Top in enterprise bottom in integrity plagiarism

Assignment Help Case Study
Reference no: EM13946545

Case study

Top in enterprise, bottom in integrity plagiarism at universities

This case highlights experiences of plagiarism in Australian universities which are mirrored at universities throughout the world. The article gives examples which show the prevalence of plagiarism based on Internet material and shows solutions which can be adopted.

The past few years have not been kind to Australian universities. It began with the case of Ted Steele, who was fired in 2001 by the University of Wollongong, New South Wales, after accusing senior faculty of encouraging ‘soft marking'.

Then followed claims that a business school in Perth had awarded a degree to a Singapore student who had twice been caught cheating. Meanwhile, a lecturer at a university in Queensland complained that students were being passed despite initial failure marks. And last year David Robinson, the vice-chancellor of Monash University, Melbourne, the country's largest academic institution, was forced to resign after admitting to three cases of plagiarism.

In March this year a fresh scandal broke, this time over allegations that academics at the University of Newcastle, north of Sydney, had tried to cover up plagiarism by offshore students studying through the university's Graduate School of Business. The claims were raised by Ian Firns, a lecturer contracted by the university to teach an organisational effectiveness unit at the Institut WIRA in Malaysia.

Marking his students' assignments in January, Mr Firns discovered 15 cases of ‘blatant and serious' plagiarism. ‘My suspicion was initially raised by the very high standard of English', he says, ‘and inconsistencies in the sophistication of the ideas.'

An internet search showed that some of the students' work had been lifted without attribution from various consultancy and university websites. Marking the papers zero, he noted the web addresses alongside the parts of the papers concerned, together with some comments that ‘weren't particularly complimentary'. He passed the papers to the university's offshore programmes co-ordinator, who agreed that, in line with school policy, the students concerned be allowed to submit revised assignments but that their work score no more than 50 per cent.
Mr Firns later discovered that the original papers had simply been re-marked by another lecturer, with his original comments ‘whited-out'. And the plagiarised work received marks of between 18 and 29.5 out of 35, something Mr Firns found ‘absolutely staggering'.

Brian English, deputy vice-chancellor at the University of Newcastle, denies a cover-up. ‘I instituted an external inquiry within about 30 minutes of getting the allegation', he says.

According to Prof English, the inquiry (which the university refuses to release), found certain staff had misunderstood the plagiarism policy, which was ‘not fully clear'. They had erased Mr Firns' comments but had acted ‘in good faith'.

‘Incredulity is the initial response of every academic to whom I tell this story', says Mr Firns. ‘Derisive laughter is evoked when I tell them what the inquiry found.'

The episode has left Mr Firns disillusioned, particularly as it follows another plagiarism case, this time involving international students studying through the Newcastle Graduate School of Business in Hong Kong.

‘In Hong Kong] information had been downloaded wholesale from the internet', says Mr Firns. ‘In one case a student had gone to a site from the University of Poland, and submitted almost verbatim an English translation of someone's masters thesis in commerce.' Cheating is not new, and certainly not unique to Australia, but the past few years have seen what many consider to be an alarming increase in such incidents.

A survey in 2001 by the University of Canberra revealed that 81 per cent of students sampled had plagiarised at some point in their studies. (Men, it found, were significantly more likely to cheat than women.)

‘People just don't seem to feel the same moral pressure to do the right thing any more', says Paul Rizzo, dean of the Melbourne Business School. Prof Rizzo claims we are seeing the academic equivalent of the moral rot recently exposed in big business.

‘It's a case of if you can get away with it, then it's okay. Academic institutions have always prized intellectual freedom [but] this freedom presumes a level of trustworthiness which is at times sadly lacking.'

Prof Rizzo laments the ease with which students can now pilfer other people's ideas. ‘Whether it's downloading a thesis from the internet, complete with spelling errors, or using a camera-equipped mobile phone to photograph someone's answers in an exam room, technology is opening many more opportunities for people to cheat', he says.

One such technology is the term paper site, some of which hold up to 50,000 ready-made assignments available for between US$5 and US$12 (£3-£7.30) per page.

Kenny Sahr, founder of schoolsucks.com, with its motto: ‘Download your workload', says some of these sites also offer custom papers.

‘This is where the MBA students are going', he says. ‘You call a toll-free number and tell the person on the phone, usually a moonlighting teacher, exactly what you want. These go for US$15 to US$30 a page.'

According to Mr Firns, much of the cheating seems to be occurring among international students, who are worth about A$2bn a year to Australian universities. Some academics believe such profitability persuades many schools to look the other way when it comes to cheating.
‘Some universities have got on a treadmill, with overseas students funding being so much of their revenues that they appear to be doing almost unimaginable things to maintain that funding', says Mike Vitale, dean of the Australian Graduate School of Management.

All the business schools spoken to had recorded some instances of cheating, but claimed levels were so low it did not warrant significant concern.

‘A lot of universities are burying their heads in the sand', says Steve O'Connor, of Caval Collaborative Solutions, an information resources group commissioned last year by six Australian universities to conduct a survey into plagiarism.

Caval used turnitin.com, the plagiarism-detection software, to examine 1,751 essays chosen at random in 17 subjects.

‘We found that 8.85 per cent featured unattributed text in at least 25 per cent of their work. One business essay was 93 per cent plagiarised.'

Business school deans claim such findings have little relevance to them, because their assessments are based less on essays and assignments than class participation and exams, where plagiarism is, by definition, harder to commit.

One even dismissed concerns by claiming that ‘we are teaching graduate students who are much older than most undergraduates and have less to gain and more to lose from being found out as a cheat'.

None of that cuts much ice with Mr O'Connor. ‘Every scrap of evidence suggests that [cheating] is happening at every level.

'I know of one Sydney business school where a senior academic went to the dean and told him he refused to mark the assignments of a whole class because of the obvious level of plagiarism that was evident in the work.‘

Reference no: EM13946545

Questions Cloud

Determine the durbin watson statistic : Explain why the regression coefficient B0 has no practical meaning in the context of this problem. Predict the average monthly warehouse distribution cost when sales are $400,000 and the number of orders is 4,500.
Describe and give an example of a web database. : Explain the difference between system design and system analysis.
Writing resources for the development of your dissertation : week 8 Discussion 1: Writing Strategies and Resources (STUDENTS who are at this stage of the process) Post by Day 4 a description of the most useful writing resources for the development of your dissertation, given all the resources you are review..
Writing resources for the development of your dissertation : week 8 Discussion 1: Writing Strategies and Resources (STUDENTS who are at this stage of the process) Post by Day 4 a description of the most useful writing resources for the development of your dissertation, given all the resources you are review..
Top in enterprise bottom in integrity plagiarism : Top in enterprise, bottom in integrity plagiarism at universities. This case highlights experiences of plagiarism in Australian universities which are mirrored at universities throughout the world.
What percent of the welders make less than $20.00 per hour : The following chart shows the hourly wages of a sample of certified welders in the Atlanta, Georgia, area. How many welders were studied? What is the class interval?
Chez fred bakery estimates : Chez Fred Bakery estimates the allowance for uncollectible accounts
Frasqutta acquired equipment : Frasqutta acquired equipment from the manufacturer gave a noninterest-bearing note in exchange
Construct requency distribution table for the above majors : A sample was taken of 25 high school seniors who were planning to go to college. Each of the students was asked which of the following majors he or she intended to choose: business, economics, management information systems (MIS), behavioral scien..

Reviews

Write a Review

Case Study Questions & Answers

  From the scenario, prioritize the attributes of golds reling

From the scenario, prioritize the attributes of Golds Reling's brand from the brand map presented in the scenario according to the attributes that you believe would be most important to the new tablet's target market. Provide support for your respons..

  Discuss critically infosys current and future strategy

Discuss critically Infosys current and future strategy. What advice would you give Kris Gopalakrishnan and KShop has resulted in information overload among staff. What operational measures would you suggest to overcome such challenges?

  Review tarmac business case for diversity

Review Tarmac's Business Case for Diversity and the Learning Resources. Think about Tarmac's approach to managing diversity and how it relates to organisational behaviour concepts and human resource processes.

  Enron case shared activity

Enron was the first nationwide natural gas pipeline network in the United States. As the company grew, executives shifted the company's primary focus from energy delivery and infrastructure to investing in the stock market.

  Ebay inc internet success or fairy tale

Read the case study "eBay Inc.: Internet Success or Fairy Tale? "and answer the question below,   Use the 2002 financial statement data to replicate the Meyer's report calculations that illustrate the conclusion based on the 2001 data reached in the ..

  Mintendo game girl case study

Which option delivers the maximum profit for the supply chain: Sandra's plan, Bill's plan, or no promotion plan at all? How does the answer change if a discount of $10 must be given to reach the same level of impact that the $5 discount received?

  Splash soft drinks case study

Splash Soft Drinks Inc. (SSD) has recently achieved sales that exceeded its expectations after it introduced a new beverage that was greatly welcomed by their customers. The company is currently considering opening a new plant to which some of the pr..

  Details of the task using tesco plc

Details of the task Using Tesco plc (www.tesco.com) as a case study, prepare a report of no more than 2,500 words that:

  What are the common manifestations of alcoholic cirrhosis

What are the common manifestations of alcoholic cirrhosis? Which of these are secondary to hepatocellular failure? Which are secondary to portal hypertension?

  Judge the extent to which the marketing plan at just us

From the case study, judge the extent to which the marketing plan at Just Us! is outdated. Propose two (2) ways that Just Us! could improve the customer experience and thus sustain future growth.

  Read natasha kingery case and answer the questions

Read the DATA CASE on pages 126-127 about Natasha Kingery who is considering furthering her education and is seeking financial advice. Determine the interest rate she is currently earning on her inheritance by going to Yahoo!

  Identify the relevant facts of the case study

Imagine you are the financial controller of XYZ Ltd a corporation that is a very large donor to HOHO. You have recently become aware that its TV advertising has resulted in the charity violating the 25% expenditure ratio for its charity drive.    Id..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd