Objection to the critics of utilitarianism

Assignment Help Humanities
Reference no: EM131118571 , Length:

The swine argument.

- The notion that morality based on pleasure is low. (criticism)

- Mill responds: - But there are higher pleasures that are specifically human and not bodily pleasures.

- He classifies pleasures such as: the pleasure of intellect, feeling, imagination as higher than others. Mill claims that they are intrinsically better, they have higher quality.

Utilitarianism

- This is the biggest objection to the critics of utilitarianism who claim that util. equals men to pigs.

- we know from experience what the higher, what the lower pleasures are; - we know that people who know both types of pleasures, consistently choose the higher ones;

- even the ones who don't know the highest pleasure (philosophy), wouldn't trade few higher pleasures for lots of low ones. This is the response to the quantitative utilitarianism;

- sense of dignity

- it makes us choose the higher pleasures;

- if we choose only lower pleasures, we have an opportunity to be completely satisfied, but if we choose higher, we will not; the lower ones are easy to satisfy and we can be fairly certain that we can satisfy them, we can obtain these pleasures easily; but the higher pleasures require work and we can't be sure that we will master what is required to obtain those pleasures (like learning to play piano or learning mathematics) - but it is better to be dissatisfied.

- Mill starts talking about the social dimension of his ethics. The pursuit of noble pleasures produces benefit to the others not only to one person.

- - Firmer statement: the pursuit of what is the highest, best is beneficial not only for one but for all.

- Mill claims here again that those who have experience of both, prefer the higher pleasures that benefit the others more than the higher pleasures that benefit only them.

- Different objections discussed:

- I. some claim that happiness is not attainable or only attainable in a small degree in this life.

- II. others claim that virtue requires giving up happiness
- The utilitarian ideal is one with the Christian ideal

- the golden rule and "love your neighbor as yourself."

- There are people who object to utilitarianism because moral sacrifice, obligations require us to give up some of our happiness. It often has to be done voluntarily by a martyr (self-sacrifice)

- So, making the sacrifices for moral obligation is compatible with utilitarianism for 2 reasons:

- such sacrifices are almost always done for the sake of others happiness, so happiness is still a principle;

- even when we make such sacrifices, we still can have the happiness in the sense of ataraxia because we loose the fear of loosing what we already decided to give up. So we preempt our passions.

- Mill makes the distinction between the rule of action and the motive for it.

- Mill: (1) it does not matter what the motive is as long as what is done is done for the promotion of the general good. (2)You are free to benefit yourself as much as you want to as long as you don't interfere with the rights of others.

- So, Mill is very liberal in his understanding of social relations in the sense of Adam Smith that individual seeking their own benefit, when this desire is moderated by reason, leads them to see that they have to benefit somebody else in order to benefit themselves.

- Chapter 5 - "The Connection Between Justice and Utility," was originally written as a separate essay, but later incorporated into this work. Critics of utilitarianism argue that morality is not based on consequences of actions (as utilitarianssuppose), but is instead based on the foundational and universal concept of justice. Mill sees this as the strongest attack on utilitarianism, and thus sees the concept of justice as a test case for utilitarianism.

- First, he argues that all moral elements in the notion of justice depend on social utility (punishment, and the notion that someone's rights were violated) - Mill's second argument is that if justice were as foundational as the other philosophers claim, it would not be as ambiguous as it is; punishment, fair distribution of wealth, and fair taxation: these disputes can only be resolved by appealing to utility.

Verified Expert

Utilitarianism is a doctrine worthy of swine is an objection that is based on very primitive and fundamental view towards the concept of utilitarianism, however Mills visualised in a different view point with consideration to the pleasure differentiation between high quality and low quality pleasures. Also indicated nobleness in seeking pleasure through actions with broader and ethical objectives. A discussion is made to reflect Mills response to the objection that the Utilitarianism is a doctrine worthy of swine.

Reference no: EM131118571

Questions Cloud

Describe how well article meets the criteria for causality : Based on your critique, do you agree with the author's conclusions? Does exposure to thimersol via vaccines cause adverse neurological outcomes?
Determining the single industry sector : Statistical analysis demonstrated that the challenges faced by marketers are universal and not specific to any single industry sector or company size. Give three challenges.
The major factors in the social environment : Identify and explain the major factors in the social environment that create an atmosphere in which business criticism takes place and prospers. How are the factors related to one another? Has the revolution of rising expectations run its course? ..
What is the distance to ht cas in light years : Which main sequence stars can be found with a surface temperature of between 3000K-4000K? Which stars have a luminosity about 100 times less than that of the Sun?
Objection to the critics of utilitarianism : what the motive is as long as what is done is done for the promotion of the general good. (2)You are free to benefit yourself as much as you want to as long as you don't interfere with the rights of others.
Determine the number of revolutions that the motor executes : When the power to an electric motor is turned on the motor reaches its rated speed of 2400 rpm in 4s, and when the power is turned off the motor coasts to rest in 40s.
What should be the length of a side in centimeters : What should be the length of a side, in centimeters? (Use the conversion 1 gallon = 3.786 liter.)
Candidates for an advertising and sales management : Create a list of three best practices recruiters should use when screening potential candidates for an advertising and sales management position. Support your selections.
Consider credit default swap of notional amount : Consider a credit default swap (CDS) of a notional amount $10 million and a term of one year. The CDS spread is 120 basis points and the payment is quarterly. If the bond has not defaulted, calculate the payment from B to A in the first quarter of th..

Reviews

Write a Review

Humanities Questions & Answers

  Plan to improve correctional facilities

Women imprisonment should be facilitate with certain correctional facilities. In this paper, we have discussed about the plan for improving correctional facilities for the women prisoner in America.

  Situation analysis of food security in new zealand

This paper aims to present, discuss and analyse factors that are causing low food security, the management, current and proposed solutions in New Zealand (NZ).

  Social services on human traffic

The research study is limited to the understanding of  how social service agencies could approach or respond to the needs of the victim/ survivor of sex trafficking.

  Social deviance: the issue of risky sexual behaviour

The issue of deviant behaviour has been discussed by various sociologists from a number of perspectives.

  Race and racism

This paper is a brief description of the study, discrimination pertains to the prejudice perception and treatment of a person or demographical issues belonging to a category.

  Depth of challenges people face

Your own knowledge about the Depth of Challenges People face

  Project plan written report

Sufficient information to enable the organisation's Board of Executives to understand the rationale for the program and the activities required to design, implement and evaluate the program including any additional data that would need to be colle..

  Evaluation structure logical and achievable.

Health care organisational processes management, service administration, service provision and delivery

  Write an essay on locke''s theory of meaning

Write an essay on Locke's theory of meaning

  Leadership reflections paper

Write a paper on Leadership Reflections Paper Summarizes and reflects upon leadership ideas gleaned from the four required readings

  What role has feminism played

what role has feminism played in our appreciation of their work today.

  What subject matter choices were available to women artists

Prior to the beginning of the twentieth century, what subject matter choices were available to women artists? What cultural and historical influences placed limitations on their choices?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd