What arguments most influenced your decision

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13950423


Based on what you have read, should we legalize the production of human clones?

What arguments most influenced your decision?

How would you explain your position to someone who disagrees with you?


Medical research using human cloning techniques should be permitted for therapeutic purposes, the Australian Academy of Science (AAS) has declared in a controversial statement released last week.

The Academy says, the recent cloning advances could revolutionise treatment of damaged tissues and organs. "Human cells, whether derived from cloning techniques, from embryonic stem-cell lines, or from primordial germ cells should not be precluded from use in approved research activities in cellular and developmental biology", says the AAS statement (http://www.science.org.au/policy/statemen/cloning.htm).

Sue Serjeantson from the AAS Steering Group on Human Cloning, said the Academy, like other similar organisations internationally was firmly opposed to reproductive cloning to create fetuses. "We want to encourage public discussion on this. It is going to take quite a long time, as it is a complex issue and there will be different and legitimate points of view being aired."

Recent developments make self-compatible tissue and organ repair more likely, the AAS notes. These developments include: cloning of mammals from adult cells; the establishment of embryonic stem-cell cultures; and the ability of human fetal nerve stem-cells to develop into multiple and appropriate nerve-cell types following transplantation into animals. Julian Savulescu (Ethics Unit, The Murdoch Institute for Genetics Research, Melbourne), supports the AAS position: "Some people think that human zygotes are special because they have the potential to create people. Cloning has shattered that belief. There is no morally significant difference between a fertilised egg in a petri dish in an IVF [in-vitro fertilisation] clinic, a cloned cell, and a skin cell: they could all be persons, with the application of modern technology".

However, the Catholic church and some ethicists have condemned the AAS's position. The federal Government supports the more cautious line taken by the Australian Health Ethics Committee of the National Health and Medical Research Council, which advocates regulation to allow cloning on embryos in "exceptional circumstances".

Reading 2:

New methods can create a baby who is your genetic twin


The cloning of human beings is now possible. Scientists can take an egg cell, remove its DNA, insert DNA from a cell of any person, and create an embryo who is that person's younger but identical twin. This technology offers a miracle option for families who cannot have children of their own by any other method. After 25 years as a fertility specialist, trying to help couples have babies, I have joined with scientists in Europe and elsewhere to develop that option. By doing so, I believe, we will be helping humanity.

It is true that the cloning of animals-such as Dolly the sheep, created in Scotland in 1997-has so far had a high failure rate and is fraught with risks. But those risks have been exaggerated, and many of them have resulted from improper cloning. Meanwhile, I can show you e-mails from thousands of families eager to accept those risks. They say in their messages that if they are able to have a child through cloning, they will love that son or daughter just as much as they would any other.

Believe it or not, the genie is out of the bottle. Human cloning will be done whether we like it or not. I think we should accept it, make it legal, regulate it, and make sure it is done in a responsible, scientifically correct way -not left to unscrupulous black-market exploiters.

Director, Andrology
Institute of America
Lexington, Ky.

Don't think about human cloning from the point of view of the person being cloned. Think about it as if you were the younger, duplicated copy. If you do, you'll see at once why cloning a human being is deeply unethical.

First, the known grave risks of abnormality and deformity seen in animal cloning make attempts at human cloning an immoral experiment on the resulting child-to-be. Second, even if you were a healthy clone, would you want to be constantly compared with the adult original in whose image you have been made? Wouldn't you want to have your own unique identity and an open-ended future, fully a surprise to yourself and the world?

If you were the clone of your "mother," would it help your adolescence to turn into the spitting image of the woman Daddy fell in love with? If you were the clone of your "father" but your parents later divorced, would you like to look just like the man your mother now detests?

Third, don't you think it is a form of child abuse for parents to try to determine in advance just exactly what kind of a child you are supposed to be? Do you want to live under the tyranny of their biologically determined expectations?

Finally, would you like to turn human procreation into manufacture, producing children as artifacts? Cloning is tyrannical and dehumanizing. We should have none of it.

Use for reference page:

Panos Zavos, & Leon R Kass. (2001, April). Should humans be cloned? New York Times Upfront, 133(17), 26

Tattam, A. (1999). Australia considers human cloning for therapeutic purposes. Lancet, 353(9158), 1076.

Reference no: EM13950423

Analyzes the effect of a theory or concept of management

Analyzes empirical and theoretical literature relevant to the selected research topic. 16% Does not reference empirical and theoretical literature relevant to the selected r

Multicultural respect to their coworkers

Describe three reasons why police officers need to show multicultural respect to their coworkers and citizens in their community. Also list three ways to demonstrate this resp

Would you utilize punishment or reinforcement

Choose a behavior you would like to shape on someone you know. Select a terminal and initial behavior and the steps you would use to shape the behavior. Would you utilize pu

Discuss why these strategies were selected

Provide a brief overview of the theories of motivation presented in the textbook that will work best in the development of you ideal organization. Discuss why these strategi

Ability to succeed as online graduate student-home work

How confident are you in your ability to succeed as an online graduate student? Are there particular areas you need to improve in? 2. How will your responses on this survey in

Optimal production run quantity

The Ambrosia Bakery makes cakes for freezing and subsequent sale. The bakery, which operates five days a week, 52 weeks a year, can produce cakes at the rate of 116 cakes per

Write research design in order to explore the given problem

Write a research design in order to explore the problem. In your research design you should identify a problem, develop a hypothesis, and create a logical plan for testing y

Magnetic resonance imaging

Magnetic Resonance Imaging is one of most important imaging technique, however, it still needs a lot of improvement to enhance the quality of the image and reduce time. In t


Write a Review

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd