List the changes made based on given feedback

Assignment Help Case Study
Reference no: EM13776797

Case Study Analysis

Introduction

Carl Robins has been named the new campus human resources recruiter for ABC Inc. Having only been in that role for six months, Carl has successfully hired 15 new recruits in April. Since Carl himself is a relatively new employee, he is not familiar with the whole hiring process of ABC Inc. Carl now faces some very challenging problems due to his lack of qualifications and training. Carl does not know what he needs to know in order to successfully pull the new trainees into the company. And by failing to realize this he may be putting his future and the futures of the new employees at risk.

Background

Sometime at the beginning of April, Carl Robins successfully hired 15 new employees for ABC Inc. after only being on the job for six months. The 15 new employees will be working for Monica Carrolls. Monica is the Operations Supervisor. Carl did schedule a new employee orientation that was supposed to start on June 15th. Carl wanted the new employees to start by July of that year. Monica contacted Carl on May 15th. Inquiring about the progress of the new employees. Monica asked about several issues including, drug screening, physicals, policy booklets and manuals. Carl reassured Monica that all the issues would be taken care of and she had nothing to worry about.
After Memorial Day Carl was in his office and went to check the statues of the 15 new hires. Carl new that in order for everything to go according to plan the paper work and testing needed to be completed by June 15th. As Carl was looking through the paperwork he became concerned that a lot of the paperwork had not been completed. Some of the trainees did not have applications on file and or their transcripts. None of the physicals and none of the drug testing had been done yet. He also found that there were only three copies of the orientation manuals and several of them were missing pages.

It was at that point that Carl felt overwhelmed and frustrated. Instead of attempting to fix the problem and resolve the issues he went for a walk. When Carl returned from his walk he decided to check on the status of the training room that he had scheduled for the orientation. To Carl's surprise he had not reserved the training room and the training room had been booked b Joe from the technology services department. Joe was already setting up computers for his upcoming class. As Carl looked over the scheduling log he noticed that Joe had reserved the room for the whole month of June. This left Carl with no place to hold his orientation. This is when Carl realized he was in over his head. He went to his office and placed his head on the desk and questioned what he had gotten himself into. Carl realizes that he has not done anything that has been required of him. The position that he was put in required him to know the ins and outs of the hiring process. Carl has only started something that he cannot finish.

The Key Problems

While Carl has many problems with his plan to hire new employees, four stand out as needing to be addressed immediately as cause-effect problems. Other than Carl, the ABC Inc. also may have some issues to address with leadership and management. Being able to adequately look after your employees and know that they have the training to do their job is paramount in the business world. The first problem is that Carl is improperly trained for his position. One cannot expect to oversee the hiring of many new employees if the individual doing the hiring is not fully knowledgeable on how to train or hire. This one may fall onto his supervisor as well. Monica needs to have confidence in her employees to get the job done with little or no guidance. Carl only having six months of experience has not prepared him for the many challenges that he will face while bringing new employees on board. Since Carl was not trained properly his planning and execution skills are not in line with how the fully transition through the hiring process. The second fault is that Carl seems to be a procrastinator. Carl did not check on the progress for almost two weeks. This let things build and put him behind from the start. By putting off the things that he could have done right away he put them off and now all the steps in the process stack up on top of one another. By procrastinating Carl could not prepare for any unforeseen problems that will ultimately come up. The third key problem is that Carl did not stay on top of the hiring process. By doing a daily follow up Carl eliminates the potential of unforeseen problems and stays up on any issues that arise. Also by checking in daily he can inform his supervisor of the progress that is being made. Again this may also fall in Monica as she should have been checking in as well. The fourth key problem that has been identified is that Carl failed to ask for help when he needed it and at the beginning. Only having six months of experience, Carl was in no position to hire 15 new employees on his own, first thing out of the gate. Carl needed guidance in the hiring process but failed to ask for or seek help. This is a major flaw in big business, employees fail to ask for instructions or guidance for fear that they will look weak or incapable of doing their jobs. On the contrary this shows maturity in the individual. When Carl first realized that he was behind he should have gone to his supervisor and informed her of his situation and sought guidance.

Answer each of the questions included on the form. Suggested revisions should improve the content, organization, development, and mechanics of other students' papers. Return your peer review comments to each of the two members, and submit one copy of each peer review you completed to your faculty member to receive credit.

1. Reviewer question: What is the author's thesis?

2. Reviewer question: Is the thesis clearly stated? If not, how would you help the writer restate it?

Writer question: List the changes made based on this feedback. Also list those suggestions that were offered but that you did not make, and explain why you did not make the suggestions.

3. Reviewer question: Does the essay's body stick to the main topic? If not, where does it digress, and how could the writer revise the paper to make it stay more on the main topic?

Writer question: List the changes made based on this feedback. Also list those suggestions that were offered but that you did not make, and explain why you did not make the suggested changes.

4. Reviewer question: Does the paper contain any ambiguously-worded or confusing sentences? Please list them below and offer a suggested revision for each one you identify.

Writer question: List the changes made based on this feedback. Also list those suggestions that were offered but that you did not make, and explain why you did not make the suggested changes.

5. Reviewer question: Which closing strategy did the writer use? Is the closing effective? Why or why not? Offer a revision suggestion for making the closing more effective.

Writer question: List the changes made based on this feedback. Also list those suggestions that were offered but that you did not make, and explain why you did not make the suggested changes?

6. Reviewer question: Please give the writer feedback regarding the essay's effect on you.

Writer question: List the changes made based on this feedback. Also list those that were offered but that you did not make, and explain why you did not make the suggested changes.

Reference no: EM13776797

Questions Cloud

Effects of child sexual abuse : What would this literature indicate about the psychological and developmental effects on a child who has been sexually victimized? What intervention strategies might Carole recommend to Arlene?
What methods or techniques will you use to collect evidence : Prepare a comprehensive list of at least 25 questions that need to be answered about the scene and the body. Prepare a list of evidence that will be collected from the scene and from the body. What methods or techniques will you use to collect and pr..
Identical to all other atoms of the same element : Choose the scientist: write X for Democritus, D for Dalton, T for Thomson, R for Rutherford or B for Bohr - element were identical to all other atoms of the same element this was not correct.
Easton and source one associates : What responsibilities did Easton and Source One Associates, Inc. have to the individuals and businesses that were the targets of these information requests?
List the changes made based on given feedback : List the changes made based on this feedback. Also list those suggestions that were offered but that you did not make, and explain why you did not make the suggested changes.
Relationship of these areas with consciousness : Describe the areas involved in the attention mechanism. What is the relationship of these areas with consciousness
Which closing strategy did the writer use : Which closing strategy did the writer use? Is the closing effective? Why or why not? Offer a revision suggestion for making the closing more effective.
Logical fallacies in the argument : Analyze the reliability, credibility, and validity of the data used by the author.
What is the terminal settling velocity of a particle : Determine the volume of the aeration tank for the operating conditions

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Case Study Questions & Answers

  Did import substitution strategy work in brazil

Did import substitution strategy work in brazil and can brazil escap from its problem by strengtheing the rigonal integration initive called mercosur?

  What has accenture done well to target its b-to-b audience

What has Accenture done well to target its B-to-B audience

  Evaluate brian''s actions in the beginning of the case

Recommend a policy change to further protect Cenartech such as the one the CEO issued regarding the notification of the IT department when employees join or leave the company. Evaluate Brian's actions in the beginning of the case and determine wha..

  What are some of the accounting issues

Member contributions in the amount of $ 460,000 were received in cash, the city's General Fund also contributed $ 700,000 in cash.

  What could be the main motives for marriott

Identify several major categories of segmentation used by Marriott. For each relate specific examples of hotel services tailored to various target n www.marriott.com offers a brief description of 13 brands of various Marriott hotels catering differ..

  Presentation of a firm position regarding your stance

Find the evidence needed to support your stance or theory. Seek the needed facts, quotes, and existing research you can use for your argument - write the essay starting with the evidence-supported defense of your points and slowly transition into..

  What are the benefits of a corporate leadership strategy

What kind of normative leadership style do you thinkRay Kroc, as a leader in the first years of McDonald's,likely used and what are the benefits of a corporate leadership strategy?

  Choice point case

Choice Point Case;  Itemize the nature of the information security breach at ChoicePoint and how this adversely affected the organization.  Be sure to include both tangible and intangible losses in preparing your response.

  Do you think the customer relationship management system

What is your understanding of integrated view of the organization and its relations with suppliers and customers? If an organization wants to be competitive, what needs to be done in the system integration aspect?

  Review tarmac business case for diversity

Review Tarmac's Business Case for Diversity and the Learning Resources. Think about Tarmac's approach to managing diversity and how it relates to organisational behaviour concepts and human resource processes.

  Explain project integration management

Green Computing Research Project. Prepare a project charter for the Green Computing Research Project.

  Write a case study analysis paper on managerial situation

Write a case study analysis paper on managerial situation. Typically written in narrative form, a case sets forth, in a factual manner, the events and organizational circumstances surrounding a particular managerial situation.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd