Explain what can be done about the government contract

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM13850095 , Length:

Delish Pty Ltd (‘Delish') is a large private company which operates a family catering business across Western Australia and Northern Territory. Over the past 18 months, Delish's board of five directors (Mr and Mrs Turner, their daughter, their son and Richard Jones, a family friend) had discussed expanding their operations into Australia's southern and eastern states. To achieve this, the company needed to obtain finance (borrow money) from a bank to cover the costs of the expansion of the business and the necessary staff. However, at a board meeting in March 2015 the board decided (3-2 against) not to proceed with the expansion at that time, and to reconsider the matter next year. The daughter (Karen) and Jones were both very keen to expand the business and were very unhappy at the risk-averse decision of Mr and Mrs Turner and their son to block the plan. Karen took the business plan (for expansion) to a bank manager in Adelaide to see if a bank would be prepared to provide a loan. The bank manager was impressed with the business plan and told Karen that he would be prepared to recommend a loan to Delish to support the expansion. Excited, Karen convinced Jones to join her in co-signing both a loan agreement and a charge over all of Delish's assets and undertaking (business) to secure the loan of $7.5 million (these documents were signed in April 2015). Without the knowledge of the other three directors, Karen and Jones then arranged for the loan funds to be spent in setting up the company's new businesses in Adelaide and Melbourne. Unfortunately, just three months later most of the borrowed money had been spent but the businesses in Adelaide and Melbourne had been total failures.

At a board meeting in early August 2015, Karen and Jones finally told the other three directors what had happened. Yesterday the bank formally wrote to the company (a letter was sent to Delish's registered office in Darwin) seeking total repayment of the loan which was in default (repayments which fell due in June and JulyMarch and April 2015 were not paid and so the bank was contractually entitled to demand or ‘call up' the entire loan). If the loan is not repaid within two weeks, the bank will enforce its charge to recover the loan. The three directors who never approved of the expansion plans (nor the loan) have today co-signed a letter for and on behalf of the company to the bank, stating that Delish is not liable to repay the loan and that the charge is void because the company never approved of the transactions. The directors are all of the view that if Delish is liable to repay the bank loan, then the company is unable to meet all of its debts as and when they become due and payable.

Jones is not only a director but also a shareholder with 20,000 shares in Delish. The other 80,000 shares in Delish are owned by various people associated with the Turner family. Jones has just become aware that in April 2015 Mr Turner (Delish's Managing Director) convinced a long-standing client of Delish (a government department) to engage another caterer, Rapacity Caterers Pty Ltd (‘Rapacity') to provide catering for a large expo event. Jones understands that this large catering contract is worth almost $500,000. Mr Turner's close personal friend is the managing director of Rapacity and has recently had some hard times and difficulties with his business. Mr Turner wanted to do his friend a good turn and therefore told a ‘white lie' to the government client, saying that Delish was too busy to do the job but that Rapacity was an excellent alternative. (Rapacity did end up getting the contract.) Rapacity's managing director offered Mr Turner a 5% ‘kickback' payment for the referral but Mr Turner refused, saying that he just wanted to do a favour for a good friend and would not accept any personal gain.

(a) Is Delish bound by the loan agreement and charge which Karen and Jones have signed? If more information would be required to provide a complete answer, state what that information is and why it would be relevant. If Delish was liable to repay the loan, describe what the directors should do and how the bank could enforce its rights and interests.

(b) Explain what can be done about the government contract which Mr Turner referred to Rapacity. In your answer focus on who might be aggrieved by what has happened and just who has (or who might have) the legal right to do something about it.

Verified Expert

Reference no: EM13850095

Previous Q& A

  About profitability ratios

Decision makers and analysts look deeply into profitability ratios to identify trends in a company’s profitability. Profitability ratios give insights into both the survivability of a company and the benefits that shareholders receive

  Explain definition of a solid waste and a hazardous waste

Describe the definition of a solid waste and a hazardous waste as defined in RCRA. Give an example of a gaseous waste that qualifies as both a solid waste and as a hazardous waste under RCRA. Give an example of a liquid waste that qualifies as bot..

  Critically evaluate the importance of individual motivation

Critically evaluate the importance of one of the following within contemporary organizations: Individual motivation, Leadership and Managing change.

  Considered a financially leveraged firm

Which of the following is considered a financially leveraged firm?

  Ratios that focus on the proportion of total assets

Ratios that focus on the proportion of total assets financed by a firm’s creditors is referred to as: The U.S. tax structure influences a firm’s willingness to finance with debt. The tax structure____________ more debt

  What is the current stock price

Pasqually Mineral Water, Inc., will pay a quarterly dividend per share of $1.20 at the end of each of the next 12 quarters. Thereafter, the dividend will grow at a quarterly rate of 1.8 percent, forever. The appropriate rate of return on the stock is..

  Explain the nature and scope of organizational culture

A clear understanding of the nature and scope of organizational culture. A clear understanding of the main defining elements of organizational culture.

  About the leveraging effect

Which of the following is true about the leveraging effect?

  Write article microorganisms and nutrients

Write a two page paper in which you summarize and reflect on this very important article that was one of the first to point out the magnitude of nutrients stored in microorganisms.

  Results of changes in the exchange rate

Early in September 1983, it took 260 Japanese yen to equal $1. Nearly 28 years later, in August 2011, that exchange rate had fallen to 110 yen to $1. What would the dollar price of the automobile be in August 2011, again assuming that the car's price..


Write a Review


Similar Q& A

  Big sneaker multinational company has an asian manufacturing

Big Sneaker Multinational Company has an Asian manufacturing facility which would be regarded as a "sweat-shop," where young, teen-age girls are exploited, working for poor wages and with minimal safety precautions, as well as some of the girls being..

  Summarize the key ethical as well legal issues in this case

Summarize the key ethical as well as legal issues in this case. Which elements of the ACHE code of ethics would help you, as an administrator involved in this case, determine the right course of action to take? Explain why you think so

  All of the following are department of justice points

1. what validity problems did the 2009 national survey on drug use and health data have as regards its finding on

  What are the limits of the powers of the state governments

What are the limits of the powers of the state governments to make laws?how is your answer affected by your understanding of the supremacy clause and why do you think the framers of the constitution placed these limitation?provide some examples of..

  Arguments for and against corporate social responsibility

Explain the arguments for and against corporate social responsibility, Discuss the challenges faced by a government in the implementation of corporate social responsibility policy

  Sex offenders in the department of corrections

Currently, sex offenders in the Department of Corrections (DOC) volunteer for the sex offender treatment program. In a 2 page paper, using APA style formatting, should convicted sex offenders, be mandated to participate in a treatment program

  Discuss the legal and ethical issues surrounding solyndra

Discuss the legal and ethical issues surrounding Solyndra, the California based solar panel manufacturer

  Explain law of diminishing returns

Explain Law of Diminishing Returns- Does Practice Make Perfect and Through my reading I found that The Law of Diminishing Returns says that continuous practice creates continuous improvement

  Filing case against transport department

Following a yearlong humanitarian trip to Another Country, Rock Star Big Bad Bruce, planned to return to his home in the USA to announce his run for political office.

  Do you believe the social standing race and age of

to obtain the most possible credit for the weeks participation on the discussion board you must answer all questions

  Direct impact on ethical issues in field of criminal justice

You are to read an article, newspaper, magazine, or other material that has a direct impact on ethical issues in the field of criminal justice

  Why innocent individuals are wrongly convicted

Describe eight (8) reasons why innocent individuals are wrongly convicted. Provide one (1) example of each of the reasons why innocent individuals are wrongly convicted

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd