Determine the soundness and validity of the article

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131270537

(1)This discussion question deals with the lack of proper premises, or the lack of a proper conclusion. Please think of a recent situation in which you have encountered hidden premises or a hidden conclusion. Please identify either the missing premises or the missing conclusion of the argument.

For example, the philosopher Peter Singer suggests that we are morally responsible for saving people who are starving in the world. The missing premise would be a premise connecting morality to the duty of providing for starving people.

Also, you should google Peter Singer for a more complete understanding of his argument on our moral duty to those in poverty. What are your thoughts on his argument?

(2)A sound argument is valid (correctly formed) and has all true premises. Your book discuss several ways to test the soundness of an argument. Now it is your turn to apply the tests. Go to a website that provides a contemporary issue, such as the Huffington Post. Find a brief article that contains a clear argument.

Identify the premises and how they support the conclusion. Please provide substantial detailing for the premises and the argument.

After you have completed your analysis, please put the premises into a standard form argument.

Premise one

Premise two

Conclusion

Evaluate the argument for its soundness. Determine the soundness and validity of the article and link the article at the end of your response by copying its Web address.

For example, the philosopher Robert Nozick makes the argument that taxation is akin to forced labor. If a person is required to work for the benefit of others against his or her will, then Nozick suggests the labor is forced. By imposing taxation on people, the U.S. government is forcing them to work for the benefit of others against their wills. Therefore, the U.S. government is subjecting its tax-paying citizens to forced labor. Do you agree? Why or why not?

(3) Case study due on wednesday @1900

Abortion is murder, because murder is intentionally killing an innocent person. Therefore, abortion is wrong.

Explicit premises:

Implicit premises:

The rate of drowning increases with the rate of ice cream eating. Therefore, ice cream eating leads to drowning.

Explicit premises:

Implicit premises:

Determine whether the conclusion follows from the premises:

No cats are pleasant creatures. This is a mouse. Since it is not a cat, it is a pleasant creature.

Determine whether the argument is sound or unsound. Then determine whether each argument is valid or invalid.

All cats are feral. Tabitha is a cat. Tabitha is feral.

Show that the argument is invalid.

Using the Counterexample Method, show that the argument's conclusion does not follow:

"If I score an A on the test, then I will pass the class." "I passed the class!" "Therefore I scored an A on the test."

Identify both the explicit and implicit premises of the argument presented. Assess whether the premises of the argument presented should be accepted or rejected.

Killing people is always wrong. Euthanasia is an example of one person killing another. Therefore, it is clear that euthanasia is wrong, and should continue to be illegal.

Reference no: EM131270537

Questions Cloud

Cloud technology and virtualization : Cloud Technology and Virtualization- With the merger of your company with a multinational company, you have come to realize that progressive solutions are necessary to defray some of the associated information technology costs.
Determine the pumping power required : Assuming no change in water pressure and the water temperature constant at 300 K, determine the pumping power required if the water experiences a change in elevation of 15 m.
Do you think that kids from urban working-class environment : While the Stanford Prison experiment is considered unethical, what usefulness has come from the experimental outcomes? Was it right to trade the suffering experienced by participants for the knowledge gained by the research? Explain how the experi..
Modify the menu function to accept its parameters from file : Modify the menu function to accept its parameters from a file. Rewrite thepr1function asprx that will behave in the manner ofpr4from Chapter 8 but will take an option for any number of columns.
Determine the soundness and validity of the article : If a person is required to work for the benefit of others against his or her will, then Nozick suggests the labor is forced. By imposing taxation on people, the U.S. government is forcing them to work for the benefit of others against their wills...
Find the power required to drive the compressor : Potential energy change and heat exchange with the environment are negligible. Determine the power required to drive the compressor
Determine the mass flow of the cooling water : Any heat loss from the water jacket may be ignored and all kinetic and potential energy changes are negligible. Determine the mass flow of the cooling water in the water jacket.
Explore the vital statistics in you respective state health : Visit the CDC National Center for Health Statistics to explore national vital statistic results with a focus on birth rates, death rates and cancer rates. Next, explore the vital statistics in you respective state health departments.
What is the patient volume needed per month : If a new technologist aide is hired, what is the patient volume needed per month at the original reimbursement rate to variable costs, but not profit?

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Who knows about the t test for a single sample

At the .01 significance level is there a difference in the mean amount purchased on an impulse at the two stores? Explain these results to a person who knows about the t test for a single sample but is unfamiliar with the t test for independent me..

  What do you think are the limits of human freedom

What do you think are the limits of human freedom? What might make it IMPOSSIBLE for a person to keep a secret? (You may consider historical examples in your answer to this question.)

  Moving average forecasting models are powerful tools that

moving average forecasting models are powerful tools that help managers in making educated forecasting decisions. a

  What will account for seans low plasma na+

What gland is primarily affected if ACTH does not cause a normal elevation of cortisol secretion? What is this abnormality known as? What gland is primarily affected if ACTH does cause an elevation of cortisol secretion.

  Body proportions change during early childhood

What statement best describes how body proportions change during early childhood?

  Institutionalized system of social inequality

Critically discuss the various ways socializing agents might contribute to the institutionalized system of social inequality. Provide a few examples to support your answer.

  Cathy claims that utilitarianism is consequentialist theory

Cathy claims that utilitarianism is a consequentialist theory. .Act Utilitarianism judges that an act is right based o. According to Act Utilitarianism, the following claim is most applicable:

  What view of the earth does the gaia hypothesis offer

What is nature? What view of the Earth does the Gaia hypothesis offer? Why did (for some, does) the word "alive" provoke controversy

  Does it work toward social responsibility

What does the company do right? What are its values? Give examples of how it treats its employees. Does it work toward social responsibility?

  Station model for both temperature and pressure

Encode a temperature of 42°F and a pressure of 1017.0mb. Encode a temperature of 101°F and a pressure of 1003.4mb. Decode the following station model for both temperature and pressure: 36O131 (Note: 36 is on the left and 131 is on the right)

  Questions raised about what good means

How does raising awareness and provoking the discussion of policy options contribute to attaining the common "good"?

  What are some of the challenges you have had so far as you

1. what are some of the challenges you have had so far as you research bullying? what are some ways you can overcome

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd