Arguments against protectionism, Managerial Economics

Arguments against protectionism 

Most of the arguments for protectionism may be met with counter arguments, but underlying the economic arguments as opposed to the social, moral, political, strategic,  etc, is the free trade argument.

Free trade argument

This, in brief, maintains that free trade allows all countries to specialize in producing commodities in which they have a comparative advantage.  They can then produce and consume more of all commodities than would be available if specialization had not taken place.  By implication, any quotas, tariffs, other forms of import control and/or export subsidies all interfere with the overall advantages from free trade and so make less efficient use of world resources than would otherwise be the case.

Reduced output argument

It has been said that import controls will protect jobs initially, but not in the longer run.  If we in the home country limit imports, then other countries will have less of our currency with which to buy our exports. 

This will lead to a decline in sales and a loss of jobs in  export industries.  The overall effect is likely to be a redistribution of jobs from those industries in which the country has a comparative advantage to those in which it has a comparative disadvantage.  The net result will be that total employment is unchanged but total output is reduced.

The infant industries seldom grow up

The infant industry argument is sometimes met with the claim that infant industries seldom admit to growing up and cling to their protection when they are fully grown up.  Most economists, however, appear to accept the infant industry argument as a valid case for protection provided it is temporary.

Gains from comparative advantage

The argument for protection against low wage foreign labour is partly a moral argument which is outside the scope of positive economics, but even the economic part of the argument that it will drag down the living standards of high wage economies can be shown to be invalid.  It is true as noted above that the payment of low wages will allow a country to export their goods cheaply and so possibly undercut those of high wage countries.  However, it must be noted that countries importing these cheap goods gain by virtue of their low cost in terms of the goods required to be exported in return.  This again is another use of the comparative advantage argument.

No Validity in economics

The other arguments such as the need to avoid over dependence on particular industries and the defence argument are really strategic arguments which are valid in their own terms and for which economic science is largely irrelevant.

Retaliation

Advocates of free trade also believe that if one country imposes import restrictions, then those countries adversely affected will impose retaliatory restrictions on its exports, so it will not end up any better off.  This could lead to a "beggar-my-neighbour" tariff war, which no one can benefit from, and which contracts the volume of world trade on which every country's international prosperity depends.

Inflation

If key foreign goods are not free to enter the country (or cost more), this will raise their prices and worsen the rate of inflation in the country.

Inefficiency

It is argued that if home industries are sheltered from foreign competition there is no guarantee that they will become more efficient and be able to compete in world markets.

Posted Date: 11/30/2012 5:02:25 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Arguments against protectionism, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Arguments against protectionism, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Arguments against protectionism Discussions

Write discussion on Arguments against protectionism
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Monetary Theory We have seen that Schumpeter theory which runs in terms of innovations and technical change, is at best an incomplete explanation of trade cycle . there are eco

Policy conflicts In their attempts to achieve the policy objectives, governments often face what are called conflict of objectives.  These arise partly because unlike private


Can identity economics explain some patterns observed in the Australian economy

Q. Avoiding Surplus and Inadequate Production? Demand forecasting is essential for the new and old organisations. It is somewhat necessary if an organisation is engaged in larg

Types of Public Debt Public debts can be classified according to the purpose for which the money was borrowed into; a.           Reproductive Debt:  where a loan has been

(Only for extra credit) Consider Freddy on a rainy Thursday afternoon after losing in his favorite video game. His friend Tommy comes over to cheer him up and offers him the follow

Dynamics  of Unemployment and  Real  Wages through Productivity Shocks   The model  that you  are  studying here  is  in  the  tradition of  the  real  business cycle theory th

ARGUMENTS FOR MONOPOLIES Although monopolies are usually hated mainly because their practice of consumer exploitation, there are some aspects of monopolies which are favourabl

Demand Function for Money In the Keynesian analysis , the demand for money is a function of the level of income and the rate of interest. According to Milton Friedman, the dema