High turnover among defense attorneys

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM131635998

What are the possible consequences of having high turnover among defense attorneys? Does the quality of justice decline as a result?

Case Study:

Unlike the portrayals that are commonly seen on television, criminal defense attorneys, for the most part, make very little money in comparison to other areas of legal speciali- zation, and they work long and hard hours. It is estimated that there are around 20,000 criminal defense attorneys in the United States, representing less than two-tenths of 1 percent of all attorneys in the country. So, why does a person become a criminal defense attorney and, more important, what motivates them initially to pursue such a profession. Also, why do they stay in a line of work when they lose an overwhelming majority of their cases?

McIntyre’s (1987) research revealed that for many criminal defense attorneys, the answers to these questions lie in their education, a belief in the presumption of inno- cence until proven guilty, and, in some cases, a zeal for making sure that the government proves its case against a defendant in a fair manner, a belief rooted in a legal logic and history that the adversarial system works best when the state is compelled to prove its case and not merely rely on allegation or innuendo. Remember, for the criminal defense attorney, it is not enough for the state to believe someone is guilty; they must prove that person is guilty.

McIntyre cites the fact that criminal defense attorneys are inculcated in law school that the legal system is predi- cated on the presumption of innocent until proven guilty. The criminal defense attorney learns in his or her legal train- ing that the burden of proof in a criminal trial is on the state. It is the prosecutor’s responsibility to prove his or her case; the defense attorney has to prove nothing. Holding the state to this standard is a belief that is drilled into the defense attorney in law school. What motivates the criminal defense attorney is the belief that when it comes to poten- tially depriving people of their liberty, it is paramount that the state produces evidence to meet the presumption- of-innocence threshold. Again, believing guilt is not the same as proving guilt.

This belief, as a guiding principle that motivates people to enter into criminal defense work and sustains them, is important to understand. How does a manager of criminal defense attorneys maintain enthusiasm for this belief among criminal defense lawyers? From a motivation theory perspective, much of this discussion is based on an intrinsic source for motivation, but as indicated in this chap- ter, this belief may become jaded and warped by the lack of extrinsic rewards for the work. It is commonly known that for many persons coming out of law school, criminal defense work is not the most desirable profession due, in large part, to the wages offered. Criminal defense attorneys make significantly less money in their careers, on the whole, and often cite their beliefs in fairness and the right to a criminal trial, as well as the presumption of innocence until proven guilty, as the reasons they continue to work. This is laudable. However, the strains of the profession and the lack of extrinsic rewards make motivation a critical issue for those who administer public defender offices.

In addition, the criminal trial can be a dirty process. Idealistic defense attorneys soon learn that the state is not always forthcoming and honest in its dealings with the defense. The harsh reality of the criminal court forces crim- inal attorneys to dissect and analyze the state’s case. Too many experiences and conversations with other defense attorneys reinforce the belief that the state is not to be trusted, nor should they be trusted. Whether it is poor evi- dence touted as solid evidence or even downright fraud and misrepresentation, the savvy criminal defense attorney has learned that you can’t trust the state, and it is the defense attorneys’ job to force the state to play the game fairly. For many defense attorneys, this is an important belief and keeps integrity in the criminal court process. But again, reality is a harsh teacher, and this intrinsic motivation is difficult to sustain. Given the limited extrinsic rewards avail- able to many criminal defense attorneys, how is this intrin- sic belief sustained?

Reference no: EM131635998

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  Transglutaminase expresses green marketing viewpoint

Which of the following reasons to use transglutaminase expresses a green marketing viewpoint? Which of the six modes of social control is not relevant when discussing the ethicality of transglutaminase? Which of the following might a virtue ethicist ..

  Select a developing country and describe the pattern of

a developing country wants to become more global hoping to increase the pace of its economic growth and improve the

  Will the widespread use of yield management

Will the widespread use of yield management eventually erode the concept of fixed prices for any service?

  Which function describes the expression of pleasure

In the closing of an interview, which function describes the expression of pleasure with the interaction and the projection of what will happen next?

  An important aspect of strategic planning is analyzing

An important aspect of strategic planning is analyzing the internal and external environments. Recently, a large organization completed their environmental analyses only using a very extensive SWOT process

  Use decision tree to recommend a decision

The Gorman Manufacturing Company must decide whether to purchase a component part from a supplier or to manufacture the component at its own plant. If demand is high, it would be to Gorman's advantage to manufacture the component. Use a decision tree..

  Difference between independent and dependent demand items

What is the difference between independent and dependent demand items? Why is this distinction important to inventory managers?

  Difference between negligence and intentional torts

As we get to the end of the week, let’s look more closely at the difference between negligence and intentional torts. Do not provide a definition of these theories - instead make up an example for each that illustrates the difference between them. If..

  Monitoring the performance of the mortgage process

The Money Pit Mortgage Company is interested in monitoring the performance of the mortgage process. Fifteen samples of five completed mortgage transactions each were taken during a period when the process was believed to be in control. Calculate the ..

  While working in somalia you schedule a meeting with a

while working in somalia you schedule a meeting with a vendor who lives there. when he shows up 20 minutes after the

  Explain how cultural diversity can affect the effective

Explain how cultural diversity can affect the effective functioning of virtual teams operating in a global economy.

  Reacting to a process gone wrong

Cignet Plastics Corporation is a contract plastics die-casting house serving a wide range of clients. What will you tell the president?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd