Was it ethical for engineer a to refuse to sign or seal plan

Assignment Help Mechanical Engineering
Reference no: EM131269705

1. Knowledge of Damaging Information

The State Pollution Control Authority advises the Bright Corporation that it has 60 days to apply for a permit to discharge manufacturing wastes into a body of water.

In order to convince the Authority that it will meet the environmental standards, the Bright Corporation employs Persaud, an engineer, to perform consulting engineering services and submit a detailed report. After completing the studies, Persaud concludes that the discharge from the plant will violate environmental standards and that the corrective action will be very costly to Bright. Persaud verbally notifies the company, which terminates its contract with Persaud with full payment for the services performed. It instructs Persaud not to render a written report to the corporation.

A short time later, Persaud learns that the Authority has called a public hearing, where the Bright Corporation will present data to support its claim that the present plant discharge meets minimum standards.

What, if anything, should Persaud do now? Is Persaud obliged to report the violation of environmental standards to the Authority? Does Persaud have any residual obligation to the Bright Corporation that would stand in the way of doing so?

2. Conflict of Interest - Specifying Equipment of Company Owned by Engineer

Engineer A is asked by a firm to prepare specifications for an air compression system. Engineer A made the firm aware that she is the President (and major shareholder) of a company that manufactures and sells air compression systems and that she has no problem with preparing a set of generic specifications. Engineer A also provides the firm with four other manufacturers that prepare air compression systems for bidding purposes, and Engineer A did not include her company as one of the four specified manufacturers.

The firm now wants to meet with Engineer A and a salesman from her company. Engineer A indicated to the firm that it might be a conflict-of-interest.

Would it be a conflict of interest for Engineer A to prepare a set of specifications for an air compression system and then have her company manufacture the air compression system under the facts?

3. Refusing to sign/seal construction documents

Engineer A, employed by Firm X, left Firm X and goes to work for Firm Y, a competitor. A project on which Engineer A was in responsible charge was virtually completed, but Engineer A did not sign or seal the construction documents before leaving Firm X's employment. Engineer B, a principal in Firm X requests Engineer A to sign and seal the drawing. Engineer A refuses to sign or seal the construction documents unless Firm X pays Engineer A an additional fee.

Was it ethical for Engineer A to refuse to sign or seal the plans?

Was it ethical for Engineer B to ask Engineer A to sign and seal the construction documents?

If additional work was required on the part of Engineer A, would it be ethical for Engineer A to request additional compensation?

Reference no: EM131269705

Questions Cloud

Manager of a medical-surgical unit in a not-for-profit : Judith is the manager of a medical/surgical unit in a not-for-profit, acute care hospital that is part of a nine-hospital healthcare system. During the budget preparation process for the upcoming fiscal year
How many internal rates of return do you expect to have : Blue Bird Café is considering a project with an initial cost of $46,800, and cash flows of $8,500, $25,000, $19,000, and -$4,500 for Years 1 to 4, respectively. How many internal rates of return do you expect this project to have?
Find the equation of a lorenz curve for the data : Use quadratic regression to find the equation of a Lorenz curve for the data.- Use the regression equation and a numerical integration routine to approximate the Gini index of income concentration.
What is a client and server database system : What are the advantages of the database server approach to client/server database compared to the file server approach?
Was it ethical for engineer a to refuse to sign or seal plan : Was it ethical for Engineer A to refuse to sign or seal the plans? Was it ethical for Engineer B to ask Engineer A to sign and seal the construction documents? If additional work was required on the part of Engineer A, would it be ethical for Engin..
Adequate supporting material : Create an outline for your Argumentative Research Paper, topic chosen (Child Support). Organize your writing by creating an outline which supports your position (your argument). After you have gathered what you believe will be adequate supporting mat..
Discuss and provide an illustrative example : What forms of resistance to a rigid, top-down control system may be evident from employees? Discuss and provide an illustrative example.
What is a distributed database management system : Why would a company be interested in moving from the centralized to the distributed database approach?
Discuss why some companies view training as important : Discuss why some companies view training as an important, ongoing and valuable activity. What type of assessment will you use to prepare for the training? How will you determine if the training was successful?

Reviews

Write a Review

Mechanical Engineering Questions & Answers

  He airplane maintains vdot constant for about 30s determine

an airplane is flying at v0130 mph and with a constant time rate of increase of speed v22fts2 when it starts to climb

  Determine a the net power developed in kw b the back work

air enters the compressor of an ideal closed air-standard brayton cycle at 100kpa with a volumetric flow rate of 5m3s.

  Determine the mass flow rate of the steam

Determine the mass flow rate of the steam

  A team of design students working on a mousetrap-powered

a team of design students working on a mousetrap-powered vehicle decides to use computercompact discs as wheels. the

  Shape of a rectangular solid

Force and Torque on a Dam. A dam has the shape of a rectangular solid. The side facing the lake has area A and height H. The surface of the freshwater lake behind the dam is at the top of the dam.

  Determining the drag and the lift slope

Estimate (a) the wing span, (b) the aspect ratio, and (c) the induced drag. Take density of air to be 0.7 Kg/m3. Assume that the factors for induced drag and the lift slope, d and t, respectively, are equal to 0.01; i.e., d = t = 0.01.

  Due to surface tension the pressure inside the jet will be

a 12-mm diameter jet of water discharges vertically into the atmosphere. due to surface tension the pressure inside the

  Deliver liquid water from a pond to a higher elevation

A pump is employed to deliver liquid water from a pond to a higher elevation. The pump steadily draws water from the pond at a volumetric flow rate of 192 gal/min through a pipe having a 7 in diameter inlet. The exit diameter of the pipe is 2 in. and..

  Determine equation in terms of final velocities of two disks

Disk A has a mass of 5 kg and disk B has a mass of 6 kg. They have the initial velocities shown in the figure. The coefficient of restitution between the disks is e = 0.4.

  Determine the reduction in the exit temperature of the

the compression stages in the axial compressor of the industrial gas turbine are close coupled making intercooling very

  Calculate coefficient of performance of this refrigerator

It is claimed that a refrigerator requiring 400 W of power (W) receives heat from cold storage (low temperature source, TL) at 200 K and rejects heat at the rate of 600 W (QH) to an environment at 600 K (high temperature reservoir, TH). Calculate the..

  If the true mean is really 20 what sample size must be used

suppose we wish to test the hypotheses ho u15 h1 u does not 15 where we know that sigma2 9.0. if the true mean is

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd