In 1962 the atlantic cement company began operating a

Reference no: EM13363253 , Length: 500 Words

In 1962 the Atlantic Cement Company began operating a cement plant outside of Albany, New York. The Company employed over 300 local residents and by 1970 had invested $45 million in the plant. The plant emitted large amounts of pollution, however, as well as causing constant vibrations and loud noise.

Local residents filed suit against the Company, claiming that the loud noise and the vibrations were harming their health and property. The suit asked that the court issue an injunction that would close down the plant until the pollution and vibrations could be eliminated. The Company was already using the best available technology, which meant that the suit was asking that the plant be closed down indefinitely. The court refused to issue the injunction, reasoning that the costs of closing the plant outweighed the benefits to be gained by the residents.

Instead of closing the plant, the court ruled that the cement company should pay residents a one—time fee to compensate them for ongoing harms. This fee was calculated to be a fair market price for what the residents would receive if they were inclined and able to rent their property.

Read the court’s decision as well as the dissent:

https://www.law.berkeley.edu/faculty/rubinfeldd/LS145/boomer.html

Prepare a 350- to 700-word paper discussing the decision of the court in this case. Was it fair and defensible from an ethical viewpoint? If so, then why? If not, why not? Use appropriate theories that we have discussed during the course (social responsibility, utilitarianism, etc) to defend your position. A minimum of two peer-reviewed sources are required for this assignment.

Reference no: EM13363253

Questions Cloud

Module is to select an organization for your project you : module is to select an organization for your project. you may consider any of these organizations as long as you have

Project appraisal techniquesexplain which three of these : project appraisal techniquesexplain which three of these investment criteria you recommend for use at your current or a

Under what conditions the project might be still : under what conditions the project might be still desirablethese different investment appraisal methods provide

Your process team has been requested to identify technology : your process team has been requested to identify technology that would be beneficial to manufacturing and service

In 1962 the atlantic cement company began operating a : in 1962 the atlantic cement company began operating a cement plant outside of albany new york. the company employed

Project management risk managing contingency allowance risk : project management risk managing contingency allowance risk protection transfera.consider the following scenario.oa

1 select two brands within your product category with very : 1. select two brands within your product category with very different marketingpromotion strategies. submit as exhibits

Risk control planningnew markets will gather data from : risk control planningnew markets will gather data from internet chat rooms online news releases and many other sources.

Quantitative analysiscritical pathsthere may be instances : quantitative analysiscritical paths.there may be instances where something happens that does change the critical

User Account

All Pages