Machine centred versus human centred, Computer Engineering

Machine Centred versus human Centred

The discussion here is based on the difference in approach to the design of the work system when we prioritise either the needs of the machine (in this case the IS) or the needs of the people. Adopting a human-centred design approach the objective would be to implement the technology to make the work of the participants as effective and satisfying as possible. With a machine-centred design approach the technology and process is designed to simplify what the machine must do. Therefore the human participants are expected to adjust to the weaknesses and limitations of the machine.

This dilemma is an evolution of that which has existed since the industrial revolution with the creation of the principles of FW Taylor and their ultimate use in designing the Fordist production lines of the early 20th century. While there are similarities with current information systems implementation today we should be in a better position to avoid the negative effects on the worker. Firstly, we have more knowledge of the needs of the worker and what makes a good or bad job and secondly we have more flexible and capable machines.

Despite this the tradition is still to assume that the people - the technology users - are more flexible in that they can understand the technology by reading manuals and that they will be able to follow procedures regardless of how arbitrary or illogical they may seem. Therefore the tendency may still be to follow the machine-centred path and compromise the needs of the worker.

However to optimise the balance it is necessary to understand the differing abilities of both the people and the technology. Here the same set of comparisons holds true for the machines that replace the physical effort of the worker and those that are now replacing the mental capabilities of the worker. The table below adapted from Alter (2002) shows a comparison of some of the characteristics that need to be considered when choosing whether a human or machine 'worker' will carry out a task.

763_Machine Centred versus human Centred.png

Posted Date: 3/14/2013 4:07:21 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Machine centred versus human centred, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Machine centred versus human centred, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Machine centred versus human centred Discussions

Write discussion on Machine centred versus human centred
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Explain Non-Folded network Non-Folded Network: In a switching network, every inlet/outlet connection may be utilized for inter exchange transmission. In this case, the .excha

A special Slot Machine is introduced in a new casino; this machine has a digital interface of a 3X3 grid. An interface button named as SPIN for making the machine spin. There are f

Suppose there are 2 copies of resource A, 3 copies of resource B, and 3 copies of resource C. Suppose further that process 1 holds one unit of resources B and C and is waiting for

E-Commerce is not suitable for Online job searching.

What are the advantages of having e-commerce over extranets?     Extranets are about " joining up" the supply chain-suppliers, resellers, distributors, customers, etc.-enabling

Integrating Virtual Memory, TLBs, and Caches - computer architecture:   There are 3 types of misses: 1. a cache miss 2. TLB miss 3. a page fault 2 techniqu

Q. What are Dynamic Process Groups? To create and manage dynamic groups a separate library libgpvm3.a should be linked with the user programs which make use of any of group fun

RISC-Means Reduced Instruction Set Computer. A RISC system has decreased number of instructions and more significantly it is load store architecture were pipelining can be executed

Q. What is Video Card Interfaces? A video interface is the link of video system to rest of the PC. To improve video performance there is required to be an intimate connection betw

A common task for a system administrator is to create new user accounts. In this lab you will be creating output that looks like an /etc/passwd file. The Problem You are to