Internal rate of return: multiple alternatives, Other Engineering

Internal Rate of Return: Multiple Alternatives

To compare multiple alternatives using the IRR as measure of economic worth we must use the incremental approach. It is erroneous to use the ranking approach to compare multiple alternatives using the IRR (or MIRR) as the economic worth. This is based on the economic analysis principle # 6: Continue to invest as long as each additional increment of investment yields a return that is greater than the investor's TVOM (MARR).

Recall the incremental approach (White et al.). In summary

1. Rank the feasible alternatives in increasing order of the initial investment.

2. Calculate the IRR of the alternative with the minimum investment (same as incremental versus do nothing). If alternative has an IRR > MARR then select it as the new defender, and proceed to step 3. If IRR < MARR then select the next alternative with the second minimum investment, and repeat step 2.

3. Select alternative with the next investment level (in ascending order) as the new challenger. Calculate the incremental cash flow of Challenger - cash flow of defender. Calculate the IRR of the incremental cash flow. If IRR > = MARR then select the new challenger as the defender, and repeat step 3 until no alternative can be selected as defender.

4. The preferred alternative is the current (last) defender.

Example

a) Calculate the IRR independently for each of the feasible alternatives of example.

b) Compare the feasible alternatives using the incremental approach.

Note that if we would use the ranking approach we would erroneously select alternative 2 as the preferred alternative (largest IRR). However, using the incremental approach the preferred alternative is 6, which is the same conclusion obtained with the PW, AW, and FW method.

Posted Date: 3/15/2013 5:46:37 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Internal rate of return: multiple alternatives, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Internal rate of return: multiple alternatives, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Internal rate of return: multiple alternatives Discussions

Write discussion on Internal rate of return: multiple alternatives
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Principal of Assembly buildings- fire protection engineering: As assembly buildings accommodate members of the public they often accommodate people with disabilities. People

Cold junction compensation A recent solution to the problem of controlling a reference junction temperature is to use a 'cold-junction compensator'. This is an integrated circu

What is Variable Interest Rate? Interest rates which is offered by banks or financial institutions on loans or deposits which are liable to change according to circumstances. For e

1-calculate the present value of the expected synergies. ( Assume a tax rate of 35%. a discount rate of 10% suitable for the cost oand revenue synergies combined, and inflation of

Oil supply failure - Propeller: To prevent an overspeed caused by an oil supply failure, one of two methods may be employed: • Hydraulic lock valve The pitch lock mecha

Firm A needs to purchase a new machine. If the machine is purchased, it will replace an old machine purchased 10 years ago for €105,000 and which is being depreciated on a straight

Sonic airflow though divergent and convergent ducts When a flow of fluid (i.e. gas) flows at sonic speed through a convergent duct a shock wave forms at the exit area of the du


an iron ring with amean dia of 50 cm has an air gap of 1mm awinding of 200 turns if the permeability of the iron is 400 when a circuit of 1.25A flows through the coil find the flux

Design a detailed surface mine excavation plan. Detail development requirements. Detail Production requirements including a full description of the method selected. Number of produ