Formulate a philisophical response

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13520584

Consider the following two scenerios. Formulate a philisophical response as to what you would do in each situation and give your reasons why.

Imagine you are hiking in a secluded region and you come across a group of armed thugs threatening to kill 10 people, who you strongly suspect to be perfectly innocent. The thugs capture you, and the leader gives you a choice. He says if you personally kill one of the prisoners, he will let the remaining 9 go free; otherwise, he will kill all 10. He gives you a knife and two armed thugs escort you to the prisoner. What do you suspect you would do and why?

Five of your loved ones require organ transplants to survive, but you are the only suitable organ match. If you sacrifice yourself, your organs can be used to save all of them. For the sake of the thought-experiment, assume you could legally do this. Would you do this, why or why not? Does your rationale rule out a physician sacrificing you without your consent for the same purposes?

Reference no: EM13520584

Questions Cloud

Various proofs of the existence of god : After reading about the various proofs of the existence of God, identify which of these arguments seems to be the best, and explain why you think so.
What augustine means by predestination and free will : Using quotations from On Rebuke and Grace, explain what Augustine means by “predestination” and “free will.”
Why are not there more news reports about police brutality : What issue is the speaker using to take a position in the following situation? Police brutality does not happen very often. Otherwise, it would not make headlines when it does happen. Why aren't there more news reports about police brutality?
What is real and how do we know what is real : Which answer Plato and Aristotle give to these questions: What is real And How do we know what is real? How would Aristotle explain what it is to be human?
Formulate a philisophical response : Imagine you are hiking in a secluded region and you come across a group of armed thugs threatening to kill 10 people, who you strongly suspect to be perfectly innocent. The thugs capture you, and the leader gives you a choice. He says if you perso..
Difference between subjective claims and objective claims : Explain how you would teach the difference between subjective claims and objective claims to someone who had never heard of critical thinking.
A hypothetical case : A hypothetical case and question You are a medical researcher who has discovered a means to cure mentally ill people. The people you can "cure" do not know who they are or who you are.
Is being off the grid possible in your current profession : Which specific electronic device or appliance could you not live without? Could you go “off the grid”? What might be good about going off the grid? Is being off the grid possible in your current profession?
Why bother changing a corrupt constitution : Whose advice is most practical?  Why bother changing a corrupt constitution (Politeia)?

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Discussion on truthfulness

Jesusita, eighty years old and with a bad heart, is living in a convalescent hospital where she is visited regularly by her fifty-year-old son, along with other part of the family.

  Question 1following the popularization of sustainable

question 1following the popularization of sustainable development as an environmental management concept by the

  What is the value of the sample test statistic round your

a michigan study concerning preference for outdoor activities used a questionnaire with a six-point likert-type

  Memory capacity and speed processing-pathological condition

Can someone help me understand the comparison between the declines in working memory capacity and speed of processing with a pathological condition like anterograde amnesia and the precipitous loss of semantics?

  Explain a potentially controversial aspect of the

consider the culture of your organization or an organization with which you are familiar. what is a potentially

  Extraordinarily moody

Adolescents are often thought to be extraordinarily moody, moving from joy to sadness to irritation to anger over the course of a morning or afternoon. And the source of teenage moodiness is often presumed to be the influx of hormones associated with..

  discrimination case versus the typical civil case

What is the difference between the presentation of plaintiff's proof in a discrimination case versus the typical civil case?

  Create horizontal oval towards middle top of the page

Create the horizontal oval towards middle top of the page, create two long vertical lines descending from farthest sides of oval, gently curve vertical lines.

  Explain the complexities and difficulties in enforcing

explain the complexities and difficulties in enforcing standards for lifting. use specific examples to support your

  Constitution and system of separation

Explain how the Constitution provides for a system of separation of powers and checks and balances.

  Determine problems at evco''s current system

Analyse the data collected to determine problems at Evco's current system, and the nature of the problems. You must write a report on analysis of the existing system's problems.

  The struggle of african and african americans

Identify by dates negative experiences of the three african americans and the specific methods and goals of the struggle of African and African Americans through the three distinct phases of African American history in the post columbian era.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd