How justice alito concludes that closely held for-profit

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131628035

RFRA requires that a person may be exempted from a generally applicable law if the law substantially burdens the person's exercise of religion unless the government can demonstrate that (ii) the law's burden "is in furtherance of a compelling government interest" and (ii) the law's burden "is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling government interest." 42 U.S.C. § 2000bb-1(b). The majority opinion, authored by Justice Alito, says that Congress intended in RFRA to broaden the protection of religious exercise beyond what pre-Smith cases had concluded. Justice Ginsburg's dissenting opinion says that RFRA was intended only to restore the pre-Smith jurisprudence. Explain how they reached their different conclusions.

Compare and contrast how Justice Alito concludes that closely held for-profit corporations are "persons" within the meaning of RFRA, and Justice Ginsburg concludes the opposite. Who do you think has the better argument, and why?

On the question of whether there is a substantial burden, explain how Justice Alito concludes that ACA's "mandate clearly imposes a substantial burden on [Hobby Lobby's] beliefs." Also explain how Justice Ginsburg reached her conclusion that it did not. Who do you think has the better argument, and why?

Reference no: EM131628035

Questions Cloud

How has specialization of labor or division of labor : What kinds of jobs are needed in an organization? How has specialization of labor, or division of labor,
Describe the assessment you used to analyze your skills : Describe assessment you used to analyze your skills. Discuss your communication gaps. Describe additional training you need in specific areas of communication.
Preparing for the holiday season : A small candy shop is preparing for the holiday season. The owner estimated that no more than 110 bags of one type can be sold.
Find the adjusted monthly payment including piti : The annual insurance premium on Maria Snyder's home is $2,074 and the annual property tax is $1,403. If her monthly principal and interest payment is $1,603.
How justice alito concludes that closely held for-profit : Compare and contrast how Justice Alito concludes that closely held for-profit corporations are "persons" within the meaning of RFRA
What are the stages of a corporation life cycle : What are the stages of a corporation's life cycle? How can a corporation's life cycle be extended?
Explain the impact of workplace bullying on the organization : Review the Wiedmer article regarding workplace bullying. Provide a review of article. Explain impact of workplace bullying on both victims and the organization.
Find susan blair monthly piti payment : Susan Blair has a 25-year home mortgage of $208,917 at 4.75% interest and will pay $1,798 annual insurance premium. Her annual property tax will be $2,106.
Define an undeveloped lot on a lake : Suppose you have inherited a piece of property about two hours from where you live and work, an undeveloped lot on a lake

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  During world war I-thousands of blacks moved north

During World War I, thousands of blacks moved north because

  Stocks are commonly valued using the price earnings model

Stocks are commonly valued using the Price Earnings (PE) model. Evaluate the usefulness and effectiveness of the price earnings ratios when valuing stock

  What were the long term consequences of wwi

Look through the following websites that include videos, pictures, and articles about WWI. What were the long term consequences of WWI

  Describe when it might be covered by insurance

Today's concept of "medical necessity" determines the extent to which individuals with health conditions receive health care services. "Medical necessity" is the measure of whether a procedure is appropriate for the diagnosis and the treatment of ..

  Occupational therapy issues

Which trend is reflected in the centennial vision for occupational therapy?

  What do you know about the work based on that short passage

Read the first 2-3 paragraphs of each of the four works chosen, and address the following in your summary for each piece: What do you know about the work based on that short passage? Are any characters revealed? Who are they

  Draft of all items and questionnaires

you will submit a draft of all items and questionnaires that will be given to your participants in your study.

  Write a paper addressing all three code violations

Code Violations Paper- You will compose a paper addressing all three code violations given above. You are tasked with the job of seeking repairs.

  What is the rate of change in air density in the tank

A tank contains air at P = 1200 kPa (absolute) and has a volume of 0.01 m3. The air leaves the tank at t = 0 with a speed of v = 100 m/s through a nozzle with an area of A = 50 mm2. The initial air density in the tank is p = 12 kg/m3. What is the rat..

  Problem regarding the bond valuation

Greenwich  Research  Plcissued  in  22.11.2012  a  10-year,  3.85%  coupon  bond  with coupons paid semi-annually. The bond issue is rated as A- and has a default spread of 1.65%. The Treasury yield rates are presented in the table below.

  Discuss the crime trends comparing happy town

Your report should clearly describe all the details necessary for the Chief of Police. Your answers will be judged not only on the accuracy of the information you provide, but also on how thoroughly the information is covered, how effectively the ..

  Stress and the effect it has on both our physical and our

stress and the effect it has on both our physical and our mental wellbeing. among the people what are some of the most

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd