Fundamentals of public health law, Business Law and Ethics

Fundamentals of Public Health Law

The Honorable Art Vandelay has been a member of the U.S. Congress for 10 years, representing the 12th District in South Caledonia. Through his career in the Congress he has been an advocate for the prevention of injuries. You are serving as Representative Vandelay's chief health legislative assistant at his Washington office on Capitol Hill. You are not a lawyer and do not have formal legal training, but you have taken an introductory course in public health law at a leading public health school in the United States. Representative Vandelay has become increasingly concerned about the rising toll of morbidity and mortality from car-surfing in her district.

In South Caledonia alone, the number of persons killed by participating in car surfing has increased four-fold over the past two years, and numerous injuries have also been reported. Two weeks ago, the son of a close friend and political supporter of Rep. Vandelay was killed while car surfing. Rep. Vandelay is considering introducing a bill in Congress to make car surfing illegal throughout the entire United States, with the purpose of reducing the number of associated deaths and injuries. He has drafted a bill, tentatively called the American Car Surfing Prohibition Act (ACSPA), which would prohibit persons from participating in car surfing in the United States, punishable by up to a $2,000 fine and up to 30 days in federal prison.

The Congressman has asked you to write a memo of no more than 600 words (Members of Congress do not like to read long memos) on a specific point concerning the advisability of introducing the ACSPA into Congress as a bill. You decide to refer his request to one of the attorneys in the office but the attorneys are out on vacation for two weeks. So, you decide to write your own memo, and then ask the attorneys to review it when they return from vacation, before you give it to Rep. Vandelay. Under the principles of federalism as expressed in the Raich case, and the federalism materials presented in class, and the assigned readings, would the ACSPA be found constitutional if it were challenged on grounds that it was not within the federal government's power under the Commerce Clause? First state your conclusion on this, and then give your reasoning.

Posted Date: 3/22/2013 2:55:51 AM | Location : United States

Related Discussions:- Fundamentals of public health law, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Fundamentals of public health law, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Fundamentals of public health law Discussions

Write discussion on Fundamentals of public health law
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Disadvantage of a scheme of arrangement: The disadvantage of a scheme of arrangement is that it requires the preparation of elaborate documents and the observance of a strict

Law Society of US Establishment However it is established through sec 3 of the Law Society of US Act Cap 18.  Hence it is a body corporate through the name Law Society

i.Over the years a number of systems have been developed which record coded information across a range of factors about disabilities in ethnic communities. A new coding convention

Domicile law of UK However a person's domicile is such country in where he either has or is deemed through law to have, his permanent home.  Hence it is the country of permane

Question 1: Constructive dismissal is inherently different from dismissal in the sense that it is the employee who takes the initiative in considering the contract as having be

Counter - offer and Death - Termination of an Offer Counter - offer However a counter - offer is constituted through the offeree's qualified acceptance that in itself g

Undischarged Bankrupts: S.188 provides that if an undischarged bankrupt acts as director of any company without leave of the court he shall be liable to imprisonment for a ter

Question 1: (A) What is an industrial dispute and what are the elements involved in the definition of an industrial dispute? (B) What are the various options available to t

Proceedings at Meetings: (a)Each item of business comprised in the notice should be taken separately, discussed and put to the vote.  Members may propose ammendments to the re

Ddisadvantages - mergers and winding up: The disadvantages of s.280 are that cash may have to be provided to pay off creditors and dissenting members or alternatively the sale