Getting a grip from prohibition to harm reduction

Reference no: EM13805628

The textbook by Kinney, Loosening the Grip, only provides brief discussions of two of the most important policy strategies for dealing with alcohol problems and their damaging consequences: prohibition and harm reduction. The online materials assigned for this week in Unit 8 of the Online Review provide additional examples and information about these alternative strategies. Based on those materials and other sources, I want you to compare and contrast these two approaches to "getting a grip" on alcohol-related problems in U.S. society.

Generally, prohibitionist policies aim to control alcohol-related problems by banning the use of alcohol. These strategies are sometimes known as "zero-tolerance" or "abstinence only" policies. The majority of alcohol treatment programs in the U.S. fall in this category, including AA and programs based on a disease model. The most notorious example of this approach is the Prohibition era, when alcohol was constitutionally banned from the U.S. from 1920-1933. The Lectures page for Unit 8 in the Online Review provides you with material on this "Great Experiment" and its implications for the more recent prohibitionist "War on Drugs."

On the other hand, harm reduction policies attempt to limit or minimize the hazardous consequences of alcohol (or drug) use without necessarily banning use itself (see Marlatt and Witkiewitz, 2010). For instance, instead of having "zero tolerance" for drinking or drug use, harm reduction strategies might include the goals of "safer use" or "managed use." Examples range from needle-exchange programs to reduce the risks of HIV infection among drug users to the sale of beer on college campuses to reduce risks of drunk driving (or walking) to-and-from off-campus bars. The Resources page for Unit 8 focuses on another example of harm reduction: the "wet house" for homeless, alcohol-dependent men.

Your comparison of prohibition and harm reduction strategies should: (1) begin with a clear discussion of their respective characteristics and differences; (2) present one or two examples of how they would deal differently with particular alcohol problems; and (3) conclude with your evaluation of the relative strengths or limitations of each approach. You can use material from Kinney, the Online Review, or other legitimate sources from publications or the internet, but be sure to cite, quote, and reference your sources properly.

Grading:

You can earn as many as 15 points by providing a clear, complete, well-documented, and well-written response to this assignment in 1,000 words (approximately two single-spaced pages) or more, not counting references. The paper will receive full credit if it is:

(a) clearly focused on the assigned topic;

(b) well-organized and systematically argued;

(d) free of grammatical errors, typos, and other stylistic problems.

I will deduct points to the extent that the paper:

(a) fails to address key elements of the assignment (deduct 1-4 points);

(b) wanders off topic or lacks coherence (deduct 1-4 points);

(d) is marked by lapses in grammar, by typos and misspelled words, or by awkward and unclear writing (deduct 1-3 points).

I will deduct two points a day for late papers. Like other assignments in the course, the paper must be your own, original work. All papers will be checked for plagiarism and other forms of academic dishonesty. Be sure that you properly cite and reference any source that you use in writing this paper.

Format:

American Psychological Association (APA) or American Sociological Association (ASA) style

Separate title page

12-point font

Single-spaced

Numbered pages

One-inch margins

Reference no: EM13805628

Questions Cloud

Confined space standard : Describe the fundamental safety and health principles behind the Confined Space Standard. Be sure to touch on what hazards the standard is designed to circumvent. In your discussion, include three examples of confined spaces that might be found in..

How analytics and cloud technology could align with company : Create a workflow diagram to illustrate how analytics and cloud technology could align with the company's business processes. Note: The graphically depicted solution is not included in the required page length but must be included in the design do..

Define the creation of the federal reserve system : The concept of Income Tax was created which was the same year as the creation of the Federal Reserve System. Do you find that this is a coincidence or are the possible implications greater

Were fallacies identified and defined correctly : Were fallacies identified and defined correctly? Are words added to make the writing logical and complete? Are verbs consistent in mood and voice?

Getting a grip from prohibition to harm reduction : Getting a Grip: From Prohibition to Harm Reduction

Revisit a musical piece : Explain how this piece "sounds" different to you now compared to when you first heard it. Remember to share the: Title of the song or musical piece Artist or composer.

How close could you get to a risk free investment with stock : How close could you get to a risk free investment with stocks? Are stocks inherently risky, so that a risk free return would not be possible?

Compute both design-effective capacity utilization measures : Joes Tasty Burger has determined that its production facility has a design capacity of 400 hamburgers per day. The effective capacity, however, is 250 hamburgers per day. Lately Joe has noticed that output has been 300 hamburgers per day. Compute bot..

Good things about value chain management : The line managers in the production department have heard a lot of good things about value chain management. They heard that you have done considerable research on this topic. They have come to your office today to discuss value chain management wi..

User Account

All Pages