Subsidiary that charges more for processing orders

Assignment Help Finance Basics
Reference no: EM13827447


SF is a division of, an internet retailer. SF operates two large server farms, each of which is a set of interconnected computers and hard drives that are used to process sales orders from customers. SF started out with one farm, then added a second farm as the volume of orders rose, and will eventually need to add additional farms over time. SF charges different divisions within the firm for processing sales orders for those divisions. The transfer price is the average actual cost of processing an order plus 10%. Actual costs are a mix of "fixed" costs of $10 million per server farm per year (which include depreciation, utilities, staff, etc.), and "variable" costs of about $0.05 per sales order (which relate mostly to the wages for staff involved in manually correcting about 1% of orders that have problems). The two server farms have a combined capacity to process about 20 million orders, but they are currently running at about 75% of that capacity. All divisions in are evaluated based on their operating profits before taxes and capital charges.

(a) Some of the divisions have begun to complain about the high order processing costs charged by SF, and refer to quotes received from outside vendors to process orders that are much lower. They suspect that part of the problem is that SF has no incentive to control its own costs, since it gets back whatever it spends plus 10%. They have threatened to "go outside" but top management has customer privacy concerns and would prefer to process orders internally, unless the gap between inside and outside costs is too much to ignore. What suggestions do you have for top management in terms of their policy for how much SF should charge other divisions for processing sales orders?

(b) What is the current average cost of processing an order?

(c) A more careful evaluation of the costs incurred by SF suggests that orders are in fact generated by three different customer types: a) domestic retail customers, b) overseas retail customers, and c) corporate customers. Each customer type generates about 5 million orders currently. All of the variable costs are generated by overseas retail customers, unfamiliar with some of the data fields they have to fill in when ordering goods, and about 25% of the fixed costs (relating to specialist staff costs) are created by corporate customers who need special attention. These costs are essentially fixed since they require specialists to be available 24x7, regardless of the number of corporate customer orders processed. The remaining fixed costs are common and relate equally to all 3 products. Calculate the actual cost of processing an order for each of the three customer types. Based on the new cost structure revealed, speculate on some of the changes that downstream divisions (those buying services from SF) might undertake to benefit from the results of your analysis.

(d) While the analysis conducted in part (c) mollified some of the divisions buying services from SF (since the outside quotes they had received related to domestic retail customers), they were still uncomfortable about having to pay for excess capacity. The remaining 75% of total fixed costs were spread over the actual orders processed. More important, they felt that the cost of processing an order declined as excess capacity declined, and then would rise sharply as a new server farm comes on line. What suggestions do you have for ways to deal with this concern?

Summary of problem:

The question belongs to Finance and it discusses about an online retailer with a subsidiary that charges more for processing orders. The average cost of processing the order and other alternatives for this issue have been discussed in the solution.

Reference no: EM13827447

Venture capitalist john doerr of kleiner perkins

Imagine that you have been invited to a party held in a friend's back yard where you are surprised to see the renowned venture capitalist John Doerr of Kleiner Perkins stand

Financial stability and growth potential of tesco

Imagine that you are a fund manager working for a major multinational firm. You are in charge of the decision on whether your clients should invest in Tesco PLC, a major sup

Concluding a review of its current strategies

Red Pty Ltd is concluding a review of its current strategies. Which of the following statements would be a valid explanation of why current strategies may not meet objective

Forecasting the market value of common shares

Mr. David, founder and president of Heath Farm Company dealing in healthy dairy products, a profitable business and expanding rapidly, is wondering whether the company shoul

Implementing a specific tool to reduce exchange rate risk

At the next finance department staff meeting, the CFO asked you to lead a discussion on the use of one specific tool to reduce exchange rate risk-a currency swap (The others

Explains about preparing a memo

Your CFO was unable to attend the recent monthly chamber of commerce meeting. You learned from some other local CFOs that changing exchange rates had dramatically affected t

Question based on big mac purchasing power parity

The problem is belongs to financial basics and it is explains The exchange rate in June 2005 was 2,300 pesos per US Dollar. So, on Big Mac purchasing power parity grounds t

Calculating the worth of the silver present

An original United States silver dollar from the late 1800s consists of about 24 grains of silver. Suppose that at current prices, the silver content of this coin is worth $


Write a Review

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd