contrary case, Business Law and Ethics

a) Two family businesses are competing in the same industry, and have been bitter rivals since their early days.  The feud eventually extended into the personal lives of each family, where even the children were taught to dislike their rivals since birth.  While stubborn rivalries of the owners intensified, other competitors have steadily taken market share away from both companies.  The old owners eventually retired, and the troubled businesses were taken over by their children.  One day, the president of Company A called for a meeting with the president of Company B.  Surprised that the perceived enemy would do so, the meeting was agreed to.  At the meeting, the two presidents discussed the nature of their rivalry, its history, its negative effects on both businesses and families, and decided that it is best to try to end it.  Teams from both sides drafted up various proposals which formed the basis of cooperation, and a deal was struck.  Both sides were initially suspicious of each other, and the relationship was very fragile.  Neither side knew for sure whether the deal would end up being a takeover plot, an elaborate scheme of corporate espionage, or some trap.  However, both sides also knew that pursuing their rivalry would eventually destroy both businesses and decide to build trust, believing the other meant well.

b) This is a good example of a contrary case because:

  • The fathers of each family developed and nurtured their hostility towards each other, while their children reflected on it.
  • The end of the inherited feud was initiated by a decision to communicate and cooperate, even though each side was weary to trust the other.
  • There were no guarantees that either side will uphold the deal, the deal was motivated by rational necessity for mutual benefit.
  • The motivations of both sides were questioned, and the decisions of both presidents were guided by logic, despite unknowns and lack of certainty.
  • Both sides were willing to take a leap of faith to trust the other side after reasoned and rational consideration of their situation.

c)

FAITH

IRRATIONALITY

Trust

Self-reflection

Connecting over uncertainty

Rational necessity

Path to mutual benefit

Changer of nature of relationships

Catalyst to social connections

Nurtured emotional state

Detrimental to welfare

Emotionality

Inherited way of being

Ill intention

Stubbornness

Posted Date: 2/21/2013 5:27:51 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- contrary case, Assignment Help, Ask Question on contrary case, Get Answer, Expert's Help, contrary case Discussions

Write discussion on contrary case
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Question 1 "CSR can play a key role in contributing to sustainable development while enhancing Europe's innovative potential and competitiveness" Critically analyse the link be

Elements of a Contract - Offer Further this is an unequivocal manifestation through one party of its intention to contract into another. So well it is a clear intimation for i

SUBSIDIARY LEGISLATION: Moreover this is subordinate or delegated indirect legislation. In fact section 2 of the Interpretation and General Provisions Act specified subsidi

Profit and Loss Account: with s.148(1) the directors of every company shall, at some date not soon than eighteen months later than the incorporation of the company and subsequ

Directorship - company management: A directorship is not a professional job with a legally prescribed qualification. In the circumstances, anybody (even a six-months-old baby)

Exceptions of Merger accounting: S.56 (1) permits a company to give financial assistance for a purchase of, or subscription for, its shares in the following circumstances:

Theories of international antitrust coordination We have come across various policy coordinations and adjustments but still there are other spheres of affairs where direct poli

You are the HR manager of a large manufacturing company which employs both unionized and non-unionized employees. You have a non-unionized employee, Edith, who has worked for the c

Misfeasance by the auditors: However it is not sufficient to describe that the frauds must have been detected whether the entries in the books had been put mutually in a way w

LAW OF TREATIES Treaties are an important and major source of international law. It is a convenient way by which the States deliberately  enter into agreements with other State