Ethical reasoning

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM1378863

Can someone help me with setting an ethical argument for the victim's family and the DA in the following situation?

Joe drove the getaway car during a bank robbery in which a teller was killed. Joe was caught and sentenced to twenty-fiv years to life under California's "three strikes" law.

15-years into his sentence -- gaunt, wheelchair bound and tethered to an oxygen tank -- he has been diagnosed with a terminal disease and three competent physicians from outside the prison system have certified he has less than 6 months to live.

A special meeting of the parole board is called.

His family argues a moral ideal -- for his "compassionate release" so he can die at home with his family.

The victim's family and the DA argue obligation & consequences -- that he should die in confinement in accordance with the sentence of the trial judge.

Assume you are in a court of ethics, not law.

Use ethical reasoning skills to argue the victim's family and the DA's side. Leave personal biases, culture, or religion as well as the experiences of all of your friends, neighbors and relatives at the door. Think obligations, moral values and consequences.

 

Reference no: EM1378863

Questions Cloud

Discussion on deontological system of ethics : Give two examples of how this theory intersect with your personal values 2-different hypothecial examples. Two good paragraphs should be sufficient.
Falling letters game : Generic queue in the first project and generic list in the second project - In the second project, the player clicks the mouse on any falling letter to remove that letter from the window.
Explain how the outcome is ethical : Think about the moral ideals presented through the facts, the obligations of the parties to one another and consequences of alternative actions in reaching a determination.
Theories in philosophy : Discuss some of the conventional models, theories, and practices embodied in philosophy, culture, and common sense that we typically draw on and make use of in creating a realistic objective image of ourselves and the world in which we live?
Ethical reasoning : Joe drove the getaway car during a bank robbery in which a teller was killed. Joe was caught and sentenced to twenty-fiv years to life under California's 3-strikes law.
Which component of freud personality theory does refelect : For as long as he can remember, Randy's passion in life has been to eat, drink, and be merry. Which component of Freud's personality theory does this reflect.
In which techniques is she likely engaging : Susan is sitting quietly, observing flow of thoughts, sensations, and awareness's going through her mind without attempting to control her mind. In which techniques is she likely engaging.
Finding which marijuana use is likely to increase onset : Finding which marijuana use is likely to increase onset of schizophrenic symptoms in those who have a genetic predisposition to disorder is likely due to effect.
Compare and contrast approaches of development of brain : Compare and contrast approaches of development of brain and of human of Carlson text to Tripartite Man's approach. Consider both scientific approach and biblical approach in your discussion.

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Sexually transmitted diseases

It has been reported that teenage pregnancy has been declining in the U.S. while incidence of Sexually Transmitted Diseases are on the rise within this age population.

  Social distribution of health and illness

what is the relationship between knowledge and power and how does this influence the social distribution of health and illness?

  Decisions of civil and criminal court

One court ruled NOT GUILTY while another one awarded damages against him for killing his wife? How's that possible?

  It is important for an organization to investigate workplace

Explain why it is important for an organization to investigate workplace accidents Outline the factors that would influence the level of investigation required following a workplace accident

  Indigenous religions and primal religions

Discuss and explain why are indigenous religions no longer called primitive religions; instead, they are now called primal religions?

  Overview of factors comprised with youth sport

What positive and negative factors are involved in youth sport? What are the reasons children give for participating in or withdrawing from sport?

  Effects of different drugs

You're interested in finding out more about the effects of different drugs . For each of the following drugs: amphetamine, MDMA (ecstasy), and nicotine, use your available resources to research those drug and then discuss the following:

  Diagnosis of aspergers

Describe the impact and effects of psychopathology on family functioning; how would a diagnosis of asperger's on one family member affect the functioning of the couple or family as a whole?

  Discussing the decision of the court in this case

Prepare a 350- to 700-word paper discussing the decision of the court in this case. Was it fair and defensible from an ethical viewpoint? If so, then why? If not, why not?

  Attention and consciousness

Describe how theories of attention apply to the situation, and point out the social and /or cultural factors that might influence attention in both this situation and others.

  Describing mcnamara-ohara service contract act

What is the significance of The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 with regard to SCA? How are minimum prevailing wage rates incorporated into the contract? Are those same rates paid throughout the contract performance?

  Cognition and neuroscience

Cognition and neuroscience are two vastly different schools. Why do you think it is beneficial to explain behavior and conditioning by combining the two?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd