How does the method reflect other studies of the same topic

Assignment Help Other Subject

Reference no: EM133752551

Homework: Nursing

The purpose of this homework is to demonstrate your ability to evaluate one quantitative or qualitative nursing research article of interest from any refereed nursing journal. Writing a critical review of a journal article can help to improve your writing and analytical skills. By assessing the work of others, you develop skills as a critical reader and become familiar with the types of evaluation criteria necessary to translate the evidence to practice.

I. In your introduction, you should briefly describe the purpose and nature of the study and, if applicable, its theoretical framework. If the paper was not published in a peer-reviewed journal, consider the credibility of the publication in which it appeared.

II. If you are reviewing a research study, organize the body of your critique according to the paper's structure.

III. Did the researcher identify the gaps in the knowledge?

IV. Did the researcher identify the purpose of the study?

V. Write a brief description and analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of the research design and methodology. For example:

A. How does the method reflect other studies of the same topic? (sample, data collection, setting).
B. What makes this method feasible? (quantitative, qualitative, mixed methods).
C. How realistic is it? How does the method address questions of validity? (independent, dependent variables).
D. How does the researcher overcome the limitations of the method?
E. Are there large limitations or minor ones?
F. How will these limitations affect your ability to use this data to answer your research question?

VI. Describe the results by answering:

A. How were the results interpreted?
B. How were they related to the original problem (author's view of evidence rather than objective findings)?
C. Look at DISCUSSION are the author(s) able to answer the question (test the hypothesis) raised?
D. Did the research provide new factual information, a new understanding of a phenomenon in the field, a new research technique?
E. How was the significance of the work described?
F. Did the reported observations/interpretations support or refute observations or interpretations made by other researchers?
G. Did the researcher report limitations.

VII. Describe the significance of the research by answering:

A. Did the research make a significant contribution to human knowledge?
B. Did the research produce any practical applications?
C. What are the nursing implications of this research?
D. How do you evaluate the significance of the research?

Reference no: EM133752551

Questions Cloud

What were the results of the study : What were the results of the study? Describe the findings. Did the findings support the research question(s)? Describe any limitations identified in the study.

Evaluate and discuss the training techniques : Evaluate and discuss the training techniques presented in Chapter 8 that you would use, and why, to reinforce and reintroduce St. Benedict's policy

How do expat entrepreneurs assumptions : How do expat entrepreneurs assumptions about conducting business internationally differ from those of entrepreneurs pursuing more traditional international

What is an example of a complex humanitarian emergency : What is an example of a complex humanitarian emergency in which the elements of the article apply? Discuss any ethical or unethical issues that may have arisen

How does the method reflect other studies of the same topic : How does the method reflect other studies of the same topic? How does the researcher overcome the limitations of the method?

Compute the eup for dm and cc using fifo : Compute the EUP for DM and CC using FIFO and WA methods and Compute the no. of units started & completed

Patient has postural hypotension : This patient complains of dizziness when she is moved to sitting position in wheelchair. How would the nurse determine if this patient has postural hypotension?

Which time management strategies will benefit you the most : Write a comprehensive APA analysis paper (minimum 1200 words) utilizing all the knowledge you have gained in OL3051. Use what you have learned

Visual representation of the information : visual representation of the information extracted during discussion posts and readings. discussion of the strengths and weaknesses of open sources

User Account

All Pages