Consequences of the action

Reference no: EM1378705

Kant's ethics relies upon the intent of an action as solely determinate of its moral worth, regardless of the consequences of the action. Consider the following thought experiment in these terms.

(1) A child is drowning in the lake. A stranger jumps into save the child. He succeeds in saving the childâ?"but the reason that he jumped in to get the child was not to save the childâ?"but rather to be seen as heroic to his girlfriend, with whom he was lunching by the lake.

(2) A child is drowning in the lake. A stranger jumps into save the child. But he's not as good a swimmer as he had thought. In his frantic state, he attempts to reach out to the child and submerges him or her. While he jumped in with the intent of saving the child, he fails to do soâ?"and instead only succeeds in pulling the child's lifeless body from the water.

The first case seems to have the right consequences, but the wrong moral intent. The second case has the right intent, but a poor outcome.
(A) What would Kant say about case #1? Is it a moral act? Why or why not?
(B) Do you agree or disagree with what Kant would say about case #1? If so, why or why not?
(C) What would Kant say about case #2? Is it a moral act? Why or why not?
(D) Do you agree or disagree with what Kant would say about case #2? If so, why or why not?

Reference no: EM1378705

Questions Cloud

Determining the moral worth : It is snowing. Two people drive home from work in opposite directions down nation roads. Both slide in the snow, and run off road.

Identify the numerous cybercrimes that would apply : Identify the numerous cybercrimes that would apply in a business setting? Offer a scenario by way of example that will demonstrate to your colleagues a situation that might take place and explain how it must be managed to protect the business

Understanding of cybercrimes that we see in the business : Comprehensive the following placing it in a single Word document For your final task in this contractual theme this week you will deliver your department with an understanding of cybercrimes that we see in the business world

What proportion of the population would score higher : what proportion of the population would score higher than Bob and what proportion of commutes would be longer than 80 minutes and less than 50 minutes?

Consequences of the action : Kant's ethics believes upon the intent of an action as solely determinate of its moral worth, regardless of the consequences of the action.

Genocide is the deliberate as well as systematic destruction : Genocide is the deliberate as well as systematic destruction of an ethnic, racial or national group, such as the Turkish killing of Armenians after WWI the Nazis' slaughter of 6 million European Jews during WWII or the mass killings in Rwanda in 1..

Explain defining a new innovation : Explain Defining a New Innovation Please respond to the subsequent One of the dilemmas faced by entrepreneurs is defining a new product or identifying

Calculate ebay''s fee structure : Calculate eBay's fee structure. Is it optimum or could it be improved? Why? How? What's next for eBay? How does it continue to produce when it needs both buyers and sellers?

Ethics in medical : A woman was near death from a special kind of cancer. There was one drug that doctors thought might save her. It was a form of radium that a pharmacist in the same town had recently found.

User Account

All Pages