Discuss the moral issues at stake in the famous so-called

Assignment Help Other Subject

Reference no: EM133362508

Question: Texas has a law that prohibits the removal of mechanical life-support such as a ventilator from a pregnant patient.

In November 2013, when Marlise Munoz was 14 weeks pregnant she was found unconscious in her Texas home. With her husband and family in deep distress, they rushed her to a hospital where she was placed on a machine to keep her alive. Soon thereafter, doctors at the hospital pronounced her brain dead. Her husband and family eventually asked that she be removed from life support but Texas law prohibits removing a pregnant woman from life support if it threatens the life of the fetus. A Texas Judge has now ordered that the 22 week pregnant woman removed from life support, as requested by the family. For background, click here: LINK Links to an external site..

[1] From a utilitarian moral perspective of the greatest good of the greatest number and also the utilitarian evaluative criteria of happiness versus suffering, explain the rightness or wrongness of a law that prohibits the removal of a pregnant woman from life support. Also discuss the sad case of Marlise Munoz with someone else for how that person feels about it and what moral concerns s/he has about this particular case. Do you think that the husband of Marlise Munoz should only be granted his request to remove his wife because he has concerns about indications of severe abnormalities in the developing fetus but not if the fetus were perfectly normal? Explain.

[2] In terms utilitarian ethics, discuss the moral issues at stake in the famous so-called Trolley Problem as related in the eText and also Michael Sandel's Harvard lecture (LINK Links to an external site.), where "you are beside a train track with a train headed down the track. However, on the track ahead are five people who will all be killed if the train continues. But you also have access to a switch, and if you pull it the train will be diverted onto another track where there is only one person" (eText p.36). Do you think that this type of moral choice between the lesser of evils as in this Trolley Problem is realistic to what we might face in our everyday lives or places of employment? Do you think there is such a thing as a moral duty to choose between the lesser of evils? Why or why not? Can you give an example to support your point?

Reference no: EM133362508

Questions Cloud

Describe what is found in each kingdom : List the levels of order found in living things, beginning with an atom and culminating with the ecosystem.

What we have learned about the law : What are the differences and or similarities of what we have learned about the law, as compared to your favourite crime drama? explain the following factor

Why is that impossible - find on the internet : find on the internet is that, during cellular respiration, the oxygen (O2) we breathe in is "converted into carbon dioxide (CO2)". Why is that impossible

How would this affect the human and microbiota : how would this affect the human and microbiota as individuals? Would the human gut be less reliable or consistent, or would there be another outcome

Discuss the moral issues at stake in the famous so-called : Do you think that this type of moral choice between the lesser of evils as in this Trolley Problem is realistic to what we might face in our everyday lives

What anesthetic agent may cause pawing at the face : What anesthetic agent may cause pawing at the face and chewing of the feet and What injectable anesthetic agents can be safely administered repeated

What is the genotype for an individual who is homozygous : What is the genotype for an individual who is homozygous dominant for unattached earlobes? Case and order of alleles matter

What determines how the state must process cases : Procedural law is what determines how the state must process cases. Are these rights being upheld for the fraternity members, despite the appeals to the case?

Calculate your 25 kg canine patient has lost 6 - 4x4 gauze : calculate your 25 kg canine patient has lost 6 - 4x4 gauze squares of blood. Calculate if this is significant for this patient. (Show work)

User Account

All Pages