there were 39 such deaths or 1.3 deaths per 1000 women. while the corresponding figure for the control group was 63 (2.0 deaths per 1000 women). Compute the OLS estimate of the effect of the treatment on death rates given this information.

(b) The researchers found, however, that not everyone in the treatment group accepted the invitation for screening (we ignore compliance problems in the control group). In fact, of the 31000 individuals who received the invitation, about 10800 (1/3 roughly) refused the screening. The number of deaths from breast cancer in this group was 16 (death rate per 1000 women 1.5) the corresponding figure among the 20200 who actually accepted the treatment was 23 (death rate per 1000 women 1.1). Compute the IV estimate of the effect of the treatment on death rates using treatment assignment as an instrument and compare it to the effect you estimated in part (a) above.

(c) The researchers also recorded all other deaths (excluding breast cancer) in the treatment and control groups and obtained the following. In the control group, there were 879 deaths from other causes (death rate per 1000 women: 28) while the corresponding figure for those in the treatment group who refused the invitation was 409 (death rate per 1000 women: 38) and for those in the treatment group who accepted the invitation was 428 (death rate per 1000 women 21). Does this information cause you to doubt the OLS estimates of the treatment effect computed in (a) above and if so why (be as precise as possible)?

Reference no: EM13896671

Questions Cloud

Calculate firms inverse demand function-maximized profit : The demand function for a firm’s product is Q(P) = 50!P/10. The firm’s cost of production is-For this part only, change the demand function by assuming that demand (at any given price) is half of what it was before. In this new situation, calculate t..

Explain and categorize the cost of inflation : Because inflation has risen, the Armani clothing company decides to issue a new catalog monthly rather than quarterly. Grandpa buys an annuity for 100,000 from an insurance company which promises to pay him 10,000 a year for the rest of his life. Aft..

Most advanced form of regional integration : Although European Union is the most advanced form of regional integration, it is currently facing a challenging time. What are some of the major challenges facing the EU?

Depends inversely on the nominal interest rate : If the demand for money depends positively on real income and depends inversely on the nominal interest rate, what will happen to the price level today, if the central bank announces (and people believe) that it will decrease the money growth rate in..

Impact evaluation using an instrumental variables approach : In the 1960’s a group medical practice (Health Insurance Plan or HIP) undertook a large scale randomized trial to evaluate the effectiveness of mammography. The researchers followed the subjects for five years and recorded the number of deaths due to..

Domestic institutions play important role in globalization : While many domestic institutions play an important role in the globalization process, describe three fundamental policy measures that those countries need to promote in order to benefit from globalization. How would these policies be implemented? How..

What would be the effect on wages-inflow of foreign capital : Suppose Country A is a small open economy that takes world prices as given. What would be the effect on wages and rents in A if it were to experience an inflow of foreign capital? Use a diagram AND a table to convey your answer. Which groups would fa..

What is inflation rate and real interest rate : In the country of Dagobah, the velocity of money is constant. Real GDP grows by 3 percent per year, the money stock grows by 8 percent per year, and the nominal interest rate is 9 percent. What is: The growth rate of nominal GDP? The inflation rate? ..

Calculate the new velocity of money : An economy has the following Money demand function: (M/P)d= .4Y/i^.5 . Where i is the nominal interest rate. Calculate velocity if the nominal interest rate is 4 percent. Calculate the new velocity of money.

User Account

All Pages