Explain distinction between civil and criminal commitment

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131570246

Assignment

Thank you for offering your help

4-5 pages, APA Format paper.

Please Send me a link to the references you use, I need to be able to read them.

Please use plenty of citations from your references.

MOST IMPORTANT, please make sure all work is original, my school has a new plagiarism detection program that is very tough.

Case Study: Britney Spears

According to the text, a forensic mental health assessment refers to the practice of performing mental health evaluations to assist courts and attorneys, in the process of deciding certain matters of law applied to criminal or civil cases. In this case study, you will explore different types of forensic assessments and their application to a real world situation.

Review the case study titled "Britney Spears".

Write a three to five page paper in which you:

1. Determine whether or not you agree with the position that civil commitment violates Britney Spears' civil liberties. Provide a rationale to support your position.

2. Explain the distinction between civil commitment and criminal commitment. Next, support or criticize the premise that civil commitment was the proper course of action in the case of Britney Spears.

3. Argue for or against the theory that a short term (i.e. 72 hour) commitment provides enough time for a doctor to make a reasonable determination about the scope of the mental health problems of a patient. Provide a rationale to support your response.

4. The court ordered forensic assessments regarding Britney Spears' parenting capacity as well as her guardianship. Discuss the manner in which you believe these two assessments served the purposes of protecting the patient, protecting her children, and protecting the public. Provide a rationale to support your response.

5. Use at least three quality references. Note: Wikipedia and other related websites do not qualify as academic resources.

Your assignment must follow these formatting requirements:

• Be typed, double spaced, using Times New Roman font (size 12), with one-inch margins on all sides; citations and references must follow APA or school-specific format. Check with your professor for any additional instructions.

• Include a cover page containing the title of the assignment, the student's name, the professor's name, the course title, and the date. The cover page and the reference page are not included in the required assignment page length.

The specific course learning outcomes associated with this assignment are:

• Demonstrate basic knowledge of the different elements and aspects of forensic psychology.
• Brief and debate historic cases associated with mental health and forensic psychology.
• Distinguish between clinical, actuarial, and other prediction and evaluation methods used by forensic psychologists in legal cases.
• Use technology and information resources to research issues related to forensic psychology.
• Write clearly and concisely about topics related to forensic psychology using proper writing mechanics and technical style conventions.

CASE STUDY

Britney Jean Spears was born to be an entertainer. Even as a child, she was a star: At age 10, she began appearing on television programs such as Star Search and The New Mickey Mouse Club. At age 17, she completed her debut album, ... Baby One More Time, and quickly became one of the world's most famous and best-selling singer-entertainers. But she is also a tragic figure whose highly publicized personal problems, which may stem at least in part from a history of mental disorder and substance use, have led to numerous appearances in civil courts. Spears has appeared twice in court seeking to terminate marriages. Her first marriage, to long-time friend Jason Allen Alexander, took place on January 3, 2004. She was 22 years old at the time. Two days later, she filed a complaint with the Clark County (Nevada) District Court seeking annulment on the grounds that she "lacked understanding of her actions to the extent that she was incapable of agreeing to marriage because before entering into the marriage the Plaintiff [Spears] and Defendant [Alexander] did not know each other's likes and dislikes, each other's desires to have or not have children, and each other's desires as to State of residency." The annulment was granted after only 55 hours of marriage. (For further information, see article: Britney Spears Files For Annulment). Spears' second marriage, to Kevin Federline, took place later that year on September 18, 2004 (although the necessary legal documents were not filed until October 6, 2004). Spears and Federline had two sons together: Sean, born September 14, 2005, and Jayden, born September 12, 2006. But Spears began to behave erratically during her marriage to Federline, including an infamous incident in which she was photographed driving her car while holding a baby in her lap, without any proper restraints. She also expressed unhappiness with her marriage in media interviews and eventually filed for divorce in November 2006, citing irreconcilable differences. This started a legal battle, with both Spears and Federline seeking custody of the children.

The couple reached an agreement in March 2007 and their divorce was finalized a few months later. Spears' problems worsened after her divorce. She attended a substance use treatment facility in February 2007, then shaved her head completely bald with electric clippers a few hours after checking out. After a few days, she attended and completed an inpatient substance use treatment program. Her ex-husband, Federline, was concerned about her parenting capacity and requested an emergency court hearing regarding custody, but later cancelled the appearance. A detailed custody evaluation was conducted by a California psychologist, Dr. Jane Shatz, the results of which were released in a 700-page report submitted by Dr. Shatz. The court reached a decision in September 2007 that Spears and Federline would continue to have joint custody of their two children, with conditions placed on Spears including random testing for drug and alcohol use and attendance at counseling. Despite the court-ordered conditions, Spears continued to have problems, including being charged with hit-and-run and driving without a license. In October 2007, Federline was granted full custody of both children. But after Spears ignored the court order, police were called to her residence in January 2008. The children were placed in Federline's custody and Spears, who reportedly had not slept for several days, was hospitalized and held two days for an emergency mental health evaluation. As a result of this evaluation, a series of legal decisions imposed new conditions on Spears: She was involuntarily hospitalized due to mental disorder; her visitation rights were suspended indefinitely; and conservatorship (that is, control of her business and financial decisions) was granted to her father and attorney. In addition, a restraining order was granted that forbade a former business associate, who was suspected of exerting a negative influence on Spears, from having contact with her. (Subsequently, additional restraining orders were placed on two former associates.)

The case of Britney Spears is an excellent illustration of how the civil justice system can be used to help resolve many different difficult situations, ranging from family disputes to concerns over people's ability to manage their own business affairs or make decisions about health care. It also illustrates how psychologists (and other mental health professionals) can assist the justice system to resolve these disputes. Although the results of Spears' mental health assessment and treatment remain private, there has been considerable speculation that she suffered from mood and substance-related disorders that played a major role in her personal problems. The good news is that there appears to have been a slow but steady improvement in her personal problems since her hospitalization in early 2008. She has regained some visitation rights, and the charges against her in connection with the motor vehicle accident were dismissed. She has even regained some of her former glory as an entertainer: Her 2008 album, Circus, and the associated concert tour had excellent sales, garnered her widespread acclaim, and received numerous awards. Hopefully, the worst of Britney's troubles are behind her.

Reference no: EM131570246

Questions Cloud

Basic concepts of government and the political economy : Why is it necessary for us to study politics as a scientific discipline? Of all the sub-fields under political science which subfield appeals to you most?
Calculate the average length of stay for adults : Calculate (round to one decimal place) the average length of stay (ALOS) for adults and children for the month of October
Explain the factor necessary to ensure referential integrity : Determine and explain the factors necessary to ensure referential integrity.Create an object-oriented model to show how the tables are interrelated.
The coming of the new organization : Based upon the assigned readings (Drucker's "The coming of the New Organization" and Zahra's "The changing rules of global competitiveness.
Explain distinction between civil and criminal commitment : Explain the distinction between civil commitment and criminal commitment. Explain the distinction between civil commitment and criminal commitment.
What are the differences in the cognitive ideas of erikson : What are the differences in the cognitive ideas of erikson
Discussion-putting new fizz in carbonated beverages : SodaStream is revolutionizing a product that, for decades, did not seem to need or have room for a new and innovative idea.
Differentiate public key and a private key cryptosystem : Explain why using shift ciphers is a private key system.
Probably aware of at least one presenter : You are probably aware of at least one presenter who has "blanked out" during an important speaking situation.

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Ethical theories most accurately describes

Danny always considers how he would feel in another person’s place before he takes any action. Then, Danny only acts in accord with how she would want others to behave in the same circumstances. Which of the following ethical theories most accurat..

  The average us daily internet use at home is two hours and

the average u.s. daily internet use at home is two hours and twenty minutes. a sample of 64 homes in soddy daisy showed

  Which disorders are best treated by each therapy

Write an essay to distinguish the differences between the following psychological therapies: 1) Psychoanalysis/Psychodynamic, 2) Humanistic, 3) Behavior, 4) Cognitive and 5) Cognitive Behavioral.

  What is the conflict perspective in sociology

What is the purpose of sociological theory? What is the functionalist perspective? What are the three sociological perspectives? What is the conflict perspective in sociology

  Msw is all of the garbage refuse trash or junk that gets

msw is all of the garbage refuse trash or junk that gets thrown away from homes and small businesses. all of this msw

  Describe the organizational structure of your selected

1 explain the relationship between organizational functions and organizational structures.write a 1050- to 1400-word

  Education is primarily funded through a state-local

Summarize arguments for and against local control and full state funding of public education. (Treat each separately). Education is primarily funded through a state-local partnership with supplemental funding in specific areas from the Federal gove..

  Better way of thinking about that particular situation

You can rely on specific examples from your life, the lives of people you know, the media, books, or movies. After you describe the example, discuss a better way of thinking about that particular situation. Draw on the research from the textbook o..

  Strengths and weaknesses of articles of confederation

Describe the strengths and weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation. Why didn't the Articles of Confederation have more than one branch of government? What important powers did the Confederation Congress lack?

  Properly of particular importance to a group’s leader

Why is failure to delegate thoroughly and properly of particular importance to a group’s leader? Provide several possible reasons.

  Does mary research involve a theory of correlation

Does Mary's research involve a theory of correlation, causation, or both? Provide reasoning to support your choice. Is this an example of applied or pure research? Does it involve primary or secondary research? Explain your answers

  The information about segmentation

Do you think that the information about segmentation is enough to develop a segmentation scheme for the brand?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd