Challenges in capacity and decision making

Assignment Help Business Management
Reference no: EM131249121

Application: Challenges in Capacity and Decision Making

Patient rights include the right to informed consent, which entails that patients receive adequate information to make medical decisions. But many questions can arise if patients appear to lack the capacity to understand their medical condition or options. How is capacity determined? Who decides on behalf of the patient if the patient is determined to lack capacity? How should a surrogate decide on behalf of a patient?

In this Application Assignment, you will analyze the legal and ethical issues around patient capacity and surrogate decision making by focusing on the following scenario:

An 83-year-old diabetic male, Mr. Jones, is brought in to the emergency department because of respiratory distress, by his care-giving daughter, with whom he lives. In examining him, the emergency department physician discovers that Mr. Jones has gangrene on his right foot up to his ankle.

Mr. Jones' daughter reports that her father has been diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease. A preliminary capacity assessment is consistent with mild dementia, but one of the nurses suggests that Mr. Jones' confusion might be the result of his respiratory distress, coupled with the disorienting atmosphere of the emergency department.

The clinical recommendation is to perform a below-the-knee amputation. The patient refuses this surgery, saying he has lived long enough and wants to die with his body intact. His daughter disagrees and says she wants everything done so that she can take him home as soon as possible, and says that she will sue the hospital if they do not perform the amputation. A social worker comments that the daughter might be afraid of an elder-neglect investigation if her father dies.

Mr. Jones does not have an advance directive of any kind and is not under guardianship. Assume that the applicable law in your state is the same as Sections 5, 7, and 11, of the Uniform Health-Care Decisions Act, available athttps://www.uniformlaws.org/shared/docs/health%20care%20decisions/uhcda_final_93.pdf

To prepare for the Application:

  • Review Appelbaum, P. S. (2007). Assessment of patients' competence to consent to treatment.New England Journal of Medicine, 357(18), 1834-40.Also review the section of the Merck Manual on surrogate decision making,https://www.merckmanuals.com/home/fundamentals/legal_and_ethical_issues/surrogate_decision_making.html?qt=&sc=&alt=. Refer to these readings as well as to the laws as described in Sections 5, 7, and 11 of the Uniform Health-Care Decisions Act in order to identify legal and ethical issues that apply to the scenario above.
  • Consider the role that capacity assessment must play in health care. Why is it important? What are the consequences of not adequately assessing a patient's capacity?
  • Read Chapter 4, "Health Care Ethics Committee," in Legal and Ethical Issues for Health Professionals (required reading in Week 6). In what ways would a health care consultation or committee be able to address the ethical challenges in this scenario? How do you think a bioethicist would deal with this case in terms of the procedures he or she would engage in?

To complete this Application Assignment, write a 3- to 4-page paper in which you would address the following questions:

  • What are the relevant legal issues at stake? What are the legal rights of the patient and his daughter?
  • What are the relevant ethical issues at stake?
  • Why does capacity assessment matter?
  • How might the hospital's ethics committee or ethics consultation service help in addressing this? Include a description of how an ethics consultant or committee might become involved in this case.

Reference no: EM131249121

Questions Cloud

Examine the use of social media marketing campaigns : Next, examine the use of social media marketing campaigns for and against the company regarding the ethical issue, and analyze the main advantages and disadvantages of the public's use of social media for this company. (e.g., Did it unjustly perse..
Secretarial work and machine for quarter : Determine if there was a productivity gain or loss in the 4th quarter for each SFP in part a. Determine the TFP for each quarter. Determine if the company had a TFP gain in the 4th quarter.
Reinvent a fairytale or myth : Reinvent a Fairytale or Myth. In other words, take one of the Fairytales or Myths you heard as a child, and change it to make it your own.
Design a stable multivibrator using two resistors : Design a 555 a stable multivibrator using 2 resistors - Ra and Rb and a capacitor C, as shown in the circuit shown below. The specifications are: C = 680pF, one of the resistors is 10k?, and a duty cycle of 65%.
Challenges in capacity and decision making : Patient rights include the right to informed consent, which entails that patients receive adequate information to make medical decisions. But many questions can arise if patients appear to lack the capacity to understand their medical condition or..
What is the hypothesis : Questions you should seek to answer in your paper: What is the research question? What is the hypothesis? Who are the study subjects
Cost for solid waste pick-up : What is the cost for solid waste pick-up under the 3 different scenarios. Which of the 3 scenarios is the most economical? For the scenario that you recommand, what is the annual cost per household? What is the monthly cost per household?
Imperative aspects of public organization : Human Capital and Public Finances are two imperative aspects of any public organization. In what ways are human capital and finances competing values? How can bureaucrats navigate the competing needs?
What extent is economic inequality fair : To what extent is economic inequality fair? Did Doug have the right to vent his anger in such a violent manner? What, if anything, could be done to improve Doug's economic and ecological status?

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Business Management Questions & Answers

  How does general intelligence differ from creativity

What is leadership's role in developing and sustaining a culture of innovation in their organization? Provide an example.

  Differentiate based on higher service levels

As lower cost countries vie to receive sourcing opportunities, traditional outsourcing countries (e.g. India) will need to differentiate based on higher service levels and an ability to move up the value chain

  Write answers of law questions

Paul was hurt in a car accident involving a vehicle driven by Dick. Paul brought a federal diversity suit against Dick on a negligence theory.- Should the court grant Paul's motion to compel production of the notes?

  Servuction model recognizes that operations

1. Services differ from manufactured products in four ways. Intangibility, Inseparability, Perishability and _______________?

  Interfaces between logistics and the core functional areas

Select a manufacturer that you are familiar with and assume that youare the logistics manager of this organization, analyse the interfaces between logistics and the core functional areas, its current order cycle

  Challenging a leader

The best way to challenge a leader is to attack its strengths and The best way to attack a leader is to avoid a head-on assault and to adopt a flanking strategy

  Exceeding productivity goals

how do you reward an employee, team, or team member for exceeding productivity goals? And how do you reward a team for great ideas

  Communications when various asynchronous and synchronous

communications when various asynchronous and synchronous me1 create and submit scenarios that illustrate when various

  Major functional areas of business organizations

Briefly describe the terms operations management and supply chain. Identify the three major functional areas of business organizations and briefly describe how they interrelate.

  Case study-innovations in distribution strategy

This week's readings feature a discussion of logistics, including a case study of the future of same-day delivery. This case illustrates how companies can find competitive advantages through becoming better at logistics. Home delivery, as a servic..

  Which arguments should be given more weight

Which arguments should be given more weight: those based on industry policy, the employee handbook, also the labour agreement or mitigating factors given by the grievant also his witnesses? Elucidate.

  Analyzing job satisfaction survey datayou have joined a new

analyzing job satisfaction survey datayou have joined a new hospital and you have been reading some internal documents.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd