Evaluate the federalist and anti-federalist arguments

Assignment Help Other Subject

Reference no: EM132415780

Assignment: Too Big to Fail? Democratic Republics and the Federalist/AntiFederalist Debate

In the wake of the Constitutional Convention, a ratification debate took place in each of the thirteen United States. Numerous essays were published in newspapers and pamphlets arguing for the adoption of the Constitution (a collection known as the Federalist Papers). An equally numerous, though less centrally-organized, group of essays were published in the same fashion and opposed ratification of the Constitution.

Read all four documents provided in the Scenario Files folder:

Excerpts from Brutus I

Excerpts from Cato III

The Federalist Papers-Congress No. 10

The Federalist Papers-Congress No. 51

Evaluate the Federalist/Anti-Federalist arguments with respect to the central question: Is the United States governable as a large republic?

Write a response to the question, Is the United States governable as a large republic? in the form of an op-ed, similar to those that appear in major newspapers. Your op-ed must address the following:

• What position did the Federalist and Anti-Federalists take with respect to whether or not the newly formed United States was too large to be ruled by the people?

• What types of evidence did opponents of ratification provide to support their argument that the United States was too large to govern?

• According to the Federalists, what mechanisms did the Constitution provide to assuage the concerns of those who thought the United States was too large to govern?

• Is the Federalist or Anti-Federalist argument more convincing?

• If the authors of these essays were alive today, would they still believe their original arguments regarding the Constitution, the size of the United States, and the ability of a democratic republic to function? Why or why not?

Your op-ed should be no longer than 2 pages (excluding headers and references which should be on Page 3). It should include a clearly developed thesis statement, as well as references. A sample op-ed is provided for you in the Scenario Files.

Reference no: EM132415780

Questions Cloud

Evaluate the authors use of literature : Evaluate the authors' use of literature using the Use of Literature Checklist as a guide. Evaluate the problem using the Problem Statement Checklist as a guide.

Overall process for changing the constitution : Please explain the overall process for changing the Constitution and how this process makes it difficult to change the document, and why did the Founding Father

What professional growth occurred during development : Reflect on the development of your professional portfolio. What went well? What surprised you? What professional or personal growth occurred during.

Which one might be viewed as least important : Which one might be viewed as least important? Could a governor be successful if they only focused on the more important role and neglected the least important?

Evaluate the federalist and anti-federalist arguments : In the wake of the Constitutional Convention, a ratification debate took place in each of the thirteen United States. Numerous essays were published.

Write a policy memo to the secretary of the interior : Write a Policy Memo to the Secretary of the Interior. The goal of this memo is to influence the recommendation the Secretary makes to the President with respect

Issues confronting the federal bureaucracy : One of the issues confronting the federal bureaucracy today is a popular belief that people who work in the civil service must be partisans.

Describe the labour process : Describe the labour process and why it was important for employers

Describe things to understand the reasons for the diversity : We have seen, too, that the world's great religious traditions are also characterized by diversity. Tell me about those things in the course that help us.

User Account

All Pages