How would you go about implementing any alternative

Assignment Help Case Study
Reference no: EM13878969

Case Study: Jim Davies

Jim Davies is the manager of one of six large distribution warehouses for Mars & Spars, a multinational clothing and footwear chain store. Jim's warehouse operates as a profit centre whereby purchasing officers based within his warehouse buy in items under appropriately negotiated contracts and ‘sell' them on to the company's UK-based stores, although occasionally the goods can be exported. These are his ‘customers'. Suppliers are both UK and overseas companies.

Goods issued by Jim's warehouse are charged to his ‘customers' at the agreed contract price plus variations for agreed factors such as inflation. Any cost outside the contract price plus agreed variations are borne by the supplier. The charge to Jim's customers is the cost charged to Jim plus 5%. This is thus effectively Jim's performance measure as at the end of the year his warehouse must show a 5% ‘profit' after allowing for all costs. This profit margin determines not only Jim's performance-related pay bonus but also that of every person who works in the warehouse and Jim's distribution network. It also is a factor in determining Jim's promotion chances.

Jim is feeling aggrieved. Every year for the past three years his operating surplus has failed to achieve the necessary 5% target. This has resulted in little or no performance- related pay and he is under pressure from his senior managers to explain why he is fail- ing to perform - particularly as the other five warehouses have all achieved their targets (and more in some cases). Jim conjectures that the way in which the company allocates and apportions overheads to his warehouse causes the failure to achieve targets.

The following summary figures indicate the position for the last three years:

 

At present the company uses the following definitions of overheads:

· Corporate overheads - costs of board meetings, secretarial staff, board members salaries and expenses, etc.

 

· Technical support - financial, legal and personnel support, including such functions as business planning, financial advice on budgets, equal opportunities policy advice, etc.

· Buildings - costs for every building owned or occupied by the company.

All these overheads are charged to a trading account for each section - legal, finance, personnel, IT etc. - and then charged to a frontline service such as Jim's warehouse on the basis of a staff time analysis for each division. Staff in the support departments fill in an individual timesheet every three years. They are asked to estimate the amount of time they spend on each activity of the company and then these time sheets are analysed and used as the basis to apportion costs in the appropriate trading account. The last time sheet analysis was completed in 1990.

With buildings, all costs for all buildings are allocated to one central building account. These are then apportioned to all departments and functions on the basis of floor area occupied. For central overhead departments, the final costs are apportioned to all front- line services such as warehouses on the basis of the staff time analysis.

The net result of this process is that all costs of the overhead departments are fully apportioned to frontline departments such as warehouses.

Having read and analysed the above case:

(a) Do you think the issue of overhead allocation is important to companies?

(b) Why do you hold your point of view?

(c) Identify what, if anything, is wrong with the above system.

(d) What alternatives do you think might exist to the above?

(e) Do you agree with Jim that overheads are the cause of all his problems?

(f) How would you go about implementing any alternative?

Reference no: EM13878969

Questions Cloud

Create a candidate constitution party : The mission of the Constitution Party is to secure the blessings of liberty and posterity through the election, at all levels of government, of Constitution Party candidates who will uphold the principles of the Declaration of Independence, the Const..
Discuss competition within intermodal transportation : Discuss competition within intermodal transportation. Points of discussion may include strategies, the impact of regulation/deregulation, competition between the various modes of transport, safety, rates, supply and demand, port ownership, equipme..
Explain the risk categories for cloud computing : Explain the risk categories for cloud computing and how these risks may differ from a company that maintains its own IT hardware, software, and data.
What was the impact of the war with mexico : What was the impact of the War with Mexico on the political balance between the regions? What events after the War with Mexico forced an end to the Gag Rule?
How would you go about implementing any alternative : What alternatives do you think might exist to the above? Do you agree with Jim that overheads are the cause of all his problems? How would you go about implementing any alternative?
Dates and importance in the greek culture : Peloponessian wars, dates and importance in the greek culture
For each of the following parts of an it system : For each of the following parts of an IT system of a company, write a one sentence description of how unauthorized users could use this as an entry point
A representative of a hightech research firm : 1.B You is a consulting firm that works with managers to improve their interpersonal skills.
Explain what is meant by contribution analysis : Explain what is meant by "contribution analysis". Carefully define the term and provide examples to illustrate it

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Case Study Questions & Answers

  What evidence would you use to support your argument

Is the writer right in what he says? What points can you agree with? What points would you take issue with? How would you do that? What evidence would you use to support your argument?

  Architectural layers for our bug tracking system case study

Show your selection of hardware and software for each model in the deployment diagrams.

  Describe the role of information systems in career

Group Presentation & Case Study. Describe the role of information systems in careers in accounting/finance, human resources, marketing and operations management, and explain how careers in information systems have been affected by new technologies..

  In what way is thewriters you have chosen in the eraheroes

In what way is thewriters you have chosen in the eraheroes, meaning; in what way are they heroes in their time,but also how have/did they reflect the society they lived in.

  Using demorgan law to solve the problem

Using DeMorgan's Law, give an equivalent function for the following: f-(xy2--1-xi,)(y2+w+g)

  Identify the relevant facts of the case study

Imagine you are the financial controller of XYZ Ltd a corporation that is a very large donor to HOHO. You have recently become aware that its TV advertising has resulted in the charity violating the 25% expenditure ratio for its charity drive.    Id..

  What is the function of a credit rating agency

What is the function of a credit rating agency and why have these agencies prospered- why do credit ratings under pip the world's financial system'?

  Report to the management giving details of investigation

Describe in detail how you would approach the problem and the preparations you would make. Include in your explanation your initial thoughts with regard to the likely causes of the discrepancy.

  What are the swot implications for usa today

What are the SWOT implications for USA Today as it looks toward its future? What strengths and opportunities can USA Today leverage as it looks for a competitive advantage in the distribution of news and information

  Create value through restructuring

The Hanes spinoff realized profit for those who were able to get shares while being shareholders in Sara Lee. But were the gains enough to offset your holding and decrease in dividends from Sara Lee stock?

  What are major types of customers catherine serves

What are the three major types of customers Catherine serves? How do they differ from one another? What do you think the order winners are for each group?

  What is the factual basis of the plaintiffs claim

What is the factual basis of the plaintiff's claim? (It is helpful to associate a few key facts with the name of the case so you can quickly recall the case.)

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd