Hiding information about aliens from public

Assignment Help Other Subject

Reference no: EM133995391

Question

Consider the following answer to a question where someone is asked to create a Gettier-style counter example:

An individual, let's call her Sarah, is an avid conspiracy theorist. She has a belief that the government is hiding information about aliens from the public. She has read countless articles and watched countless videos on the topic and has spoken to other believers. She is convinced that this is true and has no doubt about it.

In this scenario, Sarah's belief that "p" (the government is hiding information about aliens from the public) satisfies all three conditions of the JTB theory:

• Sarah's belief is true (she has no doubt about it)

• Sarah's belief is justified (she has read countless articles and watched countless videos on the topic and has spoken to other believers.)

• Sarah's belief is caused by her research and speaking to other believers.

However, in this scenario, Sarah does not represent a genuine case of knowing that 'p' because her belief is based on misinformation and lack of evidence. Even though her belief is true, it is not based on any evidence or facts that can support it.

1. What grade would you give this answer (out of 10)?

2. What would be your reasons for assigning this grade?

Reference no: EM133995391

Questions Cloud

About individual rights and the value of each persons life : It can be said that utilitarianism doesn't think enough about individual rights and the value of each person's life.

Everyone should live the life of moderate pleasures : Epicurus, an ancient Greek philosopher said, Everyone should live the life of moderate pleasures.

Entirely replaced-piece by piece : Plutarch thus questions whether the ship would remain the same if it were entirely replaced, piece by piece. Centuries later,

What ethical theories and political philosopher : What ethical theories and/or political philosopher that you learned in the course will you use in your final essay.

Hiding information about aliens from public : An individual, let's call her Sarah, is an avid conspiracy theorist. She has a belief that the government is hiding information about aliens from the public

Biblical inerrancy is logical implication of inspiration : Erickson contends that belief in biblical inerrancy is a logical implication of full inspiration rather than a directly affirmed conclusion from Bible passages

Rene descartes- animals are machines : Rene Descartes, Animals are Machines. You should also make use of the various resources at your disposal.

Negatively impact the quality of person thinking : Explain how mislabeling these claims could negatively impact the quality of a person's thinking.

What has caused the successes of recent decades : According to Steven Pinker, what has caused the successes of recent decades? The inevitability of progress and the direction of time moving into the future.

User Account

All Pages