Remedies of the ultra vires lender, Business Law and Ethics

Remedies of the Ultra Vires Lender:

                         In Sinclair v Brougham (26) the House of Lords explained that no action or suit lies at law or in equity to recover money lent to a company which has borrowed for an ultra vires purpose. This means that the ultra vires lender cannot sue, as lender, to recover the money he lent to the company. However, he might avail himself of one or other of the following remedies which were summarised by Buckley, J. in Re Birkbeck Permanent Benefit Building Society:

i.        If the result of the transaction is that the indebtedness of the company is not increased because the new loan was applied in discharging an old debt, the invalid lender can be treated as standing in the place of those whose debts have been paid off. In such a case the ultra vires loan "is not to be regarded as a borrowing transaction".

ii. The aforesaid remedy would also be available if the loan was applied in discharging a future debt (ie an indebtedness which was incurred after the money was borrowed).

The basis of this remedy is that, since the company could legally become indebted in respect of the future debt, the lender whose money discharged it would be subrogated to the rights of the discharged creditor. However, he would be entitled to rank as a creditor of the company only to the extent to which his money was applied in discharging the intra vires debt and would not obtain the benefit of any security held by the intra vires creditor (although he would be entitled to enforce any security which was given to him).

iii.  If the lender can identify his money or the investment of his money in the hands of the borrowing company, he can call for its return.

The basis of this remedy was explained by Lord Parker in Sinclair v Brougham (26) as follows:

"A company or other statutory association cannot by itself or through an agent be party to an ultra vires act. If its directors or agents affecting to act on its behalf borrow money which it has no power to borrow, the money borrowed is in their hands the property of the lender."

iv.  If the lender cannot bring himself within any of the above propositions he would have no remedy except to participate in the division of the company's surplus assets, if any, which would be divisible among the ultra vires creditors rateably during the company's liquidation after all the company's members have received back their capital in full.

Posted Date: 1/12/2013 2:38:01 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Remedies of the ultra vires lender, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Remedies of the ultra vires lender, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Remedies of the ultra vires lender Discussions

Write discussion on Remedies of the ultra vires lender
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Commercial Law Alice is an 80 year old, illiterate, and suffering from Alzheimer’s disease (a disease affecting short-term memory). Will is a social worker employed by the loc

Explain the Cotton Arbitration Arbitration is a more formal process than mediation and conciliation. Arbitration can take place between two states or individuals of two states

Two very important resolutions which had a great impact on description of terrorism UNSC has also declared incitement as an offence. The interpretation of terrorism formulated

QUESTION 1 Describe the Public Procurement Legal Framework of Mauritius QUESTION 2 Explain the following, within the meaning of the Competition Act: a. collusive agreem

State succession concerns international organizations Issue regarding state succession concerns international organizations. There are more than 30,000 treaties entered into be

Registers and documents - registered office: The following registers and documents are also kept at the company's registered office:- i.             The register of members

phoenix activity involves "the evasion of tax and other liabilities, such as employee entitlements, through the deliberate, systematic and sometimes cyclic liquidation of related c

Manner of Transfer of Bills One of the characteristics of bills of exchange is such whereas  A gives B a bill accepted through X in settlement of his debt, since this same ins

Legal Profession - Magistrates However the magistrate is an advocate that who is appointed through the Judicial Service Commission to the post of - The District M

Q. What do you mean by Electrolysis? In electro refining, the impure metal is taken as the anode and a strip of pure metal coated with a thin layer of graphite is made .the cat