Skills of legal writing, Business Law and Ethics

You are a Graduate Legal Officer employed in the Constitutional Policy Unit of the Australian Attorney-General's Department. Until this point, your supervisor, Rodger Dodger, has paid you little attention, and you have not yet been asked to prepare an advice. However, it is the day after 'National Party Day' and all other staff in the Unit have called in sick.   The Attorney-General contacts your supervisor and requests urgent and immediate advice on proposed legislation. The email from the Attorney-General requesting advice is as follows:

---------------------------------------------------

Sent: 1:50PM

To: Rodger Dodger

---------------------------------------------------

G'day Rodger

Another big day in Federal Parliament, mate. The Federal Opposition has put forward the Stop the Boats Bill (2012). Given we've got a hung parliament; it's looking like the Stop the Boats Bill (2012) will get through the House of Representatives and the Senate. The Prime Minister wants to know if the legislation is constitutionally valid, or if there are grounds on which we might successfully challenge the constitutional validity of the legislation if it gets through. Specifically, Section 5 of the Bill provides: 

(1) If any marine vessel with persons aboard who do not possess valid documentation for lawful entry into Australia, approaches Australian territorial waters with the intent to enter Australian territory, or enters Australian territory, that vessel shall be forcibly removed from Australian waters by Australian military vessels, or other military equipment which may be deemed necessary.

(2) Any person in Australiawho:

a) Comments publicly on an event occurring pursuant to subsection 1 commits an offence; or

b) Provides assistance to any person on board a vessel which would be subject to section 5(1) or 5(2) above,  is liable to a maximum of 12 months imprisonment. 

Please prepare a comprehensive legal opinion advising whether section 5 is supported by 51(xxix) of the Constitution of Australia, and/or whether there are any grounds for challenging the constitutional validity of this legislation, and if so, what the counter arguments might be, and what the Court would likely conclude. Please also advise if the situation would be different if the legislation were introduced by the State of Queensland.

Please have this advice to my office by COB today. And keep that unit of yours under control too. I heard they were rather rowdy at the National Party Day festivities!

Yours,

Robby McC

Please prepare a comprehensive legal opinion advising whether section 5 is supported by 51(xxix) of the Constitution of Australia, and/or whether there are any grounds for challenging the constitutional validity of this legislation, and if so, what the counter arguments might be, and what the Court would likely conclude. Please also advise if the situation would be different if the legislation were introduced by the State of Queensland. Please have this advice to my office by COB today. And keep that unit of yours under control too. I heard they were rather rowdy at the National Party Day festivities!

Your supervisor asks you to prepare the advice. You realize this is your big chance to impress your supervisor and show him your legal research and writing skills far exceed your ability to organise the branch morning tea every fortnight. On the basis of your excellent legal education at Bond University, you know a constitutional legal advice should be well structured, well researched, contain practical solutions and provide an executive summary at the beginning of the document.

Posted Date: 2/20/2013 3:07:13 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Skills of legal writing, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Skills of legal writing, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Skills of legal writing Discussions

Write discussion on Skills of legal writing
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Important points - Contractual Capacity of Drunken Persons Here the following points should be notice for as: Ratification Well a drunken man who enters into

Question 1: (i) Distinguish between industrial relations and employee relations. (ii) State the environmental factors that affect employee relations. (iii) Give five r

Q. Diffrence between phoenix activity and  honest behaviour? There are circumstances where a business has been managed responsibly and fails, and after a period of time, its di

Registration of Resolutions: By S.143(1) a printed copy of the following resolutions shall, within 30 days after the passing thereof, be delivered to the registrar for registr

Directors' Remuneration: For technical reasons the directors are not regarded as servants or employees of the company of that they are directors. Therefore  here they have no

QUESTION John, an employee, at Mauricia Travel Ltd, wishes to set up a trade union. He has been told that trade unions are very beneficial to employees and if trade unions and

Form of reconstruction: Where one company transfers its undertaking (and assets) to another company in exchange for shares to be alloted direct or distributed to the members o

Define  Accession and ratification Another area/aspect that needs to be highlighted with regards to a Treaty is the difference between signing and ratifying a particular treaty

Powers of the Attorney General Whereas under sec 26(3) the Attorney General is empowered for as; Undertake and Institute criminal proceedings against any person b

Liability of auditors: It would cover any act of negligence - any actionable wrong by an officer of a company which did not involve any misapplication of the assets of the com