Should nonmoral claims override the moral claims

Assignment Help Humanities
Reference no: EM13926431 , Length: word count:500

According to the National Coffee Association, half of all Americans drink coffee every day. For instance, young adults drink an average of 3.2 cups of coffee per day, and in 2007 consumption of coffee actually surpassed consumption of soft drinks.

Most of this coffee is produced in developing nations, yet less than 10% of the annual value of coffee goes back to the farmers. Much of the rest ends up in the pockets of the companies that process, package, and sell it, such as Kraft, Proctor and Gamble, and Nestle, among others. The low return on their investment is devastating for farmers in developing nations like Ethiopia, where unemployment and poverty are high and coffee plantations represent a much needed source of income. In Columbia, some coffee farmers have already converted their coffee farms to opium farms because opium yields better income.

The way the coffee industry operates does not just present a problem for the farmers that grow the beans. Rather than using the traditional method of growing coffee in the shade of tropical trees, to increase yield most coffee is now grown in "full-sun" production. This change has brought on the destruction of tropical rainforests and, with that, a tremendous loss of biodiversity. According to Equator Coffee Roasters, this type of coffee production is "the second leading cause of rainforest destruction." Furthermore, the trees that could be used to offer shade can often provide additional income for farmers by producing fruit, avocados, and wood. In addition, the ground underneath the coffee plants is a good place to grow vegetables and herbs.

Full-sun plantations also lack the natural fertilizers provided by plants and the natural pest control of the animals that live in the rainforest. As a result, coffee plants require chemical fertilizers and pesticides. These plantations are also prone to flooding and erosion, both of which could be avoided if the coffee plants were nestled between larger trees. Meanwhile, the runoff from the chemical fertilizers and pesticides pollutes the surrounding rivers. The chemicals also affect farm workers: many of the hired farmhands cannot read, so they do not know how to follow the instructions given for the use of the chemicals. Sometimes there is no protective gear available for workers, which can result in chemical poisoning.

The birds are yet another casualty of the full-sun method. More than 150 species of birds thrive in the rainforest of a traditional coffee planation, which is more than twenty times the number of species that live on full-sun farms. Some of the species that depend on the rainforest for survival have declined by as must as 70%.

Many of these negatives can be avoided if consumers become more aware of what kind of coffee they buy - if they let their buying habits be guided by "eco-labels." For instance, all organic coffee is shade grown, and very few pesticides are approved for use in organic farming. To avoid coffee from full-sun plantations, consumers should look for the label "organic." An advocacy group from New York City, the Rainforest Alliance, also certifies coffee. The Rainforest Alliance prohibits certain chemicals, it requires that water and biodiversity be protected, and it also requires that new trees be planted. According to one farmer, following the Rainforest Alliance principles is "helping him farm in balance with nature, and greatly improve worker productivity and morale." Consumers can look for the "Fair Trade" label, which guarantees farmers a certain minimum price for their coffee. A portion of the profits from the coffee is then reinvested into the community in the form of schools, buildings, etc.

1. Is this a moral or legal/economic issue? Could it be both? What are some of the most important value and prescriptive claims involved here? Should any of the relevant nonmoral claims override the moral claims? Why or why not?

2. How does the fact that this issue involves international trading policies affect this case?

3. It would not be acceptable in the United States for workers to be exposed to the kinds of risks these foreign coffee workers are being exposed to. Nor could any U.S. worker be paid such low wages. Can these sorts of things nevertheless be acceptable for workers in other countries? Relate your answer to the claim that moral principles should be universal.

4. If moral principles are indeed universal, could we justifiably criticize another culture for its farming practices and the way it allows its workers to be treated?

5. To what degree do you think the rest of the world could justifiably take action against foreign farming practices when these could potentially harm farmers and the surrounding people?

Formulate some moral and nonmoral claims to support your views.

Reference no: EM13926431

Questions Cloud

Determine which data from the database to archive : Determine which data from the database to archive; that is, for each table, specify whether data needs to be archived. If it does, specify which data, when it should be archived, and whether it should be archived with data from another table.
Capital budget recommendation : Guillermo Navalles, owner of Guillermo Furniture faces a decision that could make or break the success or failure of his business. Because of increased competition and costs, profits for the Mexican company have taken a hit.
Analyzing an argument -from samizdat to twitter : How effectively does Burton's use of language help establish his credibility as well as emotional and logical appeal? Be sure to consider his rhetorical situation. Who is his audience and what is his purpose?
Declares several circle objects : Create a class named TestCircle whose main method() declares several Circle objects. Using setRadius() method, assign one circle a small radius value (code a user input making use of Scanner of JOptionPane), and assign another a larger radius valu..
Should nonmoral claims override the moral claims : Is this a moral or legal/economic issue? Could it be both? What are some of the most important value and prescriptive claims involved here? Should any of the relevant nonmoral claims override the moral claims? Why or why not?
Create a view named largeslip using the data : Create a view named LargeSlip using the data in the MarinaNum, SlipNum, RentalFee, BoatName, and OwnerNum columns in the MarinaSlip table for those slips with lengths of 40 feet. Display the data in the view.
Name of all customers that have a credit limit : List the names of all customers that have a credit limit less than $10,000.
What is green technology : You currently work for a small private consulting company. It has been very successful in the current economy but business has started to slow down. Your competitors have started implementing green technology. Your boss has asked you to research g..
Dba at premiere products : The DBA at Premiere Products wants you to investigate biometric identification techniques for potential use at the company for computer authentication purposes.

Reviews

Write a Review

Humanities Questions & Answers

  Plan to improve correctional facilities

Women imprisonment should be facilitate with certain correctional facilities. In this paper, we have discussed about the plan for improving correctional facilities for the women prisoner in America.

  Situation analysis of food security in new zealand

This paper aims to present, discuss and analyse factors that are causing low food security, the management, current and proposed solutions in New Zealand (NZ).

  Social services on human traffic

The research study is limited to the understanding of  how social service agencies could approach or respond to the needs of the victim/ survivor of sex trafficking.

  Social deviance: the issue of risky sexual behaviour

The issue of deviant behaviour has been discussed by various sociologists from a number of perspectives.

  Race and racism

This paper is a brief description of the study, discrimination pertains to the prejudice perception and treatment of a person or demographical issues belonging to a category.

  Depth of challenges people face

Your own knowledge about the Depth of Challenges People face

  Project plan written report

Sufficient information to enable the organisation's Board of Executives to understand the rationale for the program and the activities required to design, implement and evaluate the program including any additional data that would need to be colle..

  Evaluation structure logical and achievable.

Health care organisational processes management, service administration, service provision and delivery

  Write an essay on locke''s theory of meaning

Write an essay on Locke's theory of meaning

  Leadership reflections paper

Write a paper on Leadership Reflections Paper Summarizes and reflects upon leadership ideas gleaned from the four required readings

  What role has feminism played

what role has feminism played in our appreciation of their work today.

  What subject matter choices were available to women artists

Prior to the beginning of the twentieth century, what subject matter choices were available to women artists? What cultural and historical influences placed limitations on their choices?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd