Do our motivations matter when it comes to morality

Assignment Help Other Subject

Reference no: EM133939971

Problem: Fareed philosophy

Utilitarianism

In the reading this week on Utilitarianism, one of the points made about the theory is that it does not take motivation into account. Mill states, "He who saves a fellow creature from drowning does what is morally right, whether his motive be duty or the hope of being paid for his trouble." He says this to underscore the idea that as long as you achieve the greatest happiness for the greatest number, then "why" you did it doesn't matter. Get the instant assignment help.

What do you think about this? Do our motivations matter when it comes to morality? Are we less moral if we act for less than noble reasons, such as the hope of being paid? Are we more moral if we act simply out of the duty to our fellow human beings?

Think about yourself--what motivates you to act morally? Does it affect how you feel about what you've done? Have you ever done something right without expecting praise or recognition? Finally, should our motivations or intentions matter, or as Mill argues, just the results?

Reference no: EM133939971

Questions Cloud

How has your vision of health informatics changed : Would you still choose the role that you chose in week one or has this course led you down a different path as an informaticist?

What might you say to help tania normalise : What might you say to help Tania normalise and understand the possible link between her substance use and traumatic experiences?

Discuss impacts of each from an epidemiological standpoint : Can this step be worked in tandem with other steps or must it be done independently (or even temporarily) to successfully investigate an outbreak?

Why does God the Father change in appearance : Why does God the Father change in appearance? What options does Papa propose to Mack after the burial?

Do our motivations matter when it comes to morality : Do our motivations matter when it comes to morality? Are we less moral if we act for less than noble reasons, such as the hope of being paid?

What are your predictions for changes in american policing : Given the ongoing debates about police accountability and reform, what are your predictions for changes in American policing?

What role does criminal law play in each part of the system : What role does Criminal Law play in each part of the system? How do Law enforcement, the Courts, and Corrections utilize law in their work?

Discuss the Victor Frankl excerpt : Discuss the Victor Frankl excerpt. How the atrocities of Auschwitz, Treblinka, and Maidenek are, etc. the fruits of Nihilism

Which feature that can be applied to adaptive behavior : Which feature that can be applied to adaptive behavior instruction in natural environments follows, "use of numerous behavior analytic procedures used to build

User Account

All Pages